Minutes of the Graduate Committee, March 3, 2024
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Ave M/S UL34
Fresno, California 93740-8014
Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743
March 3, 2024
Member Present: M. López (Chair), J. Goto (ex officio), D. Lent, N. Mahalik, L. Diala,
S. Hernández
Members Excused: M. Crawford, A. Hoskins
Guests: I. Basurto, H. Hoesley
The meeting was called to order at 2:02 p.m. by Chair López.
I. MSC to approve the minutes from February 20, 2024
II. MSC to approve the agenda for March 5, 2024
III. Communication and Announcements
● M. López
➔ Met the Executive Committee (EC) of the Academic Senate on the 2
nd
reading of
APM 311 (Policy on Teaching Associates). Reviewed the proposed change re:
language on FAFSA. The EC voted to move it to the Senate agenda.
➔ APM 220 (Policy, Procedures, and Guidelines for the Periodic Review of Academic
Programs) was discussed in the Senate meeting on 3.4.2024. Tabled to the next
meeting.
➔ APM 206 (Policies and Procedures on Technology-Mediated Courses and
Programs) is being updated to come up with more robust guidelines on digital
education. The redline version that the ad hoc committee has drafted remains
under discussion. Chair AP&P wanted more research on it.
➔ Kremen has requested that the UGC reconsider APM 226, which requires
members of Graduate Faculty Groups be tenure track or tenured. Chair Lopez will
schedule for a future meeting.
IV. MA in Early Childhood Education (ECE)
➔ The Committee discussed the proposal for an MA in ECE online option from the
Department of Literacy, Early, Bilingual, and Special Education. The visitors
responded to the concerns and questions (italics) that the members asked.
➔ Questions and responses:
Please clarify the impact of offering the courses in both face-to-face and online
options as there can be a great deal of overlapping (López).
There are no concerns in this regard. Our program is the only nationally accredited
program in CA and we manage and maintain the standard. There is no impact on
other programs as well.
How will the program differentiate in terms of application procedure? (López)
The admission and option requirements will be clear in the program description.
Online application will make students select one of the two options. The graduate
coordinator will confirm with applicants that they are applying to the correct option.
How would you achieve fieldwork in the online version of the program? How do you
handle it? Is it a prereq? (Lent)
The course LEE 241 meets the requirements, and it is different from the traditional
approach. For example, we engage the students to gain inquiry experiences within
the community in a classroom setting. The instructor does not go to the field in
person. We handle it remotely and the instructor provides classroom-based
experience to the students. We use case-based video recordings. It is not a prereq.
Do you admit students from out of the state? How about international applicants?
(Lent and Mahalik)
We focus on in-state applicants, as we value localized learning and will continue
to do
so. One of our faculty members has a professional connection with China and other
parts. Mainly we receive queries from the central, north, and south valleys.
Tell us about the sustainability of the program considering faculty numbers and
continued enrollment. How can you give a guarantee to offer enough courses to both
programs side-by-side? (López)
Faculty capacity is okay. We have great faculty members. Two new TT hires. Five
full-time faculty. Additional faculty members from Early Literacy also support the
program. The program has a solid team of people, including the lecturers who would
support as part of the instructional team.
The possible impact is that students in face-to-face options have limits to enrolling
in
online courses. How would you deal with the availability of the courses? (López)
We understand this. Although we consider cohort-based teaching, our approach is
that we look at the advising sheet of the students. In the past, we had a similar
situation but had no issues. (Visitor Basurto) We will be happy to receive any
additional suggestions and recommendations from the UGC in this respect.
Is the program’s Culminating Experience mostly a Comprehensive Exam? (Lent)
Even with five faculty, how would you manage Projects/Theses? (López)
Yes. The enrollment has decreased from 74 to 24 recently. We are working on
increasing the enrollment to a reasonable number. We will follow a graduate
enrollment strategy not to over-admit. For this, we will work closely with the
Department and College (Basurto).
It is understood that you did not make any curricular changes. How would you
proceed with the option without curricular changes? (Hernández and Diala)
The program’s course contents are aligned with the NAEYC standards and we
maintain the standard. When the program review and accreditation processes are
over, we should be able to change the curriculum based on their recommendations.
➔ The members briefly discussed and revisited the justification section of the proposal,
and tabled the discussion to the next meeting. The concerns are (i) It is unclear
how well
they will be able to handle both options (face-to-face and online) even with planned
individual advising strategy (Diala); (ii) How will they ensure that students in the
face-to-face path will not exceed the online course-enrollment limitation (20%); (iii)
How
will it be feasible to offer courses in both modalities every semester.
The next UGC meeting will be at 2:00 p.m. on Tuesday, March 12, 2024, in TA 117.
V. MSC to adjourn at 3:01 p.m.
Agenda for February 20, 2024
I. Approval of minutes from March 5, 2024
II. Approval of agenda for March 12, 2024
III. Communications and Announcements
IV. Program Visit - Environmental Science - New Program Proposal
V. MA in ECE Discussion and Recommendation
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.