Minutes of the Writing Competency Subcommittee

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 North Barton, M/S ML 34
Fresno, California 93740-8014
Office of the Academic Senate
Ext. 8-2743

April 28, 2022

Zoom: https://fresnostate.zoom.us/j/2984108197

Attending: Jenny Krichevsky, Amanda Dinscore, Jacquelin Curry, Lalita Oka, Aric Mine,
Jamie Levitt, Juliet Wahleithner (chair)

Missing: Maria Dolores Morillo, Bernadette Muscat (Ex-Officio), Nigel Vigan (Student)

Agenda:

  • Welcome
    • Approval of minutes from April 8, 2022
      • Moved: Jenny Krichevsky
      • Second: Amanda Discore
    • Approval of Agenda
      • Moved: Amanda Dinscore
      • Second: Aric Mine
  • WAC Updates from Jenny Krichevsky
    • Advertising for June STEM WAC retreat
      • 11 applications received + 2 additional expressed interest
      • Importance of having exemplar syllabi from STEM majors to share
        with faculty
    • In May, will ask Provost’s Office for budget for 2022-2023
      • One course release allows time for consultations plus 1-2
        workshops/semester
      • Currently has course release for FLC for Fall
        • Focus will be developing critical thinking through writing
          • Deliverable: either W course syllabus OR
            significant changes—including writing sequence—to
            an existing syllabus
      • Lalita: Wondered about seeking NSF funding to focus on writing in
        engineering
  • Graduation Writing Assessment Requirement
    • Updated CSU Policy
      • Jenny shared memo from CSU AVP that indicates requirement will
        be waived for students if campuses do not have enough courses
        available, but no specific end date is listed
      • Second bullet point indicates one 3-unit course: Engineering had
        idea to spread three units across one academic year
        • Not ideal, BUT given choice between no writing course
          (because high-unit, impacted major) and stretched out
          course, stretched-out course is preferable
          • also allows to not lose content that is necessary in
            existing courses
          • Importance of flexibility in high-unit majors
    • Fresno State’s Letter of Support
      • Still needed?
        • Yes–still need to remind policymakers of importance of
          discipline-specific writing courses in order to appropriately
          prepare graduates for future professions
  • TurnItIn–Amanda Dinscore
    • Background
      • Science professor who assigned students to use TurnItIn and
        receive less than 7% score
        • Students turned to Amanda with concerns who were
          unable to meet minimum
        • TurnItIn highlighted commonly-used phrases, scientific
          terminology
        • Led to students shifting language in awkward ways to try to
          reduce scores
        • Amanda’s analysis showed ACTUAL plagiarism from
          scholarly articles but no real plagiarism from student
          papers; TurnItIn’s database does not include scholarly
          articles, only student papers
      • CSU pays for system-wide subscription
    • Resources:
    • Business Protocol
      • Require students to submit papers through Canvas screening
    • Response Possibilities
      • Committee Statement?
        • What is our goal?
          • Encourage people to not use TurnItIn
            • Develop their understanding of the
              problematic nature of TurnItIn
          • Educate people in how to use it effectively if will
            use it
        • Could students do something to complain to the chair? Or take it
          to the ASI?
  • Future work
    • Need to get back to W-course audits–focus for 2022-2023?
      • Concerns: Courses don’t align with APM
      • Specific course concern: Dinosaurs class
  • Announcements
    • May 5, 4-6 Library Write-In for students
  • Adjourned at 12:07

Next Meeting: May 5, 11-12

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.