March 3, 2011
TO: Michael Caldwell, Chair
Executive Committee of the Academic Senate
FROM: Fred Schreiber, Chair
Academic Policy & Planning
RE: (APM 220) Policy on the Procedures and Guidelines for the Periodic Review of Academic Programs
APM 220 was forwarded by AP&P last fall to the Executive Committee. The Executive Committee referred it back to AP&P with a request to conform two parts to APM 214. Attached is a track-changes document, “APM 220 Revised,” showing all of the changes being proposed to APM 220. Changes made in response to the Executive Committee are found on page 7.
The “Revised Last Change Only” document isolates the change from all other changes. APM 214 notes that:
“A call for a program discontinuation review will be issued by the Provost and Vice President for Academic Affairs (Provost) when, as a result of periodic program review, the Undergraduate Academic Program Review Subcommittee recommends to the Provost that a program be reviewed for possible discontinuation.”
The proposed change conforms the language to this. The second change recommended by the Executive Committee does not seem to be relevant. The two review processes—program review and discontinuation review—are distinct and need not have the same criteria.
Attachment
POLICY ON THE REVIEW OF ACADEMIC PROGRAMS
This packet provides the materials needed to conduct an effective academic program review. It includes:
• Program Review Policy
• Checklist for Program Reviews
• Timeline and Procedures
• Program Review Self-Study
• Site Visit and Report by a Panel of External Evaluators
• Sample Site Visit Schedules
• Description of Site Visit Sessions
• Outline for the Review Team Report
• Responses to the Review Panel’s Report
• University Senate Committee Review
• The Action Plan
• Self-Study Template
• Review Team Report Template
• Action Plan Templates
• Institutional Research, Assessment, and Planning Dataset
This document describes the academic program-review process. The review process for accredited programs will differ slightly because the schedule will be dictated by the accrediting agency. Once the accreditation visit and report have been completed, the remaining process is the same.
CHECKLIST FOR PROGRAM REVIEWS
Academic Unit
• Select a self-study coordinator in October.
• Attend the orientation meeting in October.
• Complete the self-study between October and April.
• Suggest external and on-campus reviewers in April.
• Work with the review officers to schedule the review-team visit in May.
• Revise the self-study in August or September.
• Supervise the site visitors during the September visit.
• Schedule a faculty meeting to discuss the review and prepare a response in October.
• Forward the response to the review officers between October and November.
• Attend the Senate committee meeting between November and February.
• Develop the action plan between February and April.
• Attend the planning and implementation session in May.
• Revise the action plan in May.
Academic Dean
• Attend the orientation meeting, optionally, in October.
• Work with the department in preparing the self-study between October and April.
• Receive and review the self-study in May.
• Meet with the review panel in September.
• Read the review panel’s report in October.
• Forward a response to the review officers between October and November.
• Review the proposed action plan in April.
• Attend the planning and implementation session between April and May.
Review Officers
• Notify the unit about the review in May of the preceding year.
• Consult with chairs to appoint self-study coordinators in May of the preceding year.
• Conduct an orientation session in October.
• Support the development of the self-study between October and April.
• Select the program-review panel in April.
• Arrange the review panel’s schedule with the unit in May.
• Review, process, and distribute the self-study between May and August.
• Conduct entrance and exit interviews with the review team in September.
• Obtain and distribute the review panel’s report in October.
• Schedule the committee review in November.
• Schedule the planning and implementation meeting in April.
• Coordinate the final record of the program review in May.
TIMELINE AND PROCEDURES
Notification of the Review
In May of the academic year before the review, the review officer will notify the
chair of the academic department and the appropriate dean that a review has been scheduled.
Designation of the Self-Study Coordinator
In May of the preceding year, the chair of the academic department will notify the
review officer and appropriate dean of the name of the self-study coordinator.
Self-Study Orientation Meeting
In October, the review officers will schedule a meeting for all departments participating
in a self-study.
Participants will include the department chair, self-study coordinators, school or college dean, and other department faculty members requested by the department chair.
Preparation of the Self-Study
Between October and April, all program faculty members should participate in preparing
the self-study. Deans and review officers should be consulted throughout the preparation
of the report, which addresses the program’s current status and future development.
If the department undergoing review offers multiple degrees, each degree should have a separate self-study, although multiple reports may use a common set of supporting materials.
Toward the end of the process, a draft of each self-study should be distributed to all program faculty members for comments and suggestions. Their responses should be considered when preparing the final draft.
Selection of External and On-Campus Consultants
In April, departments will suggest reviewers to the dean and review officers. The
review officers will promptly notify the chair, coordinator, and selected team members.
Submission of the Self-Study
The department should submit the self-study to the college or school dean no later
than April 25.
The dean will review the program’s self-study. If the dean has concerns, the dean should work with the department to address them.
When satisfied with the self-study’s quality and content, the dean will forward it, together with a memorandum of approval, to the review officers no later than May 15.
The review officers will review the self-study for conformity with University guidelines and requirements. Requests for necessary changes will be sent to the department no later than August 15.
Site Visit
The review officers will work with the department in May to schedule the review-team
site visit.
The department will provide the review team with an office, computer, printer, and space for scheduled meetings with various groups.
The unit is responsible for arranging:
• Tours of its facilities
• A tour of the library
• Time to review course syllabi and student work, including randomly selected theses
• Meetings with faculty, students, and alumni, as appropriate
The site visit should conclude with an exit meeting scheduled by the review officers.
Participants will include the associate provost, school or college dean, graduate dean as appropriate, dean of undergraduate studies as appropriate, department chair, and graduate program coordinator as appropriate.
Site Visitors’ Report
The review team’s report should be completed before the external consultant departs.
If necessary, the report may remain in draft form at that time, subject to final review
by the team members, but it should be complete in scope.
As appropriate, separate reports should be prepared for undergraduate and graduate programs.
The reports will be delivered to the review officers and distributed to the college or school dean and the department through the chair and coordinator.
The department will have one week following the visit to prepare the chair’s response to the team’s report.
The dean will have one week after receiving the chair’s response to prepare a response to both the team’s report and the chair’s response.
The responses, team reports, and self-study will be distributed to the Undergraduate Academic Program Review Subcommittee and/or the Graduate Committee.
Committee Review
Between October and March, the campus program-review committees will examine the submitted
reports, interview representatives of the program and administration as appropriate,
and respond to the report, particularly the review team’s recommendations.
The committees should also comment on the department’s outcomes-assessment process and five-year assessment plan.
The committee report should be completed no later than one month after receipt of the materials and delivered to the review officers.
Planning and Implementation Meeting
Between February and May, the department chair and/or program coordinator will draft
a response to the recommendations of the review committees and site team and prepare
a brief draft action plan.
The department chair and/or program coordinator will forward the draft action plan to the college or school dean and the Provost two weeks before the planning and implementation meeting.
The review officers will schedule the meeting to consider all recommendations and comments.
Participants will include the chair, program coordinator, college or school dean, associate provost, and Provost. A representative of the review committees may also attend if requested by the department.
During the meeting, the college or school dean and the Provost may propose elements for the action plan.
An agreed-upon action plan will be developed that identifies the necessary actions and responsibilities.
PROGRAM-REVIEW SELF-STUDY
After receiving notification of a scheduled review, programs may begin assembling the information to be incorporated into the self-study.
A self-study coordinator selected from the department faculty should oversee the preparation of the self-study. When a department is undergoing both a graduate and an undergraduate program review, separate self-study coordinators should be selected.
All program faculty members should participate in preparing the self-study and be consulted before the final draft is prepared.
Because the department chair is responsible for the content, accuracy, and completeness of the self-study, the chair should continually and actively oversee its preparation.
The self-study coordinator is responsible for meeting periodically with the college or school dean to review progress, share the developing content, and report the dean’s comments and recommendations to the department faculty.
The self-study is a comprehensive written report prepared by the academic program scheduled for review.
Self-studies must be prepared using the Program Review Self-Study Template and submitted electronically. The self-study report should not exceed 20 pages, excluding appendices.
For accredited programs, the self-study consists of the report prepared for the accrediting body, supplemented by a revised Student Learning Outcomes Assessment Plan.
If the department undergoing review offers multiple degrees, each degree must be included in the self-study.
If only a portion or option of the degree program is accredited, a complete self-study is required for the non-accredited program or options.
Institutional Research, Assessment, and Planning and the program-review officers will provide a standard dataset to be included in the self-study and offer technical assistance in updating assessment plans and planning and evaluating surveys.
The review officers can provide guidance and answer questions regarding the program-review process.
The self-study examines the current status of the academic program based on its activities and achievements since the previous review.
The document should identify:
• Strengths and weaknesses in curriculum and instruction
• Student performance
• Student Learning Outcomes activities conducted since the previous review
• A Student Outcomes Assessment Plan for the period until the next review
• Faculty contributions in teaching, research, creative activities, and service
• Resource availability and needs
• Special features or services provided by the department
Most importantly, the self-study should serve as a vehicle through which the department, in conjunction with the University, can plan for the future.
It should include goals for program improvement, a plan for achieving those goals, and strategies for measuring progress.
The self-study should include mechanisms for solving current problems, avoiding projected problems, building upon existing strengths, and maximizing opportunities likely to develop within the discipline.
The allocation of resources is important to every program. However, if the self-study primarily becomes a budget request, the unit misses an opportunity to provide the Campus with information concerning its strengths, weaknesses, plans, and goals.
An unduly self-serving document also loses credibility. The report is likely to have the most favorable effect on readers when the unit uses the opportunity for creative thinking and planning.
The college or school dean will review the program’s self-study, provide comments to the self-study coordinator, and work with the department to address any concerns.
When satisfied with the self-study’s quality and content, the dean will forward it with a memorandum of approval to the review officers, normally no later than May 15.
The review officers will examine the self-study for conformity with University guidelines.
If the report does not meet University requirements, it will be returned to the program with a specified due date for changes.
When all required elements have been addressed, the review officer will notify the program to submit one hard copy and one electronic copy of the self-study.
Accredited programs should submit one hard copy and one electronic copy of the accreditation self-study, together with a revised Student Outcomes Assessment Plan.
SITE VISIT AND REPORT BY A PANEL OF EXTERNAL EVALUATORS
For non-accredited programs, the site visit will be conducted by a team of at least three consultants:
• An external expert in the discipline who has experience with student-outcomes assessment in that discipline
• A faculty member from within the department’s school or college
• A faculty member from the Campus but outside the department’s school or college
The department may elect to include a fourth team member representing alumni, community members, or other accreditation experts.
The department submits to the dean the names of two or three faculty members from the college or school who are not associated with the program and two or three faculty members from outside the college or school.
The department also completes an online form identifying two or three off-campus individuals who could serve as the external reviewer.
After the dean approves the proposed reviewers, the program-review officers contact the review-team members and schedule the visit.
The University provides a stipend to the off-campus disciplinary consultant. This person serves as chair of the review team.
The review officers and department will work together to schedule the site visit.
The department will provide the review team with an office, computer, printer, and space for scheduled meetings.
The unit is responsible for arranging:
• Tours of its facilities
• A library tour
• Time to review course syllabi and student work, including randomly selected theses, projects, or comprehensive examinations
• Meetings with faculty, students, and alumni, as appropriate
The site visit should conclude with an exit meeting involving the associate provost, school or college dean, program-review officers, department chair, and graduate program coordinator.
When only one program is being reviewed, the panel will complete its work in a single day. A two-day site visit is necessary when multiple programs, such as undergraduate and graduate programs, are being reviewed.
For accredited programs, the department will work with the accrediting agency to schedule the visit and notify the program-review officers as soon as the date has been selected.
DESCRIPTION OF SITE-VISIT SESSIONS
Meeting with Review Officers
One of the first meetings scheduled for the review panel will be with the review officers.
The purpose is to orient the site-visit team to the purpose of the visit and answer questions concerning the academic program review or the team’s role in the review.
Meetings with Students
Some of the most helpful meetings are those conducted with students. Students often raise questions for which the site visitors will want to seek answers, so these meetings should occur fairly early in the schedule.
Class visits also work well. After the reviewers have been introduced and the purpose of the visit explained, unit faculty members should leave so that students feel free to discuss issues.
Because undergraduate and graduate students may have different concerns, separate meetings should be arranged for each group. A substantial number of students should participate in each group.
Meetings with Faculty Members
Depending on the department’s size, two or three small-group meetings—or individual meetings, when possible—may be desirable so that most faculty members have an opportunity to express their opinions.
A small meeting should also be held with the faculty members who prepared the report and with the graduate advisory committee or other committees whose work relates to the program review.
The department chair should not attend faculty meetings.
Meetings with Department Chairs
At least one hour should be scheduled for the site visitors to meet with the department chair.
Because the site visitors will usually have questions arising from their conversations with students and faculty, time with the chair should be scheduled relatively late in the visit.
Meetings with University Administrators
Because the site visitors’ recommendations will affect planning by the unit and college, a meeting with the school or college dean is critical.
As part of the effort to incorporate review results into general University planning, meetings will also be scheduled with the associate provost and the Academic Affairs budget officer.
Review Panel’s Report
Time should be reserved during the site visit to allow the consultants to organize and begin drafting a report summarizing their evaluations and recommendations.
The off-campus disciplinary expert serves as organizer and primary author of the team report and is responsible for submitting it to the program-review officer.
A separate report should be prepared for every undergraduate and graduate program. Reports should be delivered electronically to the review officers and will then be distributed to the college or school dean and department.
Exit Meeting
The concluding exit meeting allows the site-visit team to communicate its key findings to the associate provost, review officers, college or school dean, department chair, self-study coordinator, and graduate program coordinator, when applicable.
OUTLINE FOR THE REVIEW TEAM REPORT
The content and length of the review panel’s report will vary depending on the nature and size of the program and the reviewers’ preferences.
Consultants are welcome to comment on any aspect of the program they consider important to program quality and future development.
It is often useful to begin the report with an overall view of the program and conclude with a summary and specific recommendations.
The reviewers should consider whether the program’s mission is clearly stated and whether its activities are consistent with that mission.
A separate report is required for each degree program being reviewed.
The most effective way to assist an academic unit is to make useful recommendations within the current budget.
If a major initiative is needed, corresponding reductions should be suggested.
It is also helpful to suggest what the unit might accomplish with a three-to-five-percent increase in funding or what might best be eliminated if funding decreases by three to five percent.
RESPONSES TO THE REVIEW PANEL’S REPORT
Within two weeks of receiving the review panel’s report, the department will provide a written response addressing the issues raised.
The response may also discuss significant changes or developments that have occurred since the self-study was submitted.
The department chair’s response must address each recommendation made by the review panel.
The departmental response will be submitted to the college or school dean and the review officers.
The dean should address the issues raised in both the review panel’s report and the chair’s response.
The dean’s response shall be submitted within one week to the chair and review officers and distributed to the department faculty for review.
For every specific issue, the response should identify:
The proposed action and expected outcome.
Cost and resource implications.
The source of funds or resources.
A benchmark and timeline for resolution.
The response may also identify and discuss other changes and developments that have
occurred in response to the site visitors’ report or since the self-study was submitted.
UNIVERSITY SENATE COMMITTEE REVIEW
The campus program-review committees will examine the review panel’s reports and the responses from the department and dean.
The committees may interview representatives of the program and administration as appropriate and provide recommendations based on the submitted reports.
They should also comment on the department’s outcomes-assessment process and updated Student Outcomes Assessment Plan.
The committee report should be completed within one or two months of receiving the materials and communicated to the department chair, with copies to the review officers and college or school dean.
The following categories may be used for committee recommendations:
Approve a Program for Continuation with Notation of Exceptional Quality
Approval is recommended without reservation and includes recognition of specific areas of program promise and excellence.
Programs recommended in this category may be considered for an award for program excellence.
These programs exhibit special strength in every aspect of the review process and reflect the best attributes of commitment, quality, and promise.
Approve a Program for Continuation
Program approval is recommended with identification of specific areas requiring further development and recognition of specific achievements.
These programs meet all evaluative measures of quality but could improve in substantial ways, such as developing a stronger student-recruitment plan or completing the implementation of learning-outcomes assessment.
Approve a Program for Conditional Continuation
Conditional approval is recommended with identification of specific areas requiring significant improvement, the conditions to be met, and a reasonable timeframe for achieving unconditional approval.
Conditional continuation is appropriate for a program that fails to meet expected quality standards when additional time or the implementation of planned actions could be expected to eliminate the deficiencies without impairing student progress.
Suspend a Program
Suspension may be recommended when the program received conditional continuation in its most recent review and:
The program fails to meet established standards of quality necessary to ensure an
appropriate academic experience for students.
Evidence indicates that the deficiencies may be corrected within a specified period.
Quality standards include, but are not limited to:
• A minimum critical number of faculty members
• A minimum critical number of students
• Adequate and sufficiently frequent required courses
• Adequate library holdings
• Appropriate physical facilities
A recommendation to suspend a program could lead to administrative action that:
Places a moratorium on new student admissions.
Requires that students currently enrolled be accommodated so that they may complete
the program.
Places a moratorium on the reappointment of faculty members to graduate-faculty status,
when applicable.
Removes the program’s catalog copy.
The degree title may remain on the trustee-approved Campus Academic Plan.
If evidence indicates that the program may be successfully reconstituted later, the conditions required to reopen it fully should be identified, along with a process for removing the suspension recommendation.
Discontinuation may result if the program cannot satisfy the conditions for successful reconstitution.
Discontinue a Program
Discontinuation may be recommended when the program received conditional continuation in its most recent review, fails to meet established quality standards necessary to ensure an appropriate academic experience, and shows no evidence that the deficiencies have been corrected within the specified period.
A recommendation to discontinue a program could lead to administrative action that:
Places a moratorium on new student admissions.
Requires that currently enrolled students be accommodated so that they may complete
the program.
Places a moratorium on the reappointment of faculty members to graduate-faculty status,
when applicable.
Removes the program’s catalog copy.
A separate review of the implications of program termination will then be conducted.
This second level of review follows University policy and includes an assessment of the effects that discontinuation would have on the University and its service area, faculty, facilities, students, and resources.
THE ACTION PLAN
Soon after the Senate review committees submit their recommendations, the department chair and/or program coordinator will draft an action plan in consultation with the dean.
The action plan is based upon:
• The department’s draft plan included in the self-study
• The review team’s report
• The Senate committees’ recommendations
The action plan includes a vision for the program and, for each action item:
The proposed action and expected outcome.
Cost and resource implications.
The source of funds or resources.
A timeline for completing the proposed action.
The action plan will be discussed at a Planning and Implementation Meeting called
by the Provost.
Participants will include the chair, college or school dean, review officers, and a representative of the site-visit team if requested by the department.
The purpose of the meeting is to prioritize the action plan and obtain commitments for any resources needed to achieve its high-priority goals.
The dean and Provost may propose additional action items.
The department may be asked to revise the action plan, and another meeting may be called if needed.
The finalized action plan will be signed by the chair, dean, program-review officer, and Provost.
Each year, the Department Chair’s Annual Report to the Provost will include a progress report addressing the items in the action plan.
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.