Zimbra

Fwd: Guiding Principles for APM 322 Departmental Policy


From: Michael Caldwell <mcaldwell@csufresno.edu>

Date: Fri, Mar 25, 2011 08:25 AM

Subject: Fwd: Guiding Principles for APM 322 Departmental Policy

To: Venita Baker <venitab@csufresno.edu>

Reply To: Michael Caldwell <mcaldwell@csufresno.edu>


From: "Paula Popma" <ppopma@csufresno.edu>

To: "Michael Caldwell" <mcaldwell@csufresno.edu>

Cc: "Ted West" <twest@csufresno.edu>, "Mamta Rawat" <mrawat@csufresno.edu>, "Paula Popma"
<ppopma@csufresno.edu>, "Julie Olson-Buchanan" <julieb@csufresno.edu>,
<smathi@csufresno.edu>, <mullol@csufresno.edu>
Sent: Thursday, March 24, 2011 5:04:37 PM
Subject: Guiding Principles for APM 322 Departmental Policy

Michael,

At its March 24, 2011 meeting, the Personnel Committee reviewed the document "Creating a
Departmental Policy on Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness". We made a couple of minor changes,
and also added a section "Preparation of an overall assessment of Teaching Performance" which
addresses what a department needs to do in regards to their overall assessment. We also added ratings,
and peer evaluations, the departments need to prepare an overall assessment, and we felt that should
be part of the guideline. Hopefully, it was just the last sentence in the Sample Departmental Policy.

Otherwise, we unanimously offer our support of the Guiding Principles, Sample Departmental Policy, and
Proctor Guidelines documents.

Paula


Paula J. Popma
Assoc. for Technical Services
Paden Library
Fresno State
5200 North Barton Ave MS L34
Fresno CA 93740
559-278-5749


Dr. Michael Caldwell
Chair, Department of Music
Chair, Academic Senate
California State University, Fresno
(559) 278-8763
mcaldwell@csufresno.edu

 

CREATING A DEPARTMENTAL POLICY ON ASSESSMENT OF TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS

Please carefully review APM 322 prior to discussing and implementing a Departmental Policy
on the Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness. Please keep in mind that the sample policy at the
end of this document includes the minimum required by APM 322 and the Collective
Bargaining Agreement. Departments may choose to enhance the requirements in APM 322;
however, Departments may not choose to decrease the minimum requirements. The
Departmental Policy should address: a) student ratings of instruction, and b) peer evaluations.


GUIDING PRINCIPLES

Student Ratings of Instruction


APM 322 - III.B

B. Student Ratings of Instruction

Each department or equivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the frequency
and scheduling of student ratings of instruction. Each faculty member shall have a minimum of two
evaluations rated by students annually.

Please be certain that your Departmental Policy specifies frequency and scheduling as well as
above.

Please include this statement: While the IDEA Short Form will be the standard paper instrument
for the faculty, faculty may elect to use either the Diagnostic Form or Online version.


APM 322 - VIII.

VIII. Preparation of an Overall Evaluation of Teaching Performance

For recommendations regarding personnel actions such as retention, tenure and promotion, five
year review, contract renewal of lecturers, and peer evaluation of courses, the statistical summary
of student ratings along with other appropriate information in the Open Personnel File shall be
assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching performance and effectiveness.

Please be certain that your departmental policy recognizes that patterns and trends are more
relevant than the ratings from a single course or more than one period.


Peer Evaluations


APM 322 - III.A

II. Peer Evaluation Forms and Student Rating Questionnaires

A. Each Department shall adopt peer evaluation forms that will assess course content,
instructional design, instructional delivery, and assessment methods. In the absence of a formally
adopted departmental form, the department shall use a university-wide template provided by the
Provost. Each department may adopt a protocol for face-to-face real time peer observations of
teaching where applicable. The results of these peer evaluations may be used both formally
and summatively.

APM 322 - III.A

III. Frequency of Implementation
A. Peer Evaluation Reports

1. Each department or equivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the
   frequency and scheduling of peer evaluation of courses. The following minimum frequency shall
   apply:

   a. For part-time temporary faculty, the first time a course is taught by the instructor and,
      thereafter, at least one section every other year of employment regardless of a break in
      service.

   b. For full-time temporary faculty, two sections each semester for the first year and two
      sections each academic year thereafter.

   c. For probationary faculty, two sections (to include as many different courses as
      possible) every semester.

   d. For tenured faculty, one section each academic year on a rotating basis such that
      during a five year period the maximum number of different courses is evaluated.

2. Additional peer evaluation reports may be requested by the instructor or required by the
   College/School Personnel Committee, Dean or Provost on a case by case basis.


APM 322 - VII.B.1

B. Reports

1. Using the departmentally approved form, a written report on the peer evaluation of a course
   shall be prepared by the evaluator. The report shall include a review of the relevant components
   listed in Section I of APM 322.


Preparation of an Overall Evaluation of Teaching Performance


APM 322 - VIII

For recommendations regarding personnel actions such as retention, tenure and promotion, five
year review, contract renewal of lecturers, and peer evaluation of courses, the statistical summary
of student ratings along with other appropriate information in the Open Personnel File shall be
assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching performance and effectiveness.

The preparation of the overall assessment of teaching effectiveness shall be conducted by a
review committee composed of faculty of appropriate rank. Probationary faculty may only
perform evaluations of temporary faculty. In general, tenured faculty shall be evaluated only by
other tenured faculty at a higher rank, except full professors who may evaluate faculty at any
rank.

The Department will follow the guidelines in APM 325, APM 327 and APM 328 when electing
committee selected to prepare the overall evaluation of teaching.

 

SAMPLE DEPARTMENTAL POLICY

APM 322 is the official policy on the Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness. This Departmental
policy is designed to further define requirements at the Departmental level as specified in APM
322.


STUDENT RATINGS OF INSTRUCTION

[BRACKETS INCLUDE SUGGESTED INFORMATION THAT MAY BE INCREASED]

Each faculty member shall have a minimum of TWO [sections] rated by students annually.

While the IDEA Short Form will be the standard paper instrument for the campus, faculty may
elect to use either the Diagnostic Form or Online version.

Student ratings of instruction shall be assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching
performance and effectiveness. It is expected that the faculty member shall score [3.00 out of 5.0]
or above using adjusted or unadjusted scores, whichever are higher, on a regular basis; however,
it is more important to evaluate on the basis of multi-year trends rather than focusing on a single
course or narrow time frame.


PEER EVALUATIONS
[BRACKETS INCLUDE SUGGESTED INFORMATION THAT MAY BE INCREASED]

1. Each department shall have a minimum of TWO [sections] rated by students annually.

   a. For part-time temporary faculty, the first time a course is taught by the instructor and,
      thereafter, at least [one section every other year of employment] regardless of a break
      in service.

   b. For full-time temporary faculty, [two sections each semester for the first year and
      two sections each academic year thereafter].

   c. For probationary faculty, [two sections (to include as many different courses as
      possible) every semester].

   d. For tenured faculty, [one section each academic year] on a rotating basis such that
      during a five year period the maximum number of different courses is evaluated.

2. Faculty will use the attached Departmentally approved form to evaluate Course Content,
   Instructional Design, Instructional Delivery and Assessment methods.

3. The evaluator may elect to perform a face-to-face real time peer observation as part of the peer
   evaluation upon the request of the faculty member being evaluated. [Departments may elect to
   require in-class observations, observations for certain types of classes or observations in
   all classes.]


OVERALL

The Department will follow the guidelines in APM 325, APM 327 and APM 328 when electing
committees selected to prepare the overall evaluation of teaching.

CREATING A DEPARTMENTAL POLICY ON ASSESSMENT OF TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS

Please carefully review APM 322 prior to discussing and implementing a Departmental Policy
on the Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness. Please keep in mind that the sample policy at the
end of this document includes the minimums required by APM 322 and the Collective
Bargaining Agreement. Departments may choose to enhance the requirements in APM 322;
however, Departments may not choose to decrease the minimum requirements. The
Departmental Policy should address: a) student ratings of instruction, and b) peer evaluations.


GUIDING PRINCIPLES

Student Ratings of Instruction


APM 322 - III.B

B. Student Ratings of Instruction

Each department or equivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the frequency
and scheduling of student ratings of instruction. Each faculty member shall have a minimum of
two sections rated by students annually.

Please be certain that your Departmental Policy specifies frequency and scheduling, as stated
above.

Please include this statement: While the IDEA Short Form will be the standard paper instrument
for the campus, faculty may elect to use either the Diagnostic Form or Online version.


APM 322 - VIII

VIII. Preparation of an Overall Evaluation of Teaching Performance

For recommendations regarding personnel actions such as retention, tenure and promotion, five
year review, contract renewal of lecturers, and peer evaluation of courses, the statistical summary
of student ratings along with other appropriate information in the Open Personnel File shall be
assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching performance and effectiveness.

Please be certain that your departmental policy recognizes that patterns and trends are more
relevant than the ratings from a single course or narrow time period.

Peer Evaluations


APM 322 - III.A

II. Peer Evaluation Forms and Student Rating Questionnaires

A. Each Department shall adopt peer evaluation forms that will assess course content,
instructional design, instructional delivery, and assessment methods. In the absence of a formally
adopted departmental form, the department shall use a university-wide template provided by the
Provost. Each department may adopt a protocol for face-to-face real time peer observations of
teaching where applicable. The results of these peer evaluations may be used both formally
and summatively.


APM 322 - III.A

III. Frequency of Implementation

A. Peer Evaluation Reports

1. Each department or equivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the
frequency and scheduling of peer evaluation of courses. The following minimum frequency shall
apply:

   a. For part-time temporary faculty, the first time a course is taught by the instructor and,
      thereafter, at least one section every other year of employment regardless of a break in
      service.

   b. For full-time temporary faculty, two sections each semester for the first year and two
      sections each academic year thereafter.

   c. For probationary faculty, two sections (to include as many different courses as
      possible) every semester.

   d. For tenured faculty, one section each academic year, on a rotating basis such that
      during a five year period the maximum number of different courses is evaluated.

2. Additional peer evaluation reports may be requested by the instructor or required by the
College/School Personnel Committee, Dean or Provost on a case by case basis.


APM 322 - VI.B.1

B. Reports

1. Using the departmentally approved form, a written report on the peer evaluation of a course
shall be prepared by the evaluator. The report shall include a review of the relevant components
listed in Section I of APM 322.


Preparation of an Overall Evaluation of Teaching Performance


APM 322 - VIII

For recommendations regarding personnel actions such as retention, tenure and promotion, five
year review, contract renewal of lecturers, and peer evaluation of courses, the statistical summary
of student ratings along with other appropriate information in the Open Personnel File shall be
assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching performance and effectiveness.

The preparation of the overall assessment of teaching effectiveness shall be conducted by a
review committee composed of faculty of appropriate rank. Probationary faculty may only
perform evaluations of temporary faculty. In general, tenured faculty shall be evaluated only by

 

SAMPLE DEPARTMENTAL POLICY

APM 322 is the official policy on the Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness. This Departmental
policy is designed to further define requirements at the Departmental level as specified in APM
322.


STUDENT RATINGS OF INSTRUCTION
[BRACKETS INCLUDE SUGGESTED INFORMATION THAT MAY BE INCREASED]

Each faculty member shall have a minimum of two [sections] rated by students annually.

While the IDEA Short Form will be the standard paper instrument for the campus, faculty may
elect to use either the Diagnostic Form or Online version.

Student ratings of instruction shall be assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching
performance and effectiveness. It is expected that the faculty member shall score [3.00 out of 5.0]
or above using adjusted or unadjusted scores, whichever are higher, on a regular basis; however,
it is more important to evaluate on the basis of multi-year trends rather than focusing on a single
course or narrow time frame.


PEER EVALUATIONS
[BRACKETS INCLUDE SUGGESTED INFORMATION THAT MAY BE INCREASED]

1. Frequency

a. For part-time temporary faculty, the first time a course is taught by the instructor and,
   thereafter, at least one section every other year of employment regardless of a break
   in service.

b. For full-time temporary faculty, two sections each semester for the first year and
   two sections each academic year thereafter.

c. For probationary faculty, two sections (to include as many different courses as
   possible) every semester.

d. For tenured faculty, one section each academic year on a rotating basis such that
   during a five year period the maximum number of different courses is evaluated.

2. Faculty will use the attached Departmentally approved form to evaluate Course Content,
   Instructional Design, Instructional Delivery and Assessment methods.

3. The evaluator may elect to perform a face-to-face real time peer observation as part of the peer
   evaluation upon the request of the faculty member being evaluated. [Departments may elect to
   require in-class observations, observations for certain types of classes or observations in
   all classes.]


OVERALL

The Department will follow the guidelines in APM 325, APM 327 and APM 328 when electing
committees selected to prepare the overall evaluation of teaching.

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.