POLICY ON ASSESSMENT OF TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS
Teaching is central to the mission of the University and, therefore, its effectiveness must be assessed. The dual purpose of the assessment of teaching effectiveness is to provide the individual instructor with specific information to enhance instruction and to provide information for use in personnel actions. The primary responsibility for assessing all aspects of teaching effectiveness rests with the faculty.
This policy establishes the framework for the assessment of teaching effectiveness, including procedures for the two major components of the assessment:
The teaching effectiveness, should be taken to avoid bias based upon race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, marital status, pregnancy, age, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, veteran's status, sexual orientation.
I. The assessment of statistical data should always attempt to identify and focus upon patterns of performance rather than upon idiosyncratic responses.
Statistical data shall not be the only information considered in evaluating teaching effectiveness shall address at least threefour basic componentselements of instruction: subject matter, organization, and delivery.
II. Peer Visit Evaluation Forms and Student Evaluation Rating Questionnaires
A. The data from peer evaluations and student ratings shall be used in personnel decisions relating to retention, tenure and promotion.
B. Additional student ratings of courses may be requested by the instructor or required by the college/ school Personnel Committee, Dean or Provost.
III. Frequency of Implementation
A. Peer Evaluation Reports of Classroom Visits By Peers
1. Each department or schoolequivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the frequency and scheduling of classroom visits by peers.peer evaluation of courses. The following minimum frequency shall apply:
a. For part-time temporary faculty, the first time a course is taught by the instructor and, thereafter, at least one coursesection every other year of employment regardless of a break in service;.
b. For full-time temporary faculty, two coursessections each semester for the first year and two coursessections each academic year thereafter.
c. For probationary faculty, two classessections (to include as many different courses as possible) every semester.
d. For tenured faculty, one coursesection each academic year on a rotating basis such that during a five year period the maximum number of different courses is evaluated.
2. Additional classroom visits by peerspeer evaluation reports may be requested by the instructor or required by the College/School Personnel Committee, Dean or Vice President for Academic Affairs. Provost on a case by case basis.
B. Student EvaluationRatings of Instruction
1. Each department or school shouldequivalent unit shall establish a written policy which describes the frequency and scheduling of student evaluationratings of instruction. The following minimum frequency shall apply:
IV. Confidentiality
Information obtained from peer visitation evaluation reports and/or student evaluation rating questionnaires shall be confidential. Possession or use of this information shall be restricted to:
A. Thethe instructor, who may at his/her discretion, make such information available to others;
B. Thosethose charged with conducting evaluations or administering this policy;
C. Thosethose with access to the Open Personnel File.
V. Use and Housing of Student Ratings Data
A. Student ratings data shall not be used for any extraordinary purposes including, but not limited to, comparison of programs, departments, colleges, or any external entity or institution without the approval of the Academic Senate.
B. Data collected from the assessment of teaching effectiveness will be housed in the Offices of the Academic Senate on behalf of the Academic Assembly.
VI. Administration of Peer Evaluation Reports of Classroom Visits By Peers
A. Conducting Classroom Visits By PeersPeer Evaluation of Courses
1. Only tenured and probationary faculty shall conduct peer evaluations of courses. Probationary faculty may perform evaluations of temporary faculty only. Tenured faculty shall be evaluated only by peers. Althoughother tenured faculty at a higher rank, except full professors who may evaluate faculty at any rank. Tenured faculty being considered for promotion and participants in the Faculty Early Retirement Program may not participate in personnel committee actions. However, they may conduct classroom visitspeer evaluations of courses pursuant to this policy..
2. Prior to the peer evaluation, the evaluator(s) shall notify the faculty member of the materials that will be required for the evaluation. It is the responsibility of the faculty member to provide the materials to the evaluator. The materials shall include those designated on the peer evaluation form.
3. Evaluators shall not interview students before, during or after the class session. (Any information placed in the Open Personnel File must be identified by source.)peer evaluation.
B. Reports
1. Using the departmentally approved departmental or school formatform, a written report on each classroom visit shouldthe peer evaluation of a course shall be prepared by the evaluator. The report. The report should include specific classroom observations upon which the assessment is based and, minimally, reference should be made to subject matter, organization, and delivery (see above). shall include a review of the relevant components listed in Section I.
2. The peer evaluator(s) and the faculty member should discuss the visitevaluation prior to the submission of the written report to the department chair.
3. Each report shall be signed by the evaluator(s) and submitted to the department chair for placement by the Dean’s Office in the Open Personnel File after appropriately notifying the faculty member.
VII. Administration of Questionnaires for Student Ratings of Instruction
A. Administration of Student Rating Questionnaires
1. 1. QuestionnairesStudent rating questionnaires shall be proctored by a faculty member, student, or administrative assistant. The questionnaire may not be proctored by the instructor of record for the course.
2. The instructor being rated may not be present in the classroom during the administration of the questionnaire.
3. Proctor Responsibilities.
a. The proctor shall not interview students before, during, or after the class session.
b. The administration of the questionnaire shall occur during the last half of the scheduled term of instruction and shall be administered under the direction of the school dean. The dean will issue writtenduring the first fifteen minutes of class. Nothing besides a pencil and the rating form shall be handed out during the administration of the questionnaire.
4. Standardized instructions which identifyappropriate to the individuals whouniversity-wide rating questionnaire will administerbe provided by the student evaluations and the written and/or oralproctor. These standardized instructions to be given to the students. shall:
2. At a minimum, the instructions shall include:
a. a. Advising the inform students that the dual results will not be available to the instructor until after final grades have been submitted.
b. inform students of the purpose of the evaluations questionnaire, which is to enhance teaching effectiveness and to provide information for use in personnel actionsstaffing decisions including retention, tenure, and promotion (if any). );
c. inform students that the original or a copy of the original of the comments (if any) will be given to the instructor. ;
d. inform students that the evaluation results will not be made available to the instructor until after final grades have been turned in.
3. may not be present in the classroom during the administration of the questionnaire.
e. inform students that care should be taken to avoid bias based upon race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, marital status, age, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, veteran’s status, sex, and sexual orientation.
B. Analysis of Student EvaluationRating Data
1. Quantitative Results
a. A written interpretationstatistical summary of the quantitative results of the student evaluationratings shall be prepared by the departmentgenerated. This interpretationsummary shall be user-friendly. This summary shall be known as the Statistical Summary Report.
b. The instructor shouldshall receive a copy of the quantitative data and a copy of the Summary Report.statistical summary. In the interest of instructional improvement and fairness to retention/tenure/promotion candidates, these copies should be provided to the instructor as soon as possible after final grades are turned in. Candidates for retention/ tenure/ promotion should have priority over temporary and tenured faculty in the receipt of this information.
c. After final grades are turned in by the instructor, the Statistical Summary Report shall be placed in the Open Personnel File.
2. Open-Ended Student Comments
a. The instructor shall receive the original or a photoconjunction with student ratings. A copy of the original open-ended comments. (The copy of the Summary Report provided to the instructor will include the summary of the open-ended student comments.) shall be given to the department chair and the faculty member. The department chair shall not share the student comments with review committees. The department chair shall review the student comments in a timely fashion for evidence of gross violations of university policy.
b. In the interest of instructional improvement and fairness to retention/tenure/promotion candidates, these copies shouldshall be provided to the instructor as soon as possible after final grades are turned in. Candidates for retention/ tenure/ promotion should have priority over temporary and tenured faculty in the receipt of this information.submitted.
VIII. Preparation of an Overall Evaluation of Teaching Performance
For recommendations regarding personnel actions, the written reports of classroom visits by peers and the Summary Reports of student evaluations such as retention, tenure and promotion, five year review, contract renewal of lecturers, peer evaluation of courses and the statistical summary of student ratings along with other appropriate information in the Open Personnel File shall be assessed to identify patterns and trends of teaching performance and effectiveness. These assessments, at a minimum, shall include discussions of subject matter, organization, and delivery as outlined in Section I above.
VIIIThe preparation of the overall assessment of teaching effectiveness shall be conducted by a review committee composed of faculty of appropriate rank. Probationary faculty may only perform evaluations of temporary faculty. In general, tenured faculty shall be evaluated only by other tenured faculty at a higher rank, except full professors who may evaluate faculty at any rank.
IX. Summary of Needed Department/College Policy Decisions
In accord with the foregoing provisions, departments or schools should adopt questionnaires and forms for student evaluations and classroom visits by peers and/colleges shall develop written policies/ and procedures whichthat describe:
A. A. Thethe selection of additional items from the campus-wide pool of validated items.
B. the frequency (if the minimum described above is to be exceeded) and scheduling of student evaluations and classroom visits by peersratings.
C. E. Howhow faculty peers will be selected to prepare the Summary Reportsoverall evaluation of teaching.
D. the minimum standards for teaching effectiveness.
______________________________________________________
Approved by the Academic Senate April 15, 1991
Approved by the President May 6, 1991
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.