APM 323 Policy on Faculty Personnel Files


From: Paula Popma <ppopma@csufresno.edu>

Date: Thu, Sep 29, 2011 01:42 PM

Subject: APM 323 Policy on Faculty Personnel Files

To: Michael Caldwell <mcaldwell@csufresno.edu>

Cc:
Venita Baker <venitab@csufresno.edu>, Yoko Takahashi
<ytakahashi@csufresno.edu>, Anthony Hardig
<carandfor@csufresno.edu>, Virginia Rondor Hernandez
<virginiah@csufresno.edu>, Ted West
<twest@csufresno.edu>, Mamta Rawat
<mrawat@csufresno.edu>, Jp Narnlik
<cmmahl@csufresno.edu>


TO:       Michael Caldwell, Chair
          Academic Senate

FROM:     Paula J. Popma, Chair
          Personnel Committee

RE:       Policy on Faculty Personnel Files (APM 323)

DATE:     Sept. 29, 2011


The Personnel Committee has reviewed the Policy on Personnel Files (APM 323) in order to
bring it into alignment with the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) and current practice.
Attached are two copies of the policy, one with the tracked changes, the other with the changes
incorporated into the document.

The recommended changes are as follows:

1. Change the name from Open Personnel File (OPF) to Personnel Action File (PAF). The CBA and all
   other 22 CSU campuses use Personnel Action File.

2. Change the custodian of the PAF to the dean from the Provost. This reflects current practice.

3. Change the name from Retention, Tenure and Promotion File to Working Personnel Action File
   (WPAF) which aligns with wording in the CBA.

4. Make it clear that there is only one PAF for each faculty member (including part-time lecturers)
   and the appropriate dean is the custodian. This aligns practice with the CBA.

5. Change the name of the Correspondence/Working File to Private Administrative Files, and make it
   clear that these files do not contain any material located in the PAF, and cannot be used for personnel
   recommendation or action. Departments maintain an application pool file for part-time lecturers.
   This aligns practice with the CBA.

Please contact Paula Popma if you have any questions.

POLICY ON FACULTY PERSONNEL FILES

This policy outlines the various files maintained by the University on individual faculty members,
their purpose, and their use.


A. PERSONNEL ACTION FILE

1. The Personnel Action File (PAF) is the local equivalent of the Personnel Action File
   (PAF) as defined in Article 11 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement. An OPF
   and is maintained for every faculty employee, full-time or part-time. During the
   retention, tenure, or promotion review of a faculty member, the contents of the
   Working Personnel Action File (WPAF) formerly called the Retention, Tenure
   and Promotion (RTP) File is incorporated by reference into the PAF.

2. The PAF is the one (1) official personnel file for employment information that
   may be relevant to personnel recommendations or actions regarding a faculty
   member. Personnel recommendations relating to retention, tenure, promotion, or
   termination based upon work performance, or any other personnel action, shall be
   based on the OPF PAF. The Personnel Action File shall be maintained by the
   basis to directly related to the professional qualifications, or on work performance
   of the individual faculty member. Questions, those reasons shall be referred to
   writing and entered into the OPF PAF, and shall be immediately provided to the
   faculty member.

3. The school or college dean is the custodian of the PAF. The dean
   (Provost) is the custodian of all OPF's PAFs for faculty in his/her unit. However,
   the OPF for the individual faculty members is maintained in the office of the
   appropriate dean where it is available for the security of the file and its contents.

4. It is the policy of the California State University to maintain accurate and relevant
   personnel files.

5. The PAF is held in confidence and is accessible only to the affected faculty
   member and persons authorized in the conduct of official University business.

6. With the exception of secretaries performing clerical tasks, all instances of access to
   the PAF shall be logged and the log record shall be a permanent part of the
   file.

7. A faculty member may place any information in her/his own file which s/he feels is
   relevant to her/his employment status. A faculty member has the right to respond to
   or rebut any information which has been placed by another individual in her/his file.


8. The Provost (or designee) dean is the only university official who is authorized to
   place material in the OPF PAF. Such placement shall occur after the affected
   faculty member has been given a copy, without charge, of the material to be placed
   in the file (5 days prior to the placement of the material in the file). A copy of the
   notice shall be attached to the document being placed in the file. This provision
   does not apply to material referenced in the Temporary Suspension or Disciplinary
   Action Procedure of the Collective Bargaining agreement.

9. Upon request a faculty member shall be provided the opportunity to meet with the
   appropriate administrator regarding material to be placed in the file to which the
   faculty member objects. The request to meet shall be made within five (5) days of
   the receipt of the notification and shall be addressed to the appropriate administrator
   with a copy to the Provost. The meeting shall take place within ten (10) days of the
   request made by the faculty member. This provision shall not apply to material
   cleared for the periodic evaluation or performance reviews pursuant to Article 15
   Evaluation nor to material referenced in Article 17 Temporary Suspension or Article
   19 Disciplinary Action of the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

10. The appropriate administrator shall consider all information provided by the faculty
    member concerning the relevancy and accuracy of any material to be placed in the
    file prior to making a final decision to place material in the file. This provision shall
    not apply to material created for periodic evaluation or material referenced in Article
    17 Temporary Suspension or Article 19 Disciplinary Action of the Collective
    Bargaining Agreement.

11. Only material identified by source may be placed in the OPF PAF. Identification
    shall indicate the author, the committee, the campus office, or the name of the
    officially authorized body generating the material. References to unnamed sources
    or complaints are prohibited. Anonymous letters should be given to the individual
    faculty member concerned.

12. [Text moved to Section A.1]

13. Following receipt of a faculty member’s written request, the dean shall, within fourteen (14) days, provide a copy of all requested materials. Depending upon the amount of material copied, the faculty member may be required to bear the cost of duplicating such materials.

14. If, after examination of the OPF PAF a faculty member believes that any portion of his/her own file is inaccurate or irrelevant, she may submit a written request that the material be corrected or deleted from the file. Such requests should be directed to the Provost with a copy to the dean, as custodian of the file. The request should describe corrections and/or deletions that should be made, and the facts and reasons supporting such a request. In the event the request is denied, the request shall be attached to the disputed material and shall accompany the disputed material when used in a personnel recommendation or action.

15. If the request for correction or deletion is denied by the Provost dean, the faculty member has the right to submit a request to the President, or the President’s designee, no later than seven (7) days after the date of such a denial. Within twenty-one (21) days of receipt of such request, the President, or designee, shall provide a written response to the faculty member. If the President, or designee, grants the request, the record shall be corrected or deleted and the faculty member shall be sent a written notice to that effect. If the President, or designee, denies the request, the response shall include reason(s) for the denial.

16. The OPF PAF is maintained for each faculty member during the entire period of employment.

17. Files for individuals who have been separated from university employment are maintained in the colleges/schools for five (5) years.¹

18. Files of employees separated by reasons of (a) dismissal for cause, or (b) disability retirement, or (c) as the result of a written agreement between the university and the employee, are maintained indefinitely. In these instances, the files are maintained by Academic Personnel Services or the Office of the Chancellor, as appropriate.

B. WORKING PERSONNEL ACTION FILE

1. The Working Personnel Action File (WPAF), formerly called the Retention, Tenure and Promotion File (RTP File), is the local equivalent of the Working Personnel Action File as defined in Article 11.8 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

2. The RTP File WPAF is used during performance evaluations for retention, tenure and/or promotion and is considered as part of the OPF PAF.

3. The WPAF is held in confidence and is accessible only to the affected faculty member and persons authorized access in the conduct of official University business.

4. With the exception of secretaries performing clerical tasks, all instances of access to the WPAF shall be logged and the log record shall be a permanent part of the PAF.

5. Only material identified by source may be placed in the WPAF. This includes statements made by peer review committees as part of the review process. Identification shall indicate the author, the committee, the campus office, or the name of the officially authorized body generating the material. References to unnamed sources or complainants are prohibited.

6. Materials for evaluation submitted by a faculty member for use in the campus Retention, Tenure or Promotion (RTP) process shall be deemed incorporated by reference into the PAF, but need not be physically placed in the PAF. The inventory of items submitted by the faculty member for review during the RTP process shall be permanently placed in the PAF at the conclusion of the RTP process each year.

7. WPAFs are disassembled at the conclusion of each annual review process. Material listed on the inventory provided by the faculty member at the beginning of the process is returned to the faculty member. All other materials, including recommendations generated as part of the review, are returned to the PAF.¹

C. PRIVATE FILES

1. Department chairs, school deans and other academic administrators may maintain private files. These files may contain correspondence, notes of meetings or conversations, and other data. These working files may also contain copies of material contained in the PAF.

2. The contents of these private files may not be used as the basis of a personnel recommendation or action.

3. These private files are maintained at the discretion of the individual responsible for the file.

D. HANDLING OF FILES FOR PART-TIME LECTURERS

1. Departments may maintain two (2) distinct files on part-time lecturers: (a) the part-time lecturer application pool file and may maintain a working personnel file on all active part-time lecturers.

2. The part-time lecturer application pool file contains the position applications for all candidates for part-time positions. The application of each candidate for a part-time position is maintained in the file for five (5) years from the date of submission.

3. Access to the part-time lecturer application pool file is limited to persons authorized access in the conduct of university business. Individual applicants shall not have access to the part-time lecturer pool application file.

4. Departments shall court review the part-time lecturer application pool file prior to making nominations for part-time positions. Additionally, if an individual who has been previously employed by the University applies for a temporary position, whether full-time or part-time, the contents of the candidate's OPAF PAF shall also be considered.

5. Departments may maintain a working personnel file on part-time lecturers. This file shall only contain information which has been formally placed by reference into the part-time faculty member's OPF PAF. Appropriate notice shall be given to the faculty member regarding placement of material into this file. She shall be given a copy of the material to be placed in the file as well.

6. With the exception of secretaries performing clerical tasks, all instances of access to the working personnel file shall be logged and the log record shall be a permanent part of the file.

7. The working personnel file is to be held in confidence and is accessible only to the affected faculty member and persons authorized access in the conduct of official university business.

8. In all aspects, this working personnel file is to be considered a part of the OPF, especially with regard to the right of the part-time faculty member to respond to information placed in the file—or the right of part-time faculty member to seek the correction or deletion of material from the file.

E. MEDICAL AND POLICE RECORDS

Campus medical records and campus police records are not subject to the provisions for the OPF PAF. Content and access to these files is controlled by statutory regulation. However, any campus medical record or campus police record used as the basis for a personnel recommendation or action must be placed in the OPF PAF.

F. PRE-EMPLOYMENT FILE

1. The Pre-Employment File consists of the records involved in the hiring of the affected faculty member. The records include confidential papers received from placement bureaus, letters of recommendation, summaries of reference checks and other pre-employment information.

2. These files on full-time faculty members are maintained in the Office of Academic Personnel Services until the faculty member receives tenure or until five (5) years after separation from university employment, whichever comes first.

3. The affected faculty member shall not have access to this material.

G. SEARCH RECORDS

Records developed during a search process for faculty employees are maintained in the Office of the Dean for five (5) years after the close of the search. These records are not available to faculty members after the close of the search.

H. ACADEMIC PERSONNEL SERVICES — OFFICIAL RECORDS / EMPLOYMENT FILES

1. Academic Personnel Services maintains status records on each faculty member. These records include information on academic rank and salary, employment status, leaves, and other relevant information essential to personnel/payroll operations.

2. The information in these files is accessible only to the affected faculty member and persons authorized access in the conduct of official University business.

3. Requests to add or delete information from this file must be made, in writing, to the Provost with a copy to the Academic Personnel Officer. The request shall include the reasons for the requested addition/deletion to the file.

I. PAYROLL FILES

The Payroll Office maintains files on each University employee which include general payroll information and records such as tabulation of sick leave, vacation, leaves of absences, changes of employment status and similar items. Faculty members may review this information upon request.

REFERENCES: CBA Articles 11, 15, 17, 19

Approved by the Academic Senate        May 1968
Approved by the President              June 1968
Amended                                5/72; 10/83; 6/84; 3/95; 11/99
Amended                                October 25, 2011

 

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.