POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR ADDRESSING DISCRIMINATION, HARASSMENT, AND RETALIATION FOR UNIVERSITY FACULTY, STAFF & STUDENT ASSISTANTS
Introduction
California State University, Fresno (hereinafter referred to as the University)
strives to provide a place of work free of discrimination, harassment, retaliation
consistent with federal and state law and CSU policy. The University is firmly
committed to maintaining a working environment that is characterized by
integrity and ethical behavior. The University does not discriminate on the basis
of race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, age, sex, sexual orientation,
gender identity, marital status, mental or physical disability, mental disability,
or medical condition, nor will it tolerate unlawful acts of discrimination,
harassment or retaliation on the basis of employment. Discrimination, harassment,
and retaliation are contrary to the educational mission and behavioral
expectations of the University, such acts damage the careers, educational
experience and well-being of students, faculty and staff, undermine the respect
students and the community have for the University and tarnish the reputation of
the University as an institution of higher learning. Harassment is a form of
discriminatory behavior which will not be permitted or condoned and constitutes
unprofessional conduct. Where discrimination, harassment, or retaliation is found
to have occurred, the University will act to stop such misconduct, take
corrective measures to prevent its recurrence, and discipline those responsible.
In January 2006 the California State University (CSU) broadened the scope of
what was once the CSU's sexual harassment policy to one that prohibits unlawful
harassment based on any statutory category protected by the Fair Employment and
Housing Act (FEHA).
California State University, Fresno (hereinafter referred to as the University)
has adopted the CSU policy statement set forth in Executive Order 927 (attached
as Appendix A). Consistent with FEHA, Executive Order 927 protects employees
(including student assistants in the scope of university employment), applicants,
and independent contractors from unlawful harassment and retaliation. In
Executive Order 928 (attached as Appendix B), the CSU codified procedures for
employees to file a discrimination, harassment, or retaliation complaint. The
procedures set forth in Executive Order 928 apply to those employees who are not
eligible to file a complaint or grievance of discrimination, harassment, or
retaliation under a collective bargaining agreement or whose collective
bargaining agreement incorporates CSU systemwide complaint procedures for such
purposes. Employees who can file a complaint or grievance of discrimination or
harassment under an applicable collective bargaining agreement are directed to
file the complaint pursuant to such agreement.
Finally, in Executive Order 1046 (Appendix C), the CSU adopted a systemwide
policy providing students and applicants for admission a process for filing
complaints of discrimination, harassment and retaliation.
1. “Retaliation” means adverse action against an individual protected under
these guidelines that is taken by a University employee because the
individual has complained or opposed conduct which the individual reasonably
and in good faith believed was discrimination, harassment, or retaliation or
because the individual participated in an investigation or proceeding
related to discrimination, harassment, or retaliation.
2. “Retaliation” means adverse action against an individual protected under
these guidelines that is taken by a University employee because the individual
has complained or opposed conduct which the individual reasonably and in good
faith believed was discrimination, harassment, or retaliation or because the
individual participated in an investigation or proceeding related to
discrimination, harassment, or retaliation.
The following guidelines and procedures are intended to implement Executive
Orders 927, 928, and 1046 on the campus and within the jurisdiction of the
University. For any discrimination, harassment, or retaliation incidents
involving a university student as a possible victim, including students
participating in extended education courses and applicants for admission, please
refer to CSU Executive Order 1047. That order sets forth the procedures for
students to file complaints of discrimination, harassment or retaliation,
including sex discrimination or harassment, against the CSU, CSU employees,
other students, or any other participant in a University-related program or
activity. Executive Order 1047 is deemed to be complete on its face and
constitutes the sole process by which the University will resolve student
complaints of such unlawful acts.
The University strives to provide a place of both work and study free of
discrimination, harassment, intimidation or exploitation. Consistent with
federal and California State law and policy, California State University,
Fresno is firmly committed to maintaining a learning and working environment
that is characterized by integrity, ethical behavior, and respect for all
students and employees. Discrimination, harassment, and retaliation are
prohibited by law and CSU system policy, and are contrary to the educational
mission and behavioral expectations of the University. It damages the careers,
educational experience and well-being of students, faculty and staff, undermines
the respect students and the community have for the University, and tarnishes
the reputation of the University as an institution of higher learning.
Harassment is a form of discriminatory behavior which will not be permitted or
condoned and constitutes unprofessional conduct. Where discrimination,
harassment, or retaliation is found to have occurred, the University will act
to stop such misconduct, act to prevent its recurrence, and discipline those
responsible.
The policies below supersede all prior campus policies addressing discrimination,
sexual harassment, harassment, discrimination and retaliation as they relate to
faculty, staff, job applicants and independent contractors. Campus policies and
procedures for filing a complaint are provided to apply to complaints filed by:
Employees (including Student Assistants in the scope of University employment) in Section I.
Job Applicants and independent contractors in Section II.
Please note that where an incident of sex discrimination, sex harassment or
sexual violence is involved, the intake process for a complaint is different
from those complaints that involve other protected legal statuses listed above.
Additional information is provided in Section II pertaining specifically to
complaints regarding sexual discrimination, harassment or violence questions
that typically arise related to sexual harassment. Procedures for handling
complaints filed on campus are addressed in Section IV. Additional resources
and training information are contained in Section VI.
Communication of Procedures
This document and Executive Orders 927 and 928 and 1046 shall be made readily
available to all students, applicants for admission, and to all CSU-Fresno
State employees, utilizing multiple media of communication, including student
orientations, student catalogs, new employee orientation, the general catalog,
campus websites, and the offices of Student Affairs, Student Judicial Affairs,
and Human Resources and Faculty Affairs.
Confidentiality
The University recognizes the importance of confidentiality and will respect
the privacy of those reporting or accused of discrimination, harassment or
retaliation by keeping the matter confidential to the extent reasonably
possible. However, the University cannot guarantee confidentiality.
Confidentiality cannot be maintained when the University is required by law to
disclose information or when non-disclosure may harm the rights of others.
The psychotherapist-patient privilege ordinarily protects these communications
but this protection may not be recognized in federal court.
Section I. Employees
A. Policy
The applicable policy for employees is Executive Orders 927 and 928, or a
superseding policy if applicable. EO 927 is available as Appendix A or on the
web at:
http://www.calstate.edu/EO/EO-927.html
Procedures for filing complaints are found in Executive Order 928 (or
superseding policy, if applicable) for employees who are not eligible to file a
complaint or grievance of discrimination, harassment or retaliation under a
collective bargaining agreement. This document is in Appendix B and is available at:
http://www.calstate.edu/EO/EO-928.html
Employees who are covered by a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) should
refer to the appropriate CBA, available online at: http://www.calstate.edu/LaborRel/
B. Procedures for filing a complaint
1. Informal resolution of problems
The University is interested in resolving problems at the lowest level. This is
most likely accomplished when problems are reported early. The University
recognizes that any employee may be approached by coworkers, students seeking
advice in difficult circumstances, or third parties on behalf of someone else.
These individuals may be seeking information and not necessarily wanting to
file a complaint. If the faculty or staff member wants to keep the matter
confidential, the individual raising the concern should be reminded of the
on-campus confidential resources the University provides: the Employee
Assistance and Wellness Office, Lab School 186 (559-278-4357). Student
assistants seeking a confidential on-campus resource to discuss and may contact
Student Health & Psychological Services at the Health Center, (559) 278-2734.
Staff in both of these offices are trained to advise potential complainants on
conflict resolution skills, the complaint process and how they might proceed.
They also teach coping skills. These services are provided by licensed
counselors and certified consultants in a strictly confidential manner.
2. The complaint form
The complaint form is available at: http://www.calstate.edu/eo/eo-928.doc
This form may be used by those employees not eligible to file a complaint of
discrimination, harassment or retaliation under a collective bargaining
agreement as well as those employees whose CBA has incorporated the CSU
systemwide complaint procedures for such purposes.
3. Filing a complaint
Employees who believe they have been subjected to behavior that they consider
discrimination, harassment, or retaliation should report the behavior
immediately either orally or in writing. If the
Individual is not concerned with confidentiality, he or she may also wish to consult
with the dean,
associate dean, or director closest to the academic or work area. All of these managers
are trained to
respond to complaints of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation. Students, faculty,
staff, managers, or
other members of the campus community who believe they have been subjected to behavior
that they
consider discrimination, harassment, or retaliation should report the behavior immediately,
either orally or
in writing.
A list of those who can respond to concerns or complaints is provided in Appendix DC.
Employees represented by a collective bargaining agreement should refer to the appropriate
articles of
their agreement for instructions on how to file a complaint. In addition, the chief
stewards/faculty rights
representative of Units 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 11 may be consulted in those
cases where the
collective bargaining agreement provides a process for addressing complaints of discrimination,
harassment, and retaliation.
Employees not eligible to file a discrimination complaint or grievance under a collective
bargaining
agreement (including student assistants) who feel they were subjected to discrimination,
harassment or
retaliation in the course of their University employment, should contact their supervisor,
manager or
confidential employee resource through Executive Orders 927 and 928.
Complaints may be submitted as follows:
An employee with a workplace-related complaint against a staff member or manager or
any party other
than a faculty member may file a complaint with the Associate Vice President for Human
Resources by
contacting 559-278-2034, or by delivering or sending (via mail or fax) a copy of the
complaint form or
written statement to:
___Jannice A. Pearson
___Associate Vice President for Human Resources
___Joyal Administration Building Room 211
___Director, Human Resources
___California State University, Fresno
1610 North Maple Avenue M/S JA 41
Fresno, CA 93740
FAX: 669-278-7706
An employee with a complaint against a faculty member may file a complaint with the
Associate Vice
President for Academic Personnel/Faculty Affairs by contacting 559-278-3027, or by
delivering or sending
(via mail or fax) a copy of the complaint form or written statement to:
[Address information continues on the following page.]
Collective bargaining agreements are available on the CSU website:
http://www.calstate.edu/LaborRel/collectivebargaining.shtml
Investigations, unless an agreement or complaint does not involve allegations of sexual
discrimination,
harassment or violence, and unless otherwise provided, shall be conducted by representatives
of reviewing
departments consistent with the rules established by the President in his directive
of September, 2009.
Complaints of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation involving students will be
referred to the Dean of
Students.
Cases involving campus administrators will be referred to the appropriate Vice President,
the President,
or the Chancellor's Office. In cases alleging harassment by an administrator, the
Vice President for Human
Resources is alleged, the complaint should be filed with the Vice President for Administration.
If the
allegation is against the President, it should be filed with the CSU Vice Chancellor
for Human Resources.
These offices can be reached as follows:
Ms. Cynthia Teniente-Matson
Vice President for Administration
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML56
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2034
Ms. Gail Brooks
Vice Chancellor for Human Resources
The California State University
Long Beach, California 90802
562-951-4400
Dr. Michael Caldwell
Associate Vice President for Academic Personnel/Faculty Affairs
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML56
Fresno, CA 93740
FAX: 669-278-8191
Vice Chancellor for Human Resources
The California State University
Long Beach, California 90802
562-951-4400
Ms. Cynthia Teniente-Matson
President
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML56
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2034
Dr. William A. Covino
Executive Vice President for Academic Affairs
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML54
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2073
Dr. Paul Oliver
Vice President for Student Affairs
California State University, Fresno
Joyal Administration Building
1610 N. Maple Ave., M/S JA87
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2541
Dr. Peter Smits
Vice-President for University Advancement
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML18
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-0000
Thomas Boehm
Director of Athletics
California State University, Fresno
5160 E. Shaw Ave., Suite 105 M/S NC27
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2641
When sexual discrimination or harassment. including sexual violence, serves as the
basis for any
employee or faculty member's complaint, the matter will be referred to Fresno State's
Title IX Coordinator.
Janice A. Parten, Associate Vice President for Human Resources for review and oversight
of the
complaint assessment, investiqation and, where warranted, implementation of interim
remedies for the
complainant.
A complaint of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation by an employee covered by
Executive Order 928
should be processed by the university-submitted to the appropriate individual no later
than thirty (30)
working days following the date of, or should have had, the early giving rise to the
complaint. An employee
who is covered by a collective bargaining agreement should refer to their agreement
to
determine the time for filing. Employees who are not eligible to file a complaint
of discrimination,
harassment, or retaliation pursuant to a collective bargaining agreement should refer
to the appropriate
process for filing a complaint.
Complainants should understand that as time passes, assessment becomes more difficult
because
memories fade and witnesses become unavailable. However, it is understood by the University
that the
experience of the individual who is subjected to discrimination, harassment, or retaliation
may
frequently cause the individual to delay making a complaint. Therefore, the University
will
review all complaints whenever they are presented. The provision is not intended to
extend the
statute of limitations that is provided by law. The investigatory and appeal procedures
are set forth in
Executive Order 928, Sections VI, VII, and VIII (Appendix B).
Section II. Students and Student Applicants
A. Policy
The University is committed to a safe and learning environment where every student
is treated with dignity
and respect. Consistent with Executive Order 1046, the University will not tolerate
discrimination,
harassment, or retaliation on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin,
ancestry, age, sex,
gender identity, sexual orientation, marital status, disability, mental disability,
medical condition,
or any other protected status.
Students who believe that they have been subjected to discrimination, harassment,
or retaliation
should file a complaint through the appropriate process. Students who are employees
may be
subject to the employee complaint procedures where applicable.
This policy and procedures set forth herein do not apply to an individual taking a
course through
Continuing and Extended Education offerings outside of the normal academic year or
academic semester, or to courses offered by an outside organization. Generally, these
courses are not subject to University policies and procedures. If the University receives
a complaint of discrimination, rather than the policy, if the University receives
these types of
complaints, the Campus Civil Rights Administrator will be responsible for forwarding
the
complaint to the appropriate auxiliary organization or Continuing Education administrator.
If the complaint is brought to the attention of the University, it will promptly
provide protection against discrimination or harassment. If a complaint is received,
the University
will promptly respond to prevent discrimination or harassment. It is critical that
potential
victims report such conduct without delay.
B. Definitions
For the purpose of this policy, the following-definitions apply:
A. Academlc Affaire means the-division at the Chancellor's Office that-is-responsible for gathering. reviewing and evaluating informationon the admission criteria of a campus asadomic program.
B. Аccused means the University and/or a Universityemployee against whom an-allegation of discrimination,
haraesment or retaliation-has been made.
C Applicant for Admission (or Applicant)-means an individualwho has applied for-admission to an
undergraduate, graduate, or credential program-at-the University that leads to the
pursuit-of a CSU
degree
D. Age has the same meaning as-dofined as-defined in California California Government Code-Section
12926(b) and
refers to the chronological-age of any individual whe has reached his or her fortieth
(40th) birthdayE. Univereity means Califonia State-LIniversity, Fresno.
F. Chancellor's Office (CO) Decignee-means-the person tacked with reviewing and responding to a
students/applicant for admission'sappealat Formal LovelHI.
G.Complaint-means a written communication that coriplies-with Executive Order 1045, alleging
diserimination, harasement or retaliation against the-University and/or a University
employee.
H. Complainant means anindividual who is eligible to, and does, file-a cormplaint to repert
diserimination,-kharassment-or retaliation as defined by this poliey
Day means a work day. Work days-are-defined as Monday through Friday, excluding allofficial
holidays or campus closuree at the-саmрus where the complaint originated.
J.Disability means mental or physical disability-as defined in Califomia Educatien
Code-Section
66260.5.
K. Discrimination-means a discrriminatory actagainet a student/applicant on a basis prohibited by
California Education Code-Sections 66250 et seq. and/or this executive order.
LDiscriminatory Act means an-act-that-meets the legal elements of a diserimination
claim
M. Employee, as defined in Title 5 of the-California Code of Regulations, means-a-person legally
holding a positien in and employed by-the-lUniversity (e.g.. Administrators, Faculty
Staff and
Student Employees).
N. Gender, as defined in California Education Code Section-66260.7, means sex, and includes-a
person's-gender-identity and gender related appearance-and behavior whether or not
stereotypically-associated with the person's assignedsex-atbith.
Sex-has-the-same meaning as defined in California-Govermment Code Section 12026(p)
which-inckudos.-but is not limited to, pregnaney. child birth or medical condition
related-to
pregnaneyor child birth.
Sex -has-the-same meaning as defined in California-Govermment Code Section 12026(p)
which-inckudos.-but is not limited to, pregnaney. childbirth or medicalcondition related-to
pregnaneyorchildbith.
Q. Harassment means unwelcome conductthat is engaged in because of the protected status of a
studentoran applicant, and:
1. Submissien to such conductis-made either an explicit or implicit terT-OFCOndition
of
admission-or academic evaluation,
2 Submission to or rejection of such-conduct-is used as the basis or threatened to
be used
as the basie for an academic assessmentaffecting the student or applicant-or
3. Such conduct is so severe or pervasive-that its effect, whether or not intended,
is an
educational envirenment that could-be-considered by a reasonable person.in-the shoes
ofthe student/applicant, and is in faet-considered by the student/applicant, intimidating,
hostile or offensive.
P. Investigator means the person-tasked by a campus with investigating a complaint of
discrimination, harassment, or retaliation at the University. An investigater may
be a Management Personnel Plan employoe-or an external consultant,
Q. Nationality, as defined in California Education Code Section 66261.5, includos citizenship, country ef-origin, and national origin.
R. Preponderance of the Evidence means the greater weight-of the evidence; i.e., that the evidence
.on-one side outweighs, preponderates over, or is more than, the evidence on-the other
side. S. ProtectedStatus means any basis-listed or defined in California Education
Code-Sections 66250
et segT. Race or ethnicity, as defñined in California-Education Code Section-66261.7,
includes ancestry.
color, ethnic groupidentification, and ethnic-background
U. Religion, as defined in Califormia Education Code Section 66262, includes all aspects of religious
belief, observance,and practice and includes-agnosticism and atheism.
V. Rataliation means adverse-action that is taken-by a-CSU employee because-a student or an applicant
has or is believedto have:
Reported or opposed-conduet which the studentor applicant reasonably and in good faith
believes is discrimination/harassment/retaliation; OF
Participatod in a discrimination/harasement/retaliation-investigation/ proceeding
W. Sexual Orientatlon, as-defined in California Education Code Section 66262.7 means heterosexuality, homosexuality, or bisexuality
X. Student-means an individual-who has been admitted-to-an undergraduate, graduate, or credential
program at the University thatleads to the pursuitof-acSu degree.
C. Procedures-for filing a complaint
1. Informal resolution of problems
The University is-interosted in resolving preblems at the lowest level_This is most
likely-accomplished
when problems are reperted early. The University-recognizes that any-student may be
approached by another student seeking advico-in difficult ciroumstances, or by third
parties on behalf of someone-else.
These-individuals may be seeking-infomation and not necessarily wanting to file-a-complaint.
If the
individual-wants to keep the matter-confidential, the individual raising the concern-should
be remindedof
the on carmpus confidential resources the University provides-for students in the
office of Psychologicat
Services in-the Student Health alth Cer Center (559-278-2734).
Staff in the Student Health Center are trained to-advise potential complainants on
conflict resolution skills,
the complaint process and-how they might proceed. They can also teach-coping skills.
These-services
are provided by licensed-counselors and certified-consultants in a strictly-confidential
manner.
2. The complaint form
The complaint form is available-at http://www.calstate.edu/e0/e0-928.doc.A copy is
attached in Appendix E.
3. Filing a complaint
If the individualis-notconcerned with-confidentiality, he or she-may also wish to
consult-with the dean.
associate dean, or director closest closest to the-acadermic or work area All of these
managers-are trained to
respond to complaints of harassment Students who believe they-have been subiected-to
behavior that they consider harassment chould report the-behavior immediately either
orally or in writing
A list of those who can-respond to concerns-orcomplaints is provided in-Appendix D.
Students-seeking to file a complaint should contact the Dean of Students at the Office
of the Vice
President for Student Affairs
Dr Carolyn-Coon
Dean of Students
Office of the Vice President-for Student Affairs
JoyalAdministration Building, Room 262 5150 North Maple Avenue M/S JA-67
Fresno, California 93740
FAX:(559) 2787276
Phene–(559) 278-2541
Alternatively, students may contactthe-dean or associate dean of their schoelercollege.
Staff in either
office-can-explain the resources available-to-studonts. Additional information is
available-in-the University
CatalogCases-involving campus-administrators will be referred to the appropriate Vice
President, the President,
or the Chancellor's Office. In-cases alleging harassment by an administrator, if the
allegation is against
the Director of Human Resources, it-should be filed with the Vice President for Administration.
If the
allegation is against the President, it should-be filed with the Vice Chancellor-forHuuman
Resources. These offices-can-be reached as followe:
DrJehn D. Welty
President
Ms.Gail Brooks
ViceChancellor for Human Resources
The California-State University
Long Beach.California 90802
562-951 4400
562-951-4400
California State-University, Fresne
Haak Center 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML62
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278 2324
Ms. Cvnthia Teniente-Matson
Vice President for Administration
California State University, Fresnе
Haak Center,4th FleOF
5200 N. Barton M/S ML52
Fresno, CA 93740
559278-2083
DR William A. CoVinO
Provost and Vice President for Acadenic AffairsCalifornia State University, Fresno
Haak Center-4 Fl0OF
5200 N. Barten M/SML51
Fresле, CA 93740
559-778-2636
Dr. Peter Smits
Vice Presidentfor University Advancement
California State-LUniversity, Fresne Haak-Ceenter4t Fioor
5200 N.-Bardon M/S ML118
Fresnа. СA 93740
559 2786050
Thornas-Boeh
Directorof-Athletics
California State-University. Fresne
1510 E. Shaw-Ave-Ste 103 M/S NG27
FresneGA-B9371
Dr Paul Oliaro
Vice President for Student-Affairs
California State University,-Eresne
JoyalAdministration
5150NMaple Ave_M/S JA67
Fresno, CA93740
559-278 2641
A complaint of diserimination, harasement, or retaliation-should be received by the
univercity within-twenty
work days after the end-of the end of the academic term (semester/quarter)F)IA in
which the most-recently alleged diseriminatory harassing/rotaliatory act occurred.
Complainants-should understand that-as time passe6, а66essment becormes-more difficult
becauce memories fade-and witnesses become unavailable. However, it is understood-by
the-University that the stress and fear that-individuals who are subjectedto
harassment mау ехреrience often-complicato the decision to make a-complaint. Therefore
the University will-review-all-complaints whenever they are-brought forward. This
provision is-not-intended to extend the
statute-of-limitations that is provided by law. The-investigatery and appeal procedures
are set forth in
Executive Order 1045,-SectionsVI, VII,and VIII (Appendix-6)
Section III. Harassment-of-Job Applicants and Independent Contractors
A. Policy
The applicable disçrimination,_harassment, and retaliation policy for job_applicants
and independent
contractors is Executive Orders 927, available on the web at: http://www.calstate.edu/EO/EO-927.html
B. Procedures for filing a complalnt
1. Informal resolution of problems
The University is interested in resolving problems at the lowest level. This is most
likely accomplished
when problems are reported early. In situations where the individual wants to keep
the matter
confidential or is seeking information to help with the decision about whether or
not to file a complaint, the
indiviđuạl raising ng the concern is reminded that once the matter is reported to
a campus manager the
university-University cannot guarantee confidentiality2. The complaint form
The complaint form is
ED.
3. Filing a complaint
available at: http://www.calstate.edu/eo/e0-928.doc A copy is attached in Appendix
3. Filing a complaint
available at: http://www.calstate.edu/eo/e0-928.doc A copy is attached in Appendix
If the individual is not concerned with confidentiality, he or she may wish to consult
with the manager
closest to the academic or work area. All of these managers are trained to respond
to complaints of
discrimination, harassment, and retaliation. If you believe you have beenen subjected
to behavior that you
consider discrimination, harassment,_or retaliation, you should report the behavior
immediately either
orally or in writing-
A list of those who can respond to concerns or complaints is provided in Appendix DC.
An individual with a complaint against a sstaff member or manager may file a complaint
with the Director of
Associate Vice President for Human Resources by contacting 559-278-2364, or by delivering
or sending (via mail or fax) a copy of the complaint form or written statement to:
Ms. Janice Parten
California State University, Fresno rresno G-25.11
Revised July, 2010 August 2012 based on EO 927,EO and 928,and EO-1045
Associate Vice President for Human Resources
Joyal Administration Building Room 211
Ms.-Janice Parten
Director, Human-Resources
JeyalAdministration Building-Room-161
North Maple Avenue M/S JA 41
California State Unniversity, Fresno
Fresno, CA 93740
FAX: 559-278-77954275
An individual with a complaint against a faculty member may file a complaint with
the Associate Vice President for Academic PersonnelFaculty Affairs by contacting 559-278-3027,
or by delivering or sending
(via mail or fax) a copy of the complaint form or written statement to:
Ms. Janette Redd WilliamsDr. Michael Caldwell
Associate Vice President for Academic PersonnelFaculty Affairs
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML55
Fresno. CA 93740
FAX: 559-278-81910
Cases involving campus administratore will be referred to the appropriate Vice President,
the President,
or the Chancellor's-Office-ln cases where discrimination, harassment, or retailiation by the Associate
Vice President of Human Resources is alleged, the complaint_alleging-harassment by
an adminietrator, if
the-allegation-isagainst the Director-of HumanResources, it-should be filed with the
CSU Vice President
for Administration. If the allegation is against the President, it should be filed
with the Vice Chancellor for
Human Resources. These offices can be reached as follows:
-Ms. Cynthia Teniente-Matson
Vice President for Administration
California State University, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton M/S ML52
Fresno. CA 93740
559-278-2083
Dr.John D. Welty
President
CalifomiaStatelL.Jriversity. Fresnе
Haak-Genter 4h_FloOr
5200 N Baton-M/S-ML52
Fresno-A 93746
559 278 2324
Ms. Cynthia Teniente Matson
ViGe President-fo-Administration
Ms. Gail Gail Brooks
Vice Chancellor for Human Resources
The California State University
Long Beach, California 90802
562-951-4400
Ms. Gail Brooks
Vise-Chancellor-fer Human Res
The-California-StateJniversity
Long Beach, California 90802
562-9514400
-5629514490
Dr.WVilliamA. Covino
Provost-andVise-President for Academic Affairs
California State Univorsity, Fresno
Haak Center, 4th Floor
5200 N. Barton-M/SAL52
Fresno, CA 93740
559-278-2083
Dr. Paul Oliaro
Vice President for Student-Affairs
Califormia State University. Fresno Joval-Administration
5150N-Maple Ave.
Fresne, CA 93740
559 2782541
Thomas Boeh
Director of Athletice
M/S JA67
California State University, FresnO
1510 E. Shaw Ave Ste 103 M/S NG2Z
FresAO-CA 93710
559244564-
Hatassnent, and Retaliation
California State University, Fresno
G-25.12
Revised July2010August 2012 based on EO 927,E0 and, 928,and EO 1045
California State UJniversity, Fresno
Haak Center, 4h Floor
5200-N Barton M/S ML54
Freeno. CA93740
559 278 2636
Dr. Peter-Smits
Vice President for University Advancement
California State-University, Fresne Haak Center 4h FloeF
5200 N. Barton M/S ML118
Fresno, CAСА 93740
559-278-6050
A complaint of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation should be submitted to the
appropriate personnel
no later than thirty (30) working following the date of the event giving rise to the
claim, or no later later than
thirty (30) working days after the employee learns of, or should have reasonably known
about the event's
occurrence.
the received by the university-within oпө (1) yoar of the time that-the-allaged event(s)
occurred, orwithin the
time frame set forth in the-appropriate collective bargaining agreement in the case
of sorme employees.
Complainants should understand that as time passes, assessment becomes more difficult.
The facts and
memories fade and witnesses become unavailable. However, it is understood by the University
that
stress and fear that individuals who are subjected to harassment may experience often
complicate
decision to make a complaint. Therefore the University will review all complaints
whenever they are
brought forward. This provision is not intended to extend the statute of limitatioons
that is provided by law.
The itnvestigation procedures_-are-set forth in Executive Order 928 (Aрpendix B)7,
Section D (Aрpendix А). арply.
Section lll. Additional information regarding sexual discrimination, sexual harassment and sexual violence claims sexual harassment
A.Confidentiality
The University recognizes the importance of confidentiality and will respect the privacy
of those-reporting
or accused of harassment by keeping the matter confidentialto-the extent possible.However,
the
University cannot guarantee-confidentiality. Confidentiality cannot-be-maintained
when the University is required by law to disclose-infomation or when non diselosure
may harm the rights of others The
psychotherapist-patient privilege-ordinarily protects these communications-butthis
protection-may not-be
recognized in federal court.
A. В.-Туpes of sexual harassment
It is unlawful to subject another individual to discrimination or harassment based on that person's sex.
"Sex" includes, but is not limited to: the victim's actual sex; the harasser's perception
of the victim's sex.
the harassers perception of the victim's identity, appearance, or behavior, whether
or not that identity.
appearance, or behavior is different from that traditionally associated with the victim’s
sex at birth; sexual
orientation; pregnancy, childbirth; or medical conditions related to pregnancy or
childbirth.
Sexual harassment is any_unwelcome and/or uninvited verbal or physical conduct directed
towardsa
person because of his or_her sex. Аn аct of sexual violence is any physical sexual
act perpetrated against a person's will, and constitutes sexual harassment.
With respect to allegations of sexual harassment in the workplace, tIwo distinct categories
of sexual
harassment claims are generally recognized:
“Quid Pro Quo" sexual harassment occurs when submission to sexual conduct is made
either
an explicit or implicit condition of employment-or admission, financial aid, academic
evaluation-o
any other identifiable educational benefit,-and submission to or rejection of such
conduct by an
individual is used as the basis for employment decisions er decisions conceming admission;
financial aid, academic-evaluation or any other educational decision(s) affecting
such individual.
"Hostile Environment" sexual harassment exists when a pattern of severe or pervasive
unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, or other verbal or physical
conduct of a
sexual nature occurs, where such conduct has the purpose or effect of unreasonably
interfering
with a reasonable individual's work er educationalperformance or creating an intimidating.
hostile,_-or offensive working or learning environment.
While any one of the above mentioned types of behavior may constitute sexual harassment
in an
aggravated situation,_such as any instance where sexual violence is inyolved, "Hostile
stile Environment"
sexual harassment usually requires a continuous, severe, and pervasive pattern of
behavior that
encompasses more than one incident-of the examples-identified above. Although one
incident might not
constitute_actionable sexual harassment, it may nevertheless be unprofessional and
inappropriate
conduct in the workplace for which the Uuniversity may take personnel action action
(reprimand or disciplinary action).
BC. Аcademic freedom and freedom of speech
It is recognized that legitimate political, social, educational, religious or artistic
expression is protected by
the First Amendment. Speech or expressive conduct deemed to be sexual harassment may
not be protected by the First Amendment. For a definition of academic freedom see
the AAUP 1940 Statement
of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure, and the University Statement of Academic
Freedom
(APM 103). Generally, to be protected in an instructional setting, speech or conduct
must be intended to
advance the learning process. The law does not protect students from all discomfort.
DC. Consensual relations
The University normally has no interest in the private or romantic relationships between
individuals
However, when these relationships involve individuals in unequal positions (e.g. professor
student,
supervisor-subordinate,-advisor-advisee, mentor mentee), there are risks. Such relationships
can present potential or apparent conflicts of interest, and they can damage the integrity
of the professional
supervisory relationship. Relationships can degenerate, objectivity may be sacrificed,
and_others in the
work or learning environment may perceive favoritism or feel intimidated by the relationship.
For these
reasons, the University requires those in a position of authority (i.e. faculty and
supervisors) to report
such relationships to their department chair, dean, com cmmittee chair, or manager
as appropriate. Once
notified, that person will make arrangements to avoid real or potential conflicts
of interest
Additional policies that apply include the University policy on nеpotism
(http://www.csufresno.edu/aps/apm/303.pdf-), -and the University policy on faculty
and student
consensual relations-(-http:///www.csufresno.edu/aps/apm/346.pdf-).
Section IV: Procedures for Handling Employment Related Complaints Filed-onCampusFiled on Campus
A. A-Requirement to respond
Once the University is made aware of a discrimination, harassment, or retaliation
charge, it is legally
required to respond by taking reasonably necessary steps (subject to applicable collective
bargaining
agreements) to eliminate and deter any such misconduct even if the complainant decides
at some point
not to pursue the matter.
B. Responsibilities of managers and supervisors
Managers (i.e. those covered by the Management Personnel Plan) and supervisors7, including
department chairs, are required to report in writing all discrimination, harassment,
and retaliation
complaints to the DirectorofAssociate Vice President for Human Resources, except complaints
by faculty
members_not based on sexual discrimination, sexual harassment or sexual violence,
which must beare
reported to the Associate Vice President for Academic PersonnelFaculty Affairs. and-cormplaints
by studente, which are reported to the Dean ofStudents. Once an individual discloses
infomation to a
manager or supervisor, including a department chair, he or she will be considered
to have filed
complaint with the University. Bargaining unit employees in supervisory positions
are required to notify
their managers of allegations of discrimination,_harassment, or retaliation as soon
as they become aware as
of them. All reports of sexual discrimination, harassment or violence shali be referred
to Fresno State's
Title IX Coordinator
C. Process for reviewing complalnts
1. Lowest level of resolution - Efforts will be made to resolve complaints at the
lowest possible levei. This
may be accomplished by working with the manager or department chair closest to the
individuals involved
with the matter. The Director ofAssociate Vice President for Human Resources, the
Associate Vice
President for Asademic Personnel, the-Dean-of-StudeatsFaculty Affairs, or their designees,
will work
those in the department to resolve the problems. _In the interest of enhancing a positive
learning and
working environment, the University wishes to resolve problems as soon as possible
when they arise.
Notifying a manager or supervisor early on may help reduce the need for more formal
intervention
with
later
Under California Goverment Code § 12926(r), a supervisor is defined as any individual
with the authority to hire.
transfer, suspend, lay off, recall, promote. discharge. assign, reward, or discipline
other employees, or thе
responsibility to direct them, or to adjust their grievances, or effectively to recommend
that action, if.. the exercise
of that authority... requires the use of independent judgment."
*Supervisor is defined as any individual with the authority “to hire, transfer, suspond,
lay off, recall, promote,
discharge, assign, reward, or discipline other employees, or the responsibility to
direet them,or-to adjust their grievances,-or-effectively torecommend that action,
if..the exercise of that authority requiros the useof
independent judgnent" (Cal Code Section 12926 (t))
Discussing a problem with a manager or supervisor does not necessarily lead to personnel
action or
documentation tion beingin placed in a personnel file. However, please note that where
instances of severe
harassment are involved, including sexual violence, informal mediation of the matter
is not appropriate
and the matter will be addressed in accordance with the formal process existing under
the pertinent policy.
2. Administrative review or investigation - The Director ofAssociate Vice President
for Human Resources
or, the Associate Vice President for Acasdemic PersonnelFaculty Affairs_. ortho Dean
of Studente,-in
consultation with the appropriate Vice President(s) or Athletics Director, and others,
may determine that
1) an administrative review, and/or 2) an investigation by an external investigator
is needed. Such
review(s) and/or investigation(s) may be conducted by staff in Human Resources, by
the Associate Vice
President for Academic PersonnelFaculty Affairs, the-Dean of-Students-or others with
experience and others
authority to conduct such reviews or investigations.
the
3. Written notification and time frame - If it is determined that an administrative
review and/or investigation
is needed, the person filing the complaint (complainant) and the person against whorm
the complaint is
filed (the respondent) will be notified in writing by the administrator responsible
for processing the
complaint. A copy of these procedures will be supplied to each party. A prompt and
equitable resolution
of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation complaints is to be sought. There shall
be a resolution of a
complaint (if resolution is possible) within a reasonable periad of time which is
usually ferty five (45)-sixty
(60) university business days of the filing of the complaint for-employees and for
students no later thaR
twenty (20) workdays after the end of the academie term in which the most recently
alleged diseriminatory/harassing/retaliatory-act occurredcomplaint. Occasionally,
the time limit wilt need to be
extended if individuals necessary for interview-the investigation_are unavailable,
e.g., during academic
recesses. In this case, the investigator will infom the complainant and respondent
in writing of the need
to extend the time period.
4. Notification of conclusion of administrative review or investigation - The complainant
and the
respondent shall be notified separately in writing of the conclusion of an administrative
review or
investigation and of the findings as appropriate to each party respectively. The notif
notiication shall indicate if
the findings are being referred to the appropriate vice president for further action.
5. President's decision The President will be notified of the findings of administrative
reviews and
investigations._The President will review the findings within a reasonable period
of time, usually fifteen
(15) University business days. The President, or designee, may seek additional information
as necessary
during this time.
6. Special requirements when a complaint is filed against a faculty mermber= Depending
on the nature of
the problem reported, the Provost or academic personnel officer may intervene and
work with the nay intervene andb manager and/or department chair closest to the employee(s)
to resolve the matter. If it is determined that
an administrative review or investigation is necessary, -it will normally be coordinated
by the Associate
Vice President for Academic Personnel. At the conclusion of that review or investigation,
the findings will
be referred to the Provost for appropriate action.
In cases where the complaint is substantiated, the complainant will be inforined that
aрргорriate
will be taken. However, due to the personnel rights of the respondent as prescribed
by law, the complainant will not
be informed as to the nature of the corrective action.
Special requirements when the complaint is filed against a student - When a complaint
is filed against
a studendent, the natter will be referred to the Dean of Students. The Dean and/or
the Vice President for
Student Affairs is responsible for disciplinary decisions regarding students and subsequent
appeal
processes if applicable. The actions of the University will be governed by CSU Executive
Order No. 628
8. Employee's Right to request reconsideration — Within ten (10) university business
days of receipt of the
notification of findings, either the complainant oro the the respondent may request
reconsideration in writing
from the President based on newly discovered material information not previously presented
and which
reasonable diligence could not have been presented during the original investigation.
The appeal
shall summarize the newly discovered information upon which the complainant or respondent
feels the
appeal should be granted.
The President will acknowledge receipt of the appeal within a reasonable period of
time which is usually
five (5) university business days and will, within a reasonable period of time which
is usually twenty (20) university business days, provide a written decision sion to
the appellant. The President's decision is the final
university campus decision. Employees are entitled to appeal the campus decision to
the CSU's
Chancellor's Office within ten (10) university business days.
9. Employee's right of appeal= A respondent covered by a collective bargaining agreement
may appeala
personnel action (reprirmand or disciplinary action) under the policies and procedures
of the appropriate
collective bargaining agreement. Other employees should contact Human Resources for
procedures for
requesting reconsideration of personnel actions.
10. Retaliation - It is a violation of federal and state law, and of University policy,
for anyone to retaliate
against a person or persons who files a compl ompaint or who cooperates in the investigation
of a complaint.
University employees found to have retaliated against individuals involved in the
complaint process are
subject to personnel action. Additionally, retaliation for objecting to potentially
sexually harassing
behavior is strictly prohibited.
11. Record retention - Records related to complaints are kept in the office of the
DirectorefAssociate
Vice President for Human Resources, the Associate Vice President for Academic Personnel
rsonnelFaculty
Affairs, and the Dean of Students, as applicable, separate from personnel files. Complaints
filed against
Section Vl. Training and Resources
A proactive program will be maintained to educate the campus community about acts
of employment
discrimination, harassment, and retaliation, retaliation, the t University's University's
policies policies against such actsit, and what
recourse a complainant has to address the situationthem. This will be achieved through
a variety
means, such as:
Reminders about ther harassment policy and procedures posted electronically at the
beginning of
the academic year,
Announcements to employees of information available on-line;
Distribution of appropriate printed material to employees and-students-with definitions and contact information; Information in the General Catalogue:
Information-distributed in new employee-and-new student orientation-and
Training for employees in compliance with applicable laws.
On campus help is available through the following offices:
Emplovees: Employee Assistance and Wellness 559-278-4357
Student Asstss: Health and Psychological Services 559-278-2734
Stud/Athletes Avante Services 559-261-9050
Employees: Empleyee Assistance and Wellness -559-2278-4357
Everyone: Campus Police Department 559-278-8400
Womien's Resource Center 559-278-4435
Off campus help is available from a variety of sources. The following selection is
provided to help guide
students and employees who may wish to use services external to the campus.
The State government entity charged with investigating workplace discrimination,_harassment, and-otherfoms of workplace diserinminationand retaliation:
Department of Fair Employment and Housing
1320 E. Shaw Avenue. Suite 150
Fresno, CA 93710
559-2444760 or 800-884-1684 TDD 800-700-232o
The Federal govemment entity charged with investigating workplace cormplaints of discrimination
harassment, and retaliation:
Werkplace complaintsEqual Employment Opportunity Commission
2300 Tulare Street, Suite 215
Fresno, CA 93721
559487-5793 or 800-669-4000 TTY: 800-669-6820
-For complaints specifically based on sex disçrimination or harassment in campus
programs or activities:
U.S. Department of Education
Office of Civil Rights
50 Beale Street, Suite 7200
San Francisco, CA 94105
Tel.: (415) 486-5555 Fax: (415) 486-5570
Title IX laws address-sexual harasement between students. A student who believes he
or she
has been harassed by another student-may also file a complaint with the U.SDepartment
of Education,
Office of Civil Rights. The address for the San-Francisco office is:
US-Dораtment of EducatiOA
Office of Civil Rights
50 Beale Street, Suite 7200
San FrancisCO CA 94105
Tol.:(415)486-5556 Fax:(415) 486-5570
Local rаpe сounseling referral services throúgh:
Rape Counseling Services
1060 Fulton Mall, Fresno, CA 93721
559-497-2900 or 24-hour hotline: 559-222-RAPE [7273]
Local legal referral services:
Attorney's Information and Referral Services
1221 Van Ness Ave, Suite 300, Fresno, CA 93721-1720
559-264-0137
Local mental health counseling referral services:
Therapist Referral Network
1-800-THERAPIST
Local assistance managing the court system:
Victim-Witness Service Center
2220 Tulare Street, Suite 1126
Fresno, CA 93721
559488-3425
January 6, 2005
MEMORANDUM
TO: CSU Presidents
FROM: Charles B. Reed
Chancellor
SUBJECT: Systemwide Policy Prohibiting Harassment in Employment and
Retaliation for Reporting Harassment or Participation in a
Harassment Investigation - Executive Order No. 927
In response to recent legal and legislative developments in the area of anti-
harassment laws, the attached Executive Order 927 replaces Executive Order
345. Executive Order 927 broadens the scope of what was once the CSU's
sexual harassment policy to one that prohibits unlawful harassment based on
any statutory category protected by the Fair Employment and Housing Act.
Consistent with the Fair Employment and Housing Act, Executive Order 927
protects employees, applicants, and independent contractors from unlawful
harassment. The prohibition against harassment of students is established by
each campus and is not covered by this systemwide policy.
Executive Order 927 emphasizes the importance of training the CSU
community on anti-harassment and anti-retaliation policies and procedures in
order to prevent and correct harassment.
If you have questions regarding this executive order, please call Employee
Relations: (562) 951-4425.
In accordance with CSU policy, the campus president has the responsibility for
implementing Executive Order 927 and for maintaining the campus repository
and index for all executive orders.
CBR/eb
Attachment
cc: Executive Staff, Office of the Chancellor
Associate Vice Presidents, Faculty Affairs
Human Resources Directors
Equal Employment Opportunity Directors
THE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
Office of the Chancellor
401 Golden Shore
Long Beach, California 90802-4210
(562) 951-4425
Executive Order: 927
Effective Date: January 6, 2005
Supersedes: Executive Order No. 345
Title: Systemwide Policy Prohibiting Harassment in Employment
and Retaliation for Reporting Harassment or Participation
in a
Harassment Investigation
A. Policy
The California State University (CSU) is committed to maintaining a work
environment where every employee, applicant, and independent contractor
is treated with dignity and respect. CSU will not tolerate unlawful
harassment based on race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, age,
sex, sexual orientation, marital status, veteran status (as defined by the
Vietnam-Era Veterans' Readjustment Assistance Act of 1974, as
amended), physical disability, mental disability, or medical condition.
Individuals covered within the scope of this executive order who believe
they have been subjected to harassment should promptly report it to the
campus administrators designated to receive harassment complaints.
CSU will respond to all harassment complaints brought to its attention in a
timely and appropriate manner. If the complaint is made in a timely manner,
CSU will promptly take actions to prevent recurrence and remedy the effects of
the harassment. Persons who engage in harassment may be subject to
discipline up to and including discharge. In determining whether
conduct or issue violates this policy, the totality of the circumstances shall
be considered.
To prevent harassment, it is critical that individuals not be deterred from
reporting it. CSU will not retaliate, nor will it tolerate retaliation.
B. Application
This systemwide policy prohibits: 1) harassment of any employee,
applicant, or independent contractor; and 2) retaliation against such an
individual for reporting conduct the individual reasonably and in good
faith believes is harassment or participating in any investigation of
harassment.
C. Definitions
Harassment
Harassment occurs when unwelcome conduct is engaged in because of a
protected status of an individual, which include race, color, religion,
national origin, ancestry, age, sex, sexual orientation, marital status,
veteran status, physical disability, mental disability, or medical condition,
and:
(1) Submission to such conduct is made, either explicitly or implicitly,
a term or condition of an individual's employment;
(2) Submission to or rejection of such conduct by an individual is used
as the basis or threatened to be used as the basis for employment or
advancement affecting an individual; or
(3) Such conduct is so severe or pervasive that its effect, whether or
not intended, is a work environment that could be considered by a
reasonable person in the shoes of the individual, and is in fact
considered by the individual, as intimidating, hostile or offensive.
Harassment can be written (in print or electronically), verbal, visual, or
physical. Examples of harassment include:
• Written communications, such as sending inappropriate
jokes or comments in print or by e-mail;
• Verbal communications, such as making graphic or
degrading comments about an individual, and/or his or her
body or personal characteristics, or using epithets,
derogatory comments or slurs;
• Physical acts, such as unwelcome touching, physical
interference, or even assault;
• Visual acts or displays, such as derogatory cartoons,
drawings, or posters, or inappropriate gestures.
• Making unwelcome sexual advances or propositions, or
offering employment benefits or giving preferential
treatment in exchange for sexual favors;
• Making or threatening reprisals after a negative response to
unwelcome conduct
“Sex” includes, but is not limited to: the victim’s actual sex; the
harasser’s perception of the victim’s sex; the harasser’s perception of the
victim’s identity, appearance, or behavior, whether or not that identity,
appearance, or behavior is different from that traditionally associated with
victim’s sex at birth; and pregnancy, childbirth, or medical conditions
related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Sexual harassment is prohibited whether perpetrated by a CSU employee
or a non-employee. Where the CSU employee who engages in unlawful
sexual harassment is a supervisor or manager, the conduct is especially
insidious. Sexual harassment may be perpetrated by someone who is of
the same sex as the victim. The person who complains of sexual
harassment may be the victim toward whom the harassing conduct was
directed or a third party who witnessed the harassing conduct.
Employee
“Employee” includes any full- or part-time CSU employee, whether
permanent, tenured, probationary, temporary, intermittent, casual
employment, or Management Personnel Plan employee.
Applicant
“Applicant” refers to an individual who has completed the application
process for a specific, available position at a CSU campus or at the
Chancellor’s Office.
Independent contractor
“Independent contractor” refers to “a person providing services pursuant
to a contract.” As defined by the Fair Employment and Housing Act, “a
person providing services pursuant to a contract” is a person who meets all
of the following criteria:
• The person has the right to control the performance of the
contract for services and discretion
work, and performs work that requires a particular skill not
ordinarily used in the course of the employee's work.
Disability
A person with a “disability” is a person who:
• Has a physical or mental impairment which limits one or
more major life activities; or
• Has a record of such an impairment; or
• Is regarded as having such an impairment.
Medical condition
“Medical condition” means:
• A health impairment related to a diagnosis of cancer or a
record or history of cancer; or
• A genetic characteristic that is known to cause a disease or
disorder, or to statistically increase the risk of developing a
disease or disorder, but currently is not manifested in any
symptoms of the disease or disorder.
D. Policy Implementation
The chancellor and the presidents, or their designees, shall be responsible
for implementing this systemwide policy at each campus. This includes,
but is not limited to, publicizing the policy, conducting training, and
establishing an administrative structure consistent with this executive
order that facilitates the prevention and elimination of unlawful
harassment.
Training & Internal Communication
To prevent harassment and encourage the reporting of harassment, training
shall be provided by each campus to all employees upon their initial
arrival at the campus. Such training shall explain, but not be limited to:
what constitutes harassment under applicable laws; the rights and
responsibilities of each individual relating to workplace harassment; the
protection against retaliation for individuals who report harassment or
participate in an investigation; the internal complaint procedures for filing,
investigating and resolving a harassment complaint; and the options and
method for filing a harassment complaint with external government
agencies such as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing.
(DFEH) and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
After training has been given to employees upon their first arrival at the
campus, refresher training shall be provided, when necessary, to refresh and update
employees' knowledge of harassment and retaliation laws.
Recent amendments to FEHA include additional training requirements for
supervisory employees, who generally must receive at least two hours of
interactive sexual harassment training within six months of assignment to
a supervisory position, and continued training every two years.
Each campus should ensure that the requisite training is provided and
maintain documentation of the provided training.
Each campus shall distribute a copy of the following documents to all
employees upon their first arrival at the campus. It is recommended that
this information be made accessible for reference to current employees
annually.
• The DFEH pamphlet "Discrimination and Harassment in
Employment are Prohibited by Law" (DFEH-162 (04-01));
• This executive order, or a superseding document, if
applicable;
• Executive Order 883, or a superseding document, if
applicable; and
• Executive Order 675, or a superseding document, if
applicable.
Each campus shall obtain the poster on discrimination in employment
from the DFEH, or create an equivalent document, and shall post such
poster/document in prominent and accessible locations on campus.
The chancellor and the presidents, or their designees, shall designate the
individuals responsible for receiving and investigating complaints of
harassment on their respective campuses. Once selected, each campus
shall publicize the job titles, phone numbers and addresses of these
individuals. Their job titles, rather than names, should be publicized so as
to eliminate confusion when there is a staffing change. Training shall be
provided to these individuals, as needed, to update their knowledge and
skills.
Complaint Processing
Complaints of harassment are processed in the same manner as complaints
of discrimination. The type of internal complaint procedure that is
available to each person filing a discrimination complaint will vary
depending upon two factors: (1) the employment status of the person, and
(2) the applicable collective bargaining agreement. To direct a person
who has a harassment complaint to the appropriate complaint procedure,
the campus should first determine whether the person is an employee,
applicant, or independent contractor. If the person is an employee, the
campus should next determine if the employee is covered by a collective
bargaining agreement.
Employees Covered by a CBA
Employees who are covered by a collective bargaining agreement that
provides a procedure for filing discrimination or harassment complaints
shall be directed to the relevant provision in the respective labor contract.
Where the collective bargaining agreement does not provide a procedure
for filing discrimination or harassment complaints or, where the collective
bargaining agreement does not provide for the type of discrimination or
harassment claim the employee articulates (e.g., co-worker harassment),
the employee shall be directed to Executive Order 675, or a superseding
executive order, if applicable.
Employees Not Covered by CBA
Employees who do not belong to a collective bargaining unit (e.g., MPP
and Confidential) shall be directed to utilize Executive Order 675, or a
superseding executive order, if applicable.
Applicants & Independent Contractors
There is currently no systemwide discrimination or harassment complaint
procedure for applicants or independent contractors. Yet, their harassment
complaints must be investigated and appropriate actions taken pursuant to
this executive order and in accordance with state and federal
nondiscrimination laws. Consequently, each campus shall provide for
these investigations by having in place a complaint procedure to handle
harassment complaints from applicants and independent contractors. Such
a procedure shall designate several persons to whom a report of
harassment can be made.
January 6, 2005
MEMORANDUM
TO: CSU Presidents
FROM: Charles B. Reed
Chancellor
SUBJECT: Systemwide Complaint Procedure for Discrimination,
Harassment and Retaliation Complaints for Employees Not
Eligible to File a Complaint or Grievance Under a
Collective Bargaining Agreement or Whose Collective
Bargaining Agreement Incorporates CSU Systemwide
Complaint Procedure – Executive Order No. 928
Attached is a copy of Executive Order 928, which supersedes Executive
Order 675. Executive Order 928 provides the procedures for filing and
processing discrimination, harassment and retaliation complaints for
employees who are not eligible to file a complaint or grievance under a
collective bargaining agreement or whose collective bargaining agreement
incorporates CSU systemwide complaint procedure for such purposes.
This executive order provides guidelines for handling discrimination,
harassment and retaliation claims that are either not formalized in a
written complaint or not filed timely.
If you have questions regarding this executive order, please call Employee
Relations at (562) 951-4425.
In accordance with the policy of the Executive State University, the
campus president has the responsibility for implementing Executive Order
928 and for maintaining the campus repository and index for all Executive
orders.
CBR/eb
Attachment
cc: Executive Staff, Office of the Chancellor
Associate Vice Presidents, Faculty Affairs
Human Resources Directors
Equal Employment Opportunity Directors
I. Introduction
A. The California State University (CSU), through its chancellor and presidents, is
committed to the equitable and prompt response to any allegation of
discrimination, harassment or retaliation made by an employee.
B. Should discrimination, harassment or retaliation be found to exist in any
employment action within CSU, all appropriate measures shall be taken to prevent
recurrence and to remedy any effects on the claimant/complainant and others, if
appropriate. Furthermore, should findings be made of discrimination, harassment
or retaliation on the part of any CSU employee, appropriate action, including
possible disciplinary action against the perpetrator, shall be taken under the
direction of the president or chancellor, as applicable.
II. Application
This procedure shall apply to CSU employees, as defined below, who are not eligible
to
file a discrimination, harassment or retaliation complaint or grievance under a collective
bargaining agreement or whose collective bargaining agreement incorporates CSU
systemwide complaint procedure for such purposes.
III. Definitions
A. “Employee” includes any full- or part-time CSU employee, whether permanent,
tenured, probationary, temporary, intermittent, casual employment, or
Management Personnel Plan employee.
B. “Claimant” refers to an employee who has made a discrimination, harassment or
retaliation claim under Section V of this executive order.
C. “Complainant” refers to an employee who is eligible to file, and has filed, a
written formal discrimination, harassment or retaliation complaint under Section
VI of this executive order.
D. “Complaint” refers to a written formal allegation filed by a complainant under
Section VI of this executive order.
E. “Representative” refers to a union representative from the claimant or
complainant’s collective bargaining unit, or another individual who may serve as
a representative of an employee entitled to such representation under the
provisions of this executive order.
F. The terms “Respond” and “File” refer to personal delivery or deposit in the U.S.
Mail, certified with return receipt requested. If personal delivery is used, the
calendar date of delivery shall establish the date of response or filing. If certified
mail delivery is used, the postmark shall establish the date of response or filing.
IV. Scope
A. In order to use this procedure, a CSU employee must assert:
1. A violation of CSU's systemwide policies against discrimination, harassment
or retaliation; and,
2. The specific harm resulting from the alleged violation.
V. Informal Level (Optional)
A. Prior to or instead of filing a written formal complaint under Section VI of this
executive order, an employee (claimant) may seek to meet with the campus
administrator responsible for administering CSU nondiscrimination, anti-
harassment and non-retaliation policies, or a campus administrator designated by
the president (or chancellor, if the employee works at the Chancellor's Office),
to
determine the nature of any discrimination/harassment/retaliation claim and to
explore a resolution of the claim. Such claimant must be given information on
how to file a formal complaint during this meeting.
B. The claimant should request this meeting no later than twenty days after the event
giving rise to the claim or no later than twenty days after the claimant knew or
reasonably should have known of the event giving rise to the claim. The claimant
and campus administrator should meet as soon thereafter as possible, but no later
than fourteen days after the claimant has requested the meeting.
C. The employee may have a representative present during the discussion of the
claim with the campus administrator.
D. Whenever possible, the campus administrator shall attempt to resolve the claim
at
the Informal Level. A resolution at the Informal Level shall be documented.
E. The campus administrator may decide an informal resolution is inappropriate
and/or that the circumstances described by the claimant warrant investigation.
The campus administrator should invite the claimant to file a formal written
complaint pursuant to Section VI of this executive order if the campus
administrator concludes that an investigation is warranted.
F. If the claimant decides to file a formal written complaint, the investigation shall
be conducted pursuant to Sections VI and VII of this executive order.
G. If the campus administrator concludes that an investigation is warranted but the
claimant declines to file a formal written complaint at this time, the investigation
shall nevertheless be conducted.
H. Each campus shall have in place a procedure for investigating discrimination,
harassment and retaliation claims described in section V(G). The procedure is
to be consistent with Section VII of this executive order.
I. The campus administrator shall respond to the claimant no later than thirty sixty
days
after the meeting pursuant to Sections V(A) and V(B) is held, unless an extension
of the timeline has been obtained pursuant to Section VI(F) of this executive
order.
J. Generally, the response should include a summary of the allegations, a description
of the investigative process, the standard used to determine whether a violation
of
policy occurred, the evidence considered and a determination of whether the
allegations were substantiated.
K. The response shall inform the claimant of his/her option for filing a written formal
complaint under Section VI of this executive order, if he/she disagrees with the
finding of the investigation, and the timeline for doing so.
VI. Level I – Formal
A. An employee may enter the Formal Level procedure in one of three ways:
1. By filing a written formal complaint that was not preceded by an Informal
Level investigation;
2. By filing a written formal complaint at the invitation of the campus
administrator who, having discussed the allegations with the employee at the
Informal Level, determined that an investigation is warranted; or
3. In response to the results of an Informal Level investigation with which the
employee disagrees.
In the first two instances, an employee may file a written Formal Level I
complaint with the president (or chancellor, if the employee works at the
Chancellor's Office) no later than:
• Thirty days after the event giving rise to the complaint; or
• Thirty days after the employee knew or reasonably should have known of
the event giving rise to the complaint.
In the third instance, an employee may file a written formal Level I complaint
with the president (or chancellor, if the employee works at the Chancellor's
Office) no later than ten days after the Informal Level response.
B. If the employee chooses to file a written formal complaint, he/she shall either
complete the complaint form provided by the CSU (attached) or submit a signed
statement containing all of the information below:
1. The terms of the CSU systemwide policies against discrimination, harassment
or retaliation alleged to have been violated and, if applicable, the reasons
why
the investigation conducted under the Informal Level procedure did not
resolve the issue.
2. The specific harm resulting from the violation.
3. A detailed description of the factual events giving rise to the complaint.
4. The complainant's name, address, home and work phone numbers, job title,
and classification.
5. The name, address and telephone number of the representative, if any.
6. The date the complaint was filed.
7. The complainant's signature.
C. If the allegations contained in the complaint have not previously been evaluated
to
determine whether an investigation is warranted, the campus administrator
responsible for administering the CSU nondiscrimination, anti-harassment and
non-retaliation policies, or the campus administrator designated by the president
(or the chancellor, if the employee works at the Chancellor's Office) shall
do so.
D. If an investigation is deemed not warranted, the campus administrator shall
respond to the complainant in a timely manner, explaining why no investigation
is
conducted.
E. If an investigation is deemed warranted, the investigator shall hold a meeting
with
the complainant and the complainant's representative, if any, at a mutually
acceptable time and location.
F. The complainant shall inform the investigator of all issues and evidence known,
or which could reasonably be known, to the complainant that are related to the
complaint. If an investigation had been conducted at the Informal Level, the
complainant shall discuss the complainant's specific disagreements with such
findings and the relevant reasons and evidence. The complainant may present
no
additional issues after Level I.
G. The investigator shall carefully review the issues raised by the complainant
and
conduct an investigation pursuant to Sections VI and VII of this executive order.
Where an Informal Level investigation had already been conducted, the Level
I
investigation should be limited in scope to the complainant’s specific
disagreements with the findings at the Informal Level.
H. The campus administrator shall respond to the complainant no later than sixty
days after the Level I filing, unless an extension of the timeline has been obtained
pursuant to Section VIII(F) of this executive order.
I. Generally, the Level I response should include a summary of the allegations, a
description of the investigative process, the standard used to determine whether
a
violation of policy occurred, the evidence considered and a determination of
whether the allegations were substantiated.
VII. Level II – Formal
A. The complainant may file a Level II complaint with the Office of the Chancellor
no later than ten days after the Level I response if the complainant is not satisfied
with the outcome at Level I.
B. The request for a Level II review shall be in writing and shall detail the specific
disagreements with the Level I response.
C. The investigator shall meet with the complainant to discuss the complainant’s
disagreements with the Level I response. The investigator shall carefully review
the issues raised by the complainant and conduct an investigation pursuant to
Sections VII and VIII of this executive order. The investigation should be limited
in scope to the complainant’s specific disagreements with the findings at Level
I.
D. The University shall respond to the complainant no later than ninety days after
the
Level II filing, unless an extension of the timeline has been obtained pursuant
to
Section VIII(F) of this executive order.
E. Generally, the Level II response should include a summary of the allegations, a
description of the investigative process, the standard used to determine whether
a
violation of policy occurred, the evidence considered and a determination of
whether the allegations were substantiated. The Level II response shall be the
final decision.
VIII. General Provisions
A. The person who conducts an investigation under this executive order may be the
campus administrator in charge of administering CSU policies on
nondiscrimination, anti-harassment and non-retaliation or someone else
designated by the president/chancellor, provided that he/she shall be an MPP
employee or an external consultant, who is not within the administrative control
or authority of the person alleged to have discriminated, harassed or retaliated,
and was not involved in the investigation at the lower level(s), if any. All
investigations under this executive order shall be conducted in a reliable and
impartial manner.
B. CSU employees are required to cooperate with the investigation, be forthright
and
honest, and keep confidential the existence and details of the investigation.
C. The investigation shall include, at a minimum, formal interviews with the
claimant/complainant and the person alleged to have discriminated or harassed
(i.e., the respondent).
D. Both the claimant/complainant and the respondent shall have the right to identify
witnesses and other evidence for consideration in connection with the
investigation; however, the investigator may decide which witnesses are relevant
to the investigation.
E. The claimant/complainant may have a representative present during his/her
meeting with the campus administrator and/or the investigator to discuss the
discrimination or harassment claim/complaint. Where the respondent is a CSU
employee and the allegations are such that, if true, they could reasonably subject
the respondent to discipline, then the respondent shall be permitted to have
a
representative accompany him/her to the interview.
F. (1) Time limits set forth herein refer to working days, which are Monday
through Friday, excluding all officially recognized University holidays
or
closure of the campus where the claim/complaint originated.
(2) If the claimant/complainant, the respondent, the witnesses, the campus
administrator, the investigator, or the Chancellor's Office designee is
on
an approved leave of three days or more, the time limits shall be extended
by the length of time the individual is absent.
(3) Time limits set forth herein may also be extended by mutual agreement.
If
the University requests a time extension in order to conduct an effective
investigation and the claimant/complainant does not agree, the University
will issue a response within the timeline of this executive order based
on
the information available at that time. The investigation shall continue
until the University is satisfied its duty to respond appropriately to
allegations of discrimination, harassment or retaliation has been
discharged, provided the investigation is completed no later than one
hundred twenty days after the meeting is held between the claimant and
the campus administrator or between the complainant and the individual
designated to respond, as applicable.
G. CSU is not obligated under this executive order to investigate a complaint not
timely filed under its provisions. An untimely filed complaint may not be re-
filed. Notwithstanding the foregoing, CSU shall investigate the underlying
allegations in an untimely filed discrimination, harassment or retaliation
complaint if CSU determines the circumstances warrant investigation. The
investigation conducted in such circumstances does not resurrect the employee's
complaint or permit a subsequent filing of that complaint. The response issued at
the conclusion of the investigation will note that the complaint was untimely filed.
The investigation shall be conducted under the Informal Level procedure of this
executive order.
H. A complainant may withdraw a complaint at any time. The complainant shall not
be entitled to file any subsequent complaint on the same alleged incident under
the Formal Level procedure of this executive order. Although the complainant
is
barred from filing subsequent complaints on the same incident, the underlying
allegations of a withdrawal discrimination, harassment or retaliation complaint
shall be investigated if CSU determines the circumstances warrant investigation.
The investigation conducted in such a circumstance does not resurrect the
employee's complaint or permit a subsequent filing of that complaint. The
response issued at the conclusion of the investigation will note that the complaint
was withdrawn. The investigation shall be conducted under the Informal Level
procedure of this executive order.
I. If, after an investigation has been conducted, the president/chancellor concludes
it
is reasonably likely that CSU policy against discrimination, harassment or
retaliation was violated, he/she will take prompt and appropriate measures to
remedy any damage done by the violation and to prevent any future violations.
J. Failure by the University to respond timely shall permit the complainant to
be filed
at the next level.
K. By mutual agreement, the complainant and the University may consolidate
complaints on similar issues at any level.
L. Taking into account campus operational needs, CSU shall provide the claimant
and representative, if any, one hour release time for preparation of the claim
and
reasonable time for presenting the claim at the Informal Level upon their request.
M. Taking into account campus operational needs, CSU shall provide the
complainant and a representative, if any, reasonable release time for preparing
and presenting the complaint upon their request.
N. Where it is necessary for the complainant or his/her representative to have
access
to specific information for the purpose of investigating a complaint, the
complainant or his/her representative shall make a written request for such
information to the appropriate administrator. The complainant or his/her
representative shall have access to information within the policies and procedures
and laws governing confidentiality and privacy that are relevant to any issue
Appendix C Managers Who Can Assist with Filing Complaints
Manager Campus Office Phone
College of Arts and Humanities
Dean: Dr. Vida Semlien Music 186 278-3056
Associate Dean: Dr. Jose Diaz Music 179 278-7069
Jordan College of Agricultural Sciences and Technology
Dean: Dr. Charles Boyer Agricultural Sciences 102 278-2061
Associate Dean: Dr. Sandra Witte Agricultural Sciences 111 278-2061
Craig School of Business
Dean: Dr. Robert Harper Peters Business Bldg. 282 278-2482
Assoc. Dean: Dr. Kathleen Moffitt Peters Business Bldg. 282 278-2482
Kremen School of Education and Human Development
Dean: Dr. Paul Baere Education 210 278-0210
Associate Dean: Dr. James Marshall Education 205 278-0205
Lyles College of Engineering
Dean: Dr. Ram Nunn Engineering East 124 278-2500
Associate Dean: Dr. Manoocher Zoghi Engineering East 124 278-2500
College of Health and Human Services
Dean: Dr. Andrew Hoff McLane Hall 178 278-4004
Associate Dean: Dr. Jody Hironska-Jutesu McLane Hall 178 278-4004
College of Social Sciences
Dean: Dr. Liz Gonzalez Social Science 108 278-3013
Associate Dean: Dr. Xuanning Fu Social Science 108 278-3013
College of Science and Mathematics
Dean: Dr. Andrew Hoff Science 2, 301 278-3936
Office of Faculty Affairs
Assoc. VP for
Faculty Affairs: Dr. Michael Caldwell Haak Center, Library 4142 278-3027
Library
Dean: Mr. Peter McDonald Library 3213 278-2403
Associate Dean: Mr. David Tyckoson Library 3213 278-5678
California State University, Fresno: Complaint Form for Filing a Complaint of Harassment or Discrimination
Completion of this form is not required to formally initiate a complaint; however,
completing this form will assist
the review process. When completed, please take the form to the Office of the Dean
of Human Resources,
Powell 146, Joyal Administration Building. You will be contacted as soon as possible
for a confidential interview to
discuss the complaint.
1. Today's Date: ______________________________________________
2. Your name: _________________________________________________
3. Date of Birth: __________________
4. Signature: __________________________________________________
5. Status:
Student [ ] Faculty [ ] Staff [ ] Manager [ ]
Applicant [ ] Independent Contractor [ ]
6. Department: __________________________________________________
7. Contact Information
Home Address: _______________________________________________
Office Phone: _______________________ Home Phone: _______________________
Cell or pager: _______________________ Email: ____________________________
8. Person(s) against whom complaint is being made:
_____________________________________________________________
Status: Student [ ] Faculty [ ] Staff [ ] Manager [ ] Don't know [ ]
9. Allegation. Include dates and locations. Use additional sheets as necessary.
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
10. Has anyone been notified of this incident? If so, who and when:
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
11. Are there any other witnesses to the incident(s)? If so, who?
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
Select: September 2005
Appendix E-R – 2 of 2
California State University, Fresno Procedures for Filing a Complaint of
Harassment or Discrimination
The policy of California State University Fresno is to provide equal employment, education,
housing and services
without regard to race, color, religion, gender, national origin, pregnancy, marital
status, age (over 40), disability,
veteran's status or sexual orientation. The University does not tolerate acts of discrimination
or harassment.
Faculty, staff, management, students, applicants or independent contractors who feel
they have been subjected to
discrimination or harassment should notify the appropriate person of the campus policy
on harassment and
discrimination for acceptable procedures for filing a complaint. These procedures
are available to all employees
regardless of preliminary or permanent status, or their rank. Employees under collective
bargaining agreements
which provide procedures for addressing harassment or discrimination complaints (i.e.
CBA's and MPPs) are
required to use those procedures. The collective bargaining agreements are available
online at
http://www.calstate.edu/LaborRel/Collective_Bargaining.shtml.
The campus procedures are briefly presented below.
Where to file a complaint
Complaints may be filed with the Director of Human Resources, Mr. Justin A. Zerva.
Her office is located in Joyal
148 and she can be reached by campus mail (mail stop 3101), or phone (559) 278-2364.
Complaints may also be reported to any manager on campus (i.e. Management Personnel
Plan employee) who
shall promptly forward the complaint to the Director of Human Resources in a timely
manner.
Completing a complaint form
To facilitate the review process, complainants are strongly encouraged to complete
the form on the reverse side of
this page. This will provide us with information that is useful to responding as quickly
as possible to the complaint.
The process for responding to complaints
The Director of Human Resources will undertake fact-finding to determine how best
to proceed in accordance
with the appropriate administrative(s). The possible courses of action include resolution
at, at the most, direct level,
an investigation in conjunction with the personnel for disciplinary action. An attempt
will be made to resolve
complaints of harassment or discrimination and related problems at the lowest possible
level. Our goal, whenever
appropriate, will be to help those involved identify effective and mutually acceptable
solutions to the problem so that a
more formal process will not be necessary.
The Human Resources office serves as the first finder for all complaints involving
faculty, staff and managers.
Cases involving students may be referred to the Vice President for Student Affairs
depending on the circumstances.
Cases involving faculty are referred to the office of Academic Personnel once the
fact finding is completed.
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.