April 23, 2024
MEMORANDUM
TO: Dr. Saúl Jiménez-Sandoval
President
VIA: Dr. Xuanning Fu
Provost and Vice President for Academic Affairs
FROM: Dr. Raymond Hall
Chair, Academic Senate
RE: APM 220—Policy, Procedures, and Guidelines for the Periodic Review of Academic Programs—Approved
At its meeting of March 18, 2024, the Academic Senate approved APM 220, Policy, Procedures, and Guidelines for the Periodic Review of Academic Programs, as amended.
It is now being forwarded to you for final consideration.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Attachment
CC:
J. Goto
B. Muscat
J. Mullooly
J. Schmidtke
November 21, 2022
MEMORANDUM
TO: Ray Hall, Chair
Tinneke Van Camp, Vice Chair
Academic Senate
FROM: Nichole Walsh, Vice Chair
Academic Policy and Planning Committee
RE: AP&P Memorandum—APM 220 Program Review Revisions
This memorandum serves to inform the Academic Senate that the Academic Policy and Planning Committee moved to approve the following newly developed policy in conjunction with the University Graduate Committee at its November 10, 2022, meeting:
MSC: To forward the revised redline copy of APM 220 regarding adjustments to the abbreviated program review, as well as the removal of procedural language, to the Executive Committee for the Senate’s consideration.
The matter concerning process language in APM 220 was first brought to our attention by the Undergraduate Program Review Subcommittee in Fall 2019. The team needed to adjust the policy language to match the current procedures.
From that redline, AP&P voted to begin removing procedural language entirely, enabling the subcommittee to use its designed processes without continually amending the policy, provided those processes follow the policy. This is the current practice for all policies under AP&P’s purview. Unfortunately, the work was halted because of the COVID context.
When AP&P returned to the APM 220 project at the end of the 2021-2022 academic year, we received information through the University Graduate Committee that there was concern regarding the abbreviated review as it related to graduate programs.
In Fall 2022, the UGC voted unanimously to retain the abbreviated review and clarify that abbreviated review applies only to graduate programs with national accreditation.
Conversely, the Undergraduate Curriculum Committee had previously voted to be removed as a step in the program-review process for all externally reviewed undergraduate programs.
AP&P awaited the redline copy and presentation from the UGC so that our documents could be merged into one redline copy, with each committee addressing the areas under its respective purview.
AP&P is presenting the redline on behalf of both committees. Both groups would like the opportunity to answer questions regarding their respective, nonoverlapping revisions.
Attachments:
• Redline copy of APM 220 in PDF and DOCX formats
• Graduate Programs Abbreviated Program Review infographic
CC:
Venita Baker
Joy Goto
Tere Lopez
Bernadette Muscat
Jim Mullooly
APM 220
POLICY, PROCEDURES, AND GUIDELINES FOR THE PERIODIC REVIEW OF ACADEMIC PROGRAMS
Approved March 18, 2024
I. INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW
Periodic program reviews provide a mechanism for faculty to continuously evaluate the effectiveness, progress, and status of their academic programs.
A program review allows the department or program to evaluate its strengths and weaknesses in the context of the University’s mission and current and emerging directions within the discipline.
For purposes of program review, a program is defined as a course of study leading to a degree.
Academic programs are reviewed at least once every five to seven years. Except in special circumstances, such as interdisciplinary programs, program reviews include an evaluation of all undergraduate and graduate programs offered by the unit.
The primary purpose of program review is to improve the program by thoroughly and candidly evaluating:
• The response to the previous action plan and recommendations
• The program’s mission and goals and their relationship to the institution’s mission and strategic priorities
• The status of the curriculum, including changes within the discipline
• The level of involvement in assessing student learning outcomes, plans for future assessment activities, and program improvements based on assessment results
• The range and quality of research and creative activities
• The quantity, quality, and diversity of faculty and staff
• Activities related to student success, including advising, retention, and graduation rates
• The condition of physical facilities
• Involvement in outreach and service to the community
These reviews provide faculty with an opportunity to highlight program strengths and achievements, identify needed improvements, and address those needs through long-range plans that will endure through short-term administrative changes or budget crises.
Program reviews are integral to University planning, resource allocation, and other decision-making.
Regular program reviews also allow the University to publicly account for its use of public resources and develop support among its various constituencies.
At California State University, Fresno, the Dean of the Division of Research and Graduate Studies, or designee, serves as the review officer for graduate programs. The Dean of Undergraduate Studies, or designee, serves as the review officer for undergraduate programs.
To allow for reflection and input, the program-review process is extensive and involved.
The department prepares a self-study for each program under review. A review panel examines the self-study, visits the program, and prepares a report.
The department and dean are given an opportunity to comment on the review panel’s report. The report and comments are forwarded to the appropriate University-level committee for review.
After receiving the committee’s recommendations, the department writes a plan describing the actions to be taken in response to the recommendations arising from the review.
An action-plan meeting is then held during which the department, dean, and central administration agree upon priorities and resources for a final action plan.
Refer to “Program Review: Procedures and Guidelines for Review of Academic Programs” for additional details.
All changes to the procedures and guidelines for program review must be made in consultation with the appropriate program-review committee—the Undergraduate Program Review Subcommittee or University Graduate Committee.
Revised procedures and guidelines must be sent to the Academic Senate Executive Committee for review, although formal approval is not required.
II. THE SELF-STUDY
The self-study examines the current status of the academic program based on its activities and achievements since its previous program review.
The document should identify:
• Strengths and weaknesses in curriculum and instruction
• Student performance
• Student-learning-outcomes activities conducted since the prior review
• A Student Outcomes Assessment Plan for the period until the next review
• Faculty contributions in teaching, research, creative activities, and service
• Resource availability and needs
• Special features or services provided by the department
The self-study should serve as a vehicle through which the department, in conjunction with the University, can plan for the future.
It should include goals for program improvement, an action plan for achieving those goals, and strategies for measuring progress.
The self-study should include mechanisms for:
• Solving current problems
• Avoiding projected problems
• Building upon existing strengths
• Maximizing opportunities likely to develop within the discipline in the near future
The allocation of resources is an important matter for every program.
A self-study coordinator, selected from the department faculty by the department faculty, will oversee preparation of the report.
When a department is undergoing both a graduate and undergraduate program review, separate self-study coordinators should be selected.
All program faculty members should participate in preparing the self-study and be consulted before the final draft is prepared.
Because the department chair is responsible for the content, accuracy, and completeness of the self-study, the chair should continually and actively oversee preparation of the report.
The self-study coordinator is responsible for periodically meeting with the college or school dean to:
• Review progress on the self-study
• Share the content of the self-study as it develops
• Report the dean’s comments and recommendations to the department faculty
III. SITE VISIT AND REPORT BY A PANEL OF EXTERNAL EVALUATORS
The site visit will be conducted by a team of at least three consultants:
• An external expert in the discipline under review who has experience with student-outcomes assessment in that discipline
• A faculty member from within the department’s school or college
• A faculty member from the Campus but outside the department’s school or college
The department may elect to include a fourth team member representing alumni, community members, or other accreditation experts.
The chair of the academic department, in consultation with the department faculty and appropriate dean, shall submit to the program-review officer a list of three potential external consultants in each category.
IV. RESPONSES TO THE REVIEW PANEL REPORT
The self-study coordinator and department chair will work with the faculty to prepare a written response to the review panel’s report.
The departmental response should represent a good-faith effort to address every issue raised in the report.
It may also discuss significant changes or developments that occurred in the program after the self-study was completed.
The departmental response must be submitted to the college or school dean and the review officers within two weeks after receipt of the visiting panel’s report.
The college or school dean should address the issues raised in the review panel’s report and the department chair’s response.
The dean’s response shall be submitted to the department chair and review officers within one week and distributed to the department faculty for review.
V. UNIVERSITY COMMITTEE REVIEW
The Campus program-review committees will examine the review panel’s report and the responses from the department and dean.
The program-review committees will interview representatives of the program and administration as appropriate and provide one of the following recommendations:
Recommendation to Approve a Program with Notation of Exceptional Quality
Approval is recommended without reservation and includes recognition of specific areas
of program promise and excellence.
Programs recommended in this category may be considered for an award for program excellence.
These programs exhibit special strength in every aspect of the review process and reflect the best attributes of commitment, quality, and promise.
Recommendation to Approve a Program of Quality and Promise
Program approval is recommended with identification of specific areas requiring further
development and recognition of specific areas of achievement.
These programs meet all evaluative measures of quality but could improve in substantial ways, such as by developing a stronger student-recruitment plan.
Recommendation to Approve a Program for Conditional Continuation
Conditional approval is recommended with identification of specific areas requiring
significant improvement, the conditions to be met, and a reasonable timeframe for
achieving unconditional approval.
Conditional continuation is appropriate for a program that fails to meet expected quality standards when additional time or implementation of planned corrective actions could reasonably eliminate the deficiencies without impairing student progress, such as when additional space or equipment is needed.
Recommendation to Suspend a Program
Suspension may be recommended when the program received conditional continuation during
its most recent program review and both of the following conditions exist:
The program fails to meet established standards of quality necessary to ensure an
appropriate academic experience for students.
There is evidence that the deficiencies may be corrected within a specified period.
Quality standards include, but are not limited to:
• A minimum critical number of faculty members
• A minimum critical number of students
• Adequacy and frequency of required courses
• Adequate library holdings
• Appropriate physical facilities
A recommendation to suspend a program may lead to administrative action that:
Places a moratorium on new student admissions.
Requires currently enrolled students to be accommodated so they can complete the program.
Places a moratorium on reappointment to graduate-faculty status, when applicable to
a graduate program.
Removes the program’s catalog copy.
The degree title may remain on the trustee-approved Campus Academic Plan.
If evidence suggests that the program may later be successfully reconstituted, the conditions required to reopen it fully should be identified, along with a process supporting the removal of the suspension recommendation.
Discontinuation may result if the program cannot satisfy the identified conditions for successful reconstitution.
Recommendation to Discontinue a Program
Discontinuation may be recommended when the program received conditional continuation
during its most recent program review, fails to meet established quality standards
necessary to ensure an appropriate academic experience, and shows no evidence that
the deficiencies have been corrected within the specified period.
A recommendation to discontinue a program may lead to administrative action that:
Places a moratorium on new student admissions.
Requires currently enrolled students to be accommodated so they may complete the program.
Places a moratorium on reappointment to graduate-faculty status, when applicable.
Removes the program’s catalog copy.
A separate review of the implications of program termination will then be conducted.
This second level of review follows University policy and includes an assessment of the effects discontinuation would have on the University and its service area, faculty, facilities, students, and resources.
VI. THE ACTION PLAN
In consultation with the dean, the department chair and/or program coordinator will draft an action plan addressing every issue identified during the review.
For each issue, the action plan will identify:
The proposed action and expected outcome.
Cost and resource implications.
The source of funds or resources.
A timeline for completing the proposed action.
The action plan will be discussed during a Planning and Implementation Meeting called
by the Provost or designee.
Participants will include:
• The department chair
• The college or school dean
• The review officers
• A representative of the site-visit team, if requested by the department
The purpose of the meeting is to prioritize the action plan and obtain commitments for any resources needed to achieve its high-priority goals.
The dean and Provost may propose additional action items.
The department may be asked to revise the action plan, and another action-plan meeting may be called if necessary.
The finalized action plan will be signed by the department chair, dean, and Provost.
Each year, the Department Chair’s Annual Report to the Provost will include a progress report addressing the items in the action plan.
VII. ABBREVIATED CAMPUS PROGRAM REVIEW OF NATIONALLY ACCREDITED PROGRAMS
Programs that complete a national accreditation process through an official accrediting organization, including a site visit, may undergo an abbreviated Campus program review.
The abbreviated Campus program review recognizes the high standards maintained by national accrediting bodies and the extensive work required from program faculty in preparation for accreditation.
However, the abbreviated review still requires programs to evaluate their strengths and weaknesses specifically within the context of the University’s mission.
Procedure for Submitting an Abbreviated Campus Program Review
After the program receives the official letter from the accrediting organization granting national accreditation, the program chair will notify the program-review coordinator.
Upon receiving notification, the program-review coordinator will request that the program electronically submit the documents listed below by a specified date.
The deadline shall be no later than six months after receipt of the letter granting national accreditation.
The program must submit:
Evidence of national accreditation.
A copy of the site-visit report completed by the accrediting body.
A memorandum identifying where the expectations of APM 220 are addressed in the national-accreditation
documents.
An up-to-date Student Outcomes Assessment Plan.
A five-year analysis of enrollment trends, graduation rates, and achievement gaps
using the latest Office of Institutional Effectiveness program-review dataset as a
reference.
Review Process
Upon receiving the materials, the program-review coordinator will review the documents for content and forward them to the appropriate University committee—the Undergraduate Academic Program Review Subcommittee or University Graduate Committee.
The appropriate committee will review the materials and provide one of the five recommendations identified in Section V.
If committee members have questions about the program, the committee chair will follow up with program representatives.
If issues or concerns remain, the committee will issue recommendations to be considered for implementation in the program’s subsequent five-year action plan.
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.