MEMORANDUM

November 6, 2013

TO:

Lynn Williams and Kevin Ayotte, Chairs
Academic Senate

FROM:

Brian Tsukimura, Chair
Personnel Committee

RE: APM 315

The Personnel Committee has reviewed APM 315 and collected data that address the concerns of the senators that were submitted with the document.

Mr. Bob Murphy, Esq., was invited to address questions relating to faculty responsibilities for minors. He stated that the collective bargaining agreements for both Unit 3 and Unit 11 do not make the faculty member responsible for minors, thus relieving faculty members from liability. He also indicated that the Office of Civil Rights prefers policies that are simple so that procedures are obvious during times of duress.

The Office of Institutional Effectiveness provided student data indicating that there was only one 16-year-old and six 17-year-olds enrolled during the spring and fall semesters of the 2013 calendar year. We do not believe there are enough students to warrant revision of this policy.

Continuing and Global Education indicated that parents of minors are not required to sign a release form for their children to attend classes on campus. If instructors looked at student records, they would only see the month and day of birth, not the year.

We also found that nonmatriculated students are identified as “Undergrad/Transitory - Unitrack,” which confirmed the discussion from the Senate floor.

Based on these data, the Personnel Committee is returning APM 315 to the Senate unchanged but is including the information that senators appeared to request.

MEMORANDUM

September 26, 2013

TO:

Brian Tsukimura, Chair
Personnel Committee

FROM:

Kevin Ayotte, Vice Chair
Academic Senate

RE:

APM 315 Interim Revised Policy and Procedures for Fingerprinting and Conducting Background Checks - Personnel Committee

At its meeting of September 16, 2013, the Academic Senate voted to refer APM 315 to the Senate Personnel Committee “for review and potential additional revision in light of scenarios and contingencies discussed by the Senate during first and second reading.”

APM 315 INTERIM REVISED POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR FINGERPRINTING AND CONDUCTING BACKGROUND CHECKS

First Reading - September 9, 2013

Associate Vice President Caldwell summarized the rationale for the changes to the policy. None originated locally; instead, the changes were needed to comply with a Chancellor’s Office executive order.

Bob Murphy of Human Resources summarized the changes. They were needed to cover all employees who may work with minors.

Senator Henson expressed concern regarding the policy’s lack of clarity about events such as workshops that may include minors—for example, writing workshops in which secondary-school students come to campus.

Mr. Murphy stated that events in which minors come to campus with their own chaperones would likely not be subject to this policy. However, programs might want to have one fingerprinted individual who could assist with ad hoc supervision, such as helping a lost minor find their group.

Senator Miltiades of Social Work Education stated that the Fresno County Child Abuse Prevention Program might be a resource for providing training to faculty and staff on this issue.

Senator Fulop of Linguistics stated that all Fresno high-school students are allowed to take up to seven units at Fresno State. He asked whether this policy meant that all faculty members might have to be fingerprinted because high-school students may attend their classes.

Mr. Murphy stated that all 17-year-old matriculated students could be considered adults but that the Human Resources Office had not yet decided how to handle University High School students or minors who might enroll in regular courses.

Associate Vice President Caldwell stated that the memorandum of understanding between University High School and the university covers this issue for UHS students.

Nancy Akhavan of Educational Research and Administration stated that some programs require parents of minor children to sign a waiver before participation.

Senator Gonsoulin of Sociology asked whether Faculty Center rosters include a notation identifying high-school students enrolled in university classes. Senator Chapman answered yes.

Senator Chapman stated that some matriculated students are only 15 or 16 years old. Mr. Murphy stated that he would investigate how the policy might be revised to address this issue.

Senator Kensinger, statewide senator, requested confirmation that all matriculated students are considered adults. Mr. Murphy stated that all students who matriculate at age 17 are considered adults.

Second Reading - September 16, 2013

Senator Chapman of Modern and Classical Languages and Literatures asked how the policy would apply to a graduate student who might be both a Teaching Associate and a sex offender.

Associate Vice President Caldwell of Faculty Affairs stated that the individual would be fingerprinted under this policy if they worked with minors, just as all other faculty members would be. Graduate Teaching Associates are considered faculty members in Unit 11.

Associate Vice President Caldwell stated that the Personnel Committee revised APM 315 only to bring it into conformity with the Chancellor’s Office technical letter. Other issues raised by the Senate during the first reading were not considered.

If the Senate wished the Personnel Committee to consider those additional questions, it should refer the item back to the Personnel Committee with specific instructions.

Senator Gonsoulin of Sociology asked whether data existed regarding how often minors enroll in regular university classes, how many have parental waivers, and related questions.

Associate Vice President Caldwell stated that there were no current data. The information would have to be requested from the Office of Institutional Research or gathered through surveys.

MSC: To refer APM 315 to the Senate Personnel Committee for review and potential additional revision in light of scenarios and contingencies discussed by the Senate during first and second reading.

Attachment

CC:

M. Caldwell

 

 

 

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.