Minutes of the Library Subcommittee
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Ave, M/S ML 34
Fresno, California, 93740-8014
Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 2743
October 16, 2020 @ 2:00p
Members Present: D. Sisavath (Chair), D. Hornbuckle (Ex-Officio), K. Smith,
R. DeJordy, A. Becirbegovic, H. Ni, H. El-Razouk, K.
Tarrant, D. Lopez, P. Wu, D. Lopez
Members Excused: L. Jacobs
Guests: S. McDaniel
1. Called to order at 2:05 by Chair Sisavath
2. Introduction of current and new members
3. Communications and Announcements
a. None
4. Meeting Items
a. Dean’s Updates
i. D. Hornbuckle shared process on collections of crafting and introducing
work to colleges.
ii. S. McDaniel elaborated on process of crafting that includes small
discussion base with deans, presentation on communication process, and
how to engage with faculty.
iii. At a time of greatly reduced budget and resources, and with pivot to
mostly virtual instruction in Academic Year 2020-21, emphasis is on
student access and support. On trend nationally and in the CSUs to
critically review all of collections and subscriptions to reduce costs.
iv. Library budget flat or declined but cost increase.
b. Timeline for Communications
i. Phase 1: Plan to communicate within the next three weeks at Deans’
Forum, AALT meeting, and share with Library subcommittee to get advice
on communications process.
ii. Library Collections Review Process
1. Currently no budget
2. Conducting exercise of what will 13% reduction in allocation will
look like. Planning team conducts review by resource type and
discipline. Focus on retaining resources with high usage and that
serve the greatest number and breadth of students.
3. Long term benefit: the library will seek to mitigate impact of
cancellations or retrenchment through consultation, new web site,
clear procedures and usage of foundation funds.
5. Faculty Round-Robin
a. R. DeJordy: How are cost allocated such as subscription to database or
endnotes?
b. A. Becirbegovic: What is the future of Kanopy?
i. S. McDaniel: Expects something will continue.
ii. K. Smith: Kanopy version is demand driven. Currently, only faculty can
reserve films but looking to other streaming materials.
c. H. Ni: Is there an updated list of subscriptions that will be terminated in a year
due to budget?
i. S. McDaniel would like to include this as part of the web page and looking
to December 15th as target date on sharing the information.
d. K. Tarrant: How are decisions made on what will be cut and/or retain?
i. D. Lopez: There are three waves and library is cognizant of disruption.
The first wave: 2019-2020 cancellation examined on low usage of
journals and database. The second wave: 2020-21 review all resources in
a very granular level — relevance, student success other sources
available. A series of meetings scheduled to parse out the resources.
e. P. Wu: On presentation of collections, how will information be shared with the
university or faculty to give back to college?
i. D. Hornbuckle: Starts with deans’ forum, academic affairs, and library
subcommittee.
ii. S. McDaniel: Phase 1 on Nov 15th will have a concrete website. Phase 2.
On Dec 15th.
6. Next meeting date/time
a. Chair Sisavath will send out doodle poll to faculty members to set dates and
times for November and December meetings of this year.
7. Meeting adjourned at 3:11 pm.
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.