Minutes, Online/Blended Education Subcommittee

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Avenue, M/S ML 34
Fresno, California 93740-8027

Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743

Date: 9/7/2022

Members present: K. Tarrant (Chair), F. Kartch, W. Wu, C. Luna, S. Alteri, E. Aguilera, T. Terzian, M. Shepherd, F. Cassel Sharma

Members excused: M. Pirouz, V. Keyser, J. Kwon, E. Viera III

Members absent:

Ex-officio K. Clement, B. Berrett, M. Bennett, B. Muscat, N. Muñoz

Guests: C. Alvarez
The meeting was called to order by Chair Tarrant at 2:02 pm over Zoom.

1. Approval of the agenda

• MSC approving the agenda

2. Approval of the Minutes of 5/11/2022

• MCS approving the Minutes

3. Communications & Announcements

• Introduction of new member E. Aguilera, Asst. Professor at Kremen; rock climbs in free time
• Introduction of C. Alvarez, new ASI President
• Keep in mind when your term on the committee ends; this is located
https://academics.fresnostate.edu/senate/committees/curriculum/online.html
If your name is not on the committee list, please email K. Tarrant

Undergraduate Curriculum Committee update:

• Uncertainty of role of committee due to possible revision of APM 206. This committee and UCC don’t have clear guidance on how to move ahead with incoming courses; they either continue on with QLT or we just process them out of OnBase

• Possibility of enhanced policy role for committee about how Online/Blended education is managed at Fresno State
• Requirement for online instruction is that faculty member must be approved through training by IDEAS or equivalent training and have blessing from department
• Review is voluntary unless they want to offer course CSU wide
• Post Covid Task Force will go to individual colleges to discuss APM 206
• We are still actively doing voluntary reviews and reviews for CSU wide
• We will be drafting / revising our charge but waiting from updates regarding APM 206

Post Covid Task Force

• K. Tarrant who is on this task force; there are a number of faculty on this task force who are fundamentally against online education
• Attempting to make recommendations/proposals regarding online education - including # of courses, office hours, etc.
• If online education is something you value, talk to your senator about what makes good online education
• Resistance to having course reviews
• Online courses not as good a value for students or not as good as a physical in-person class, but this is not based on evidence from the research
• Online courses are seen as second-class by some; decision should be made by individual department
• Argument has been why rigorous review for online courses and not in-person courses

4. Old Business

• APM 206 - we’re still waiting
• We are still doing reviews for faculty who want reviews; K. Tarrant has been reaching out to faculty regarding this

5. New Business

• Course Reviews (New)
•• Course Assignments
•• 15 courses are coming to OnBase, but we don’t know how many will want review
•• New QLT rubric is on Chancellor’s site

Course/Instructor
Course/Instructor Primary Reviewer Secondary Reviewer Date Assigned to Reviewer Completion Date Comments
COUN 220 (G Sharma) Talar (CHHS) Falon (COSS) 3/3/22 3/23/22 Faculty contacted
ART 179 Tarrant (JCAST) Earl (KSOEDH) 5/11/22 9/1/22 Faculty contacted

• Course review refresher to occur after meeting adjournment

The Online and Blended Subcommittee adjourned at 2:45 pm.
Minutes submitted by: Suzan Alteri
Minutes approved by: Katy Tarrant, Chair

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.