Minutes, Online/Blended Education Subcommittee

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Avenue, M/S ML 34
Fresno, California 93740-8027

Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743

Date: 3/23/2022

Members present: K. Tarrant (Chair), C. Luna, W. Wu, S. Alteri, F. Kartch, E. Viera III, M. Pirouz, J. Kwon, V. Keyser; F. Cassel-Sharma, C. Luna, D’Aungillique Jackson (Ex-officio), K. Clement (Ex-officio), B. Berrett (Ex-officio), M. Bennett (Ex-officio), B. Muscat (Ex-officio)

Members excused:

Members absent:

Guests:

The meeting was called to order by Chair Tarrant at __12:02___pm over Zoom.

1. Approval of the agenda
● MSC approving the agenda
2. Approval of the Minutes of ______March 9, 2022_______
● MCS approving the Minutes
3. Communications & Announcements
● Need consensus from committee to pass on suggestions regarding APM 206 to Academic Senate Executive Committee this will be moved to New Business and discussed
● Subcommittee will still exist but our scope/charge may change
4. Old Business
● Amendments received and official approval finalized
● Pending amendments
5. New Business
● Full subcommittee course approvals
● Course Assignments

We need to pause this work until APM 206 is finalized
● Consensus needed on Senate/Exec/AP&P updates and communications on APM 206 and OBE
○ Synchronous modality through Digital Campus
○ APM 206 update to include instructor recertification and course re-evaluation (3-5 yr rotation)
○ Online course revision
● K. Tarrant attended Faculty Senate Executive Comm. meeting
● What is our stance on these three items?
● Synchronous modality through Digital Campus (previously was only asynchronous); student feedback is that synchronous is highly valued;
○ scheduling cannot code for both an asynchronous and synchronous so it has to be solely one or the other (important for reporting to Chancellor’s Office) - needs conversation at a higher level because this is a software problem
○ AP&P and Senate will require this
○ Could we have a percentage threshold for coding
○ Synchronous is decided by whether course has a specific time
○ Two tier system - CSU wide or only Fresno State (if only Fresno State we could waive the QLT review process and just do an accessibility review)
○ Can a faculty member teach all online, synchronous class? Faculty would not be on campus - how do they do service, etc.? (post covid taskforce is discussing this as it is CSU level policy issue)
○ Students like to have both options available - synchronous equals more connections, but asynchronous is great for students who work full-time jobs or have carework.
○ No blending - some will have scheduled class time and others will not;
○ How to convey to students that a class with a time will be online?
○ Need flexibility for both students and faculty
○ Poll launched that everyone can vote in (including ex-officios): 89% voted of having both synchronous and asynchronous and 11% voted no
● APM 206 revision to include instructor recertification and either 3 or 5 year rotation for recertification
○ Could create a recertification course that is not as many hours
○ ASI president - agree with this amended change, but not this academic year
○ Need to ensure faculty are doing recommended changes
○ 3 year might be better than five
○ Poll launched: 91% agree with recertification and 9% disagree

● Online course revision
○ AP&P: Vetting process for faculty and course was redundant and poor use of time for the people on this committee
○ Multi-faceted issue - could have a potential abbreviated review or could review requirement entirely (only for Fresno State only courses; CSU wide courses require QLT rubric)
○ CSU-wide courses would still need committee review
○ Would still need accessibility review
○ Rather than certify courses we certify professors
○ What if we kept faculty self-evaluation? Does this meet requirements
○ Change I am most concerned about - this is a quality control issue; we don’t always engage in best practices; we have set this up as being very supportive of faculty; this change does not necessarily serve our students
○ AP&P response - in-person classes aren’t regulated and we should trust the faculty; should have peer-review instead
○ Do people who are peer-reviewing also need to be certified? Yes; post-covid taskforce may address this
○ Peer review is not specific to modality and you could have someone who is not certified for online could do review
○ Share any other comments to Katy
The Online and Blended Subcommittee adjourned at __12:58___pm.
Minutes submitted by: ____Suzan Alteri_______
Minutes approved by: Katy Tarrant, Chair

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.