Minutes, Online/Blended Education Subcommittee

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Avenue, M/S ML 34
Fresno, California 93740-8027

Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743

December 1, 2021

Members Present: V. Van Vleck (Chair), J. Kwon, C. Luna, M. Pirouz, W. Wu, E. Vieira III, S. Alteri, K. Tarrant, M. Shepherd, T. Terzian, H. Xia, M. Bennett, B. Muscat

Members Absent: V. Keyser, F. C. Sharma, F. Kartch, B. Berrett

Guests: K. Clement

Meeting called to order at 12:03 pm

1. Approve/ adopt/ amend agenda
Approved with correction - ITAL 1B will be reviewed in January M/S/C

2. Approve/ amend minutes from Nov. 17, 2021
M/S/C

3. Communications & Announcements

• Inquiries about how to submit for online course review; V. Van Vleck clarified process
• Submit through OnBase
• Document was created by V. Van Vleck and E. Vieira III
• Document can be put on Curriculum Development site with caveat that it could change
• There have been issues with course enrollments for committee reviews, please email M. Bennett
• When reviewing, please look at DEV site
• If a course is completely online, score for all 24 objectives. A completely online course is if the course content is 67% or more.
These courses must meet every core objective with a score of 2 or 3
• If a course is blended and 21% - 66% of course content is online, a case could be made for an objective getting a 1 but still being

• approved. Must discuss with other reviewers and committee members
• Please do not send reviews to instructors until after both reviewers have met to discuss the course and overall review
• Question raised: Is it true or best pedagogical practice that language based courses shouldn’t be closed captioned (which goes against an objective)?
• K. Clement: something for the committee to research? What is the university policy? How is the course deviating from that policy and why? What is best practice for language courses?
• M. Bennett: Will also run by B. Berrett

a. Ex officio communications
None

4. Nominations/ Election of In-coming Subcommittee Chair K. Tarrant nominated M/S/C unanimously

5. Course/Proposal Reviews (Also see “status PDF” attached/ shared drive)

a. Active Reviews
TARGET DATE: Dec 1 Notes as of 12/1/21
DS 123 (Y Tanai) Approved (M/S/C)
MCJ 112 (J Therkelson)) Approved (M/S/C)
MCJ 116 (J Therkelson) Approved (M/S/C)
COMM 114 (S Juarez) M. Pirouz will head this course and set meeting with instructor;
moved to January meeting for approval Other reviewers are: V. Keyser and H. Xia
CI 135 (M Lomeli/P Lopez) F. C. Sharma finishing review; moved to January meeting for approval. Other reviewer: V. Van Vleck
ITAL 1A (A Polegato) C. Luna finishing review; moved to January meeting for approval TARGET DATE: Jan mtg
ITAL 1B (A Polegato) K. Tarrant will set meeting with instructor Other reviewer: T. Terzian
ITAL 110(A Polegato) S. Alteri will contact V. Keyser and F. Kartch to meet

NURS 223 (B Tune)
ASCI 125 (K Tarrant)
CFS 138 (A Roach/ Provonost)
MCJ 121 (C Higgins-Dobney)
J. Kwon and W. Wu 2 Reviews needed
V. Van Vleck will finish review
M. Pirouz and E. Vieira III 2 Reviews needed
K. Tarrant review complete, S. Alteri almost complete
MCJ 178 (C Higgins-Dobney)
V. Van Vleck will finish review Other reviewer is M. Pirouz

General notes:
• Committee does not require changes from amendment form to be made prior to approval of course by committee
• Suggestion to add signature for instructor that states they are aware of changes and will make them
• Talar will draft a Google Doc template for reviews to be shared between reviewers
• Upcoming courses will need to be reviewed under new rubric once it is released
• Any remaining December courses not approved have moved to the January meeting

6. Celebrate the conclusion of OBE’s formal Fall 2021 meeting schedule!
• V. Van Vleck said she enjoyed working with all of us on the committee
• A lot of cheers and thank you’s to V. Van Vleck for her work as chair

7. Meeting adjourned at 12:56 pm

Agenda:
Approve / adopt / amend agenda
Communications & Announcements
Nominations / election of In-coming subcommittee chair
Course / Proposal reviews
Celebrate conclusion of fall

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.