A Resource Guide for Managing Risk in Service Learning






Introduction
Service Learning in the CSU
Faculty, students, and administrators in the California State University (CSU) have been partnering with their local communities since the first CSU campus was founded in 1857. These partnerships not only improve the quality of life across California, they significantly contribute to student learning, advance faculty teaching and research, support CSU programs, and positively contribute to California communities.
Beginning in the 1990s, the CSU began to recognize the value of service learning as a vehicle that would meet the state’s changing educational needs while also imparting vital civic skills and knowledge. In 1997, with the establishment of the first-of-its-kind strategic plan on community service learning, this systemwide effort began to take shape. Infrastructure was established at campuses and the systemwide office; each of the CSU’s 23 campuses has an office of community service learning/community engagement with a designated leader. Although each campus has created its own unique infrastructure to support service learning, the end results have been consistent—quality service–learning experiences for CSU students.
In 1999, Governor Gray Davis called for a community service requirement for all students of California’s public higher education institutions. In response, the California State University Board of Trustees passed a resolution ensuring that the CSU would provide service-learning opportunities for all students.
Since that time, the CSU’s reputation as a leader in community service learning has risen to national prominence due to its unique 23-campus and systemwide coordination. Faculty and student enthusiasm and involvement have soared, data collection efforts have begun, many campus and community partnerships have been established, and the breadth and depth of service learning in both general education and major-based courses have multiplied.
The CSU continues to take bold steps to promote service learning as an educational methodology that prepares students for the complexities and rewards of lifelong learning, community engagement and professional success. In March 2008, as the Office of Community Service Learning in the Chancellor’s Office celebrated its 10-year anniversary, it also ushered in a new name, the Center for Community Engagement, and adopted a broader vision and mission that serves as the driving force to advance the CSU’s commitment to serving the economic, public policy and social needs of our state.
Definition of Service Learning
The following definitions provide important distinctions for this resource guide, which is intended to cover the intricacies of risk management as they relate specifically to service learning. (The guide is not intended to address other types of community service or experiential education.):
Service Learning
A teaching method that promotes student learning through active participation in meaningful
and planned service experiences in the community that are substantively related to
course content. Through reflective activities, students enhance their understanding
of course content, general knowledge, sense of civic responsibility, self-awareness
and commitment to the community.
Service-Learning Course
An academic course (in any discipline) that provides students opportunities to participate
in organized service activities that meet community needs while linking the community
service experiences to the course content. This makes service learning a very different
experience than community service.
Community Service
Any work provided by individuals that contributes to the quality of life in the community.
Community service work can be provided in several ways and for different purposes.
Students may be involved in community service on their own, with a group or club,
or through academic course work. When the community service is part of the academic
course work, and when the service relates directly to the course content, it is considered
service learning.
Risk Management in the CSU
Each of the California State University’s 23 campuses are responsible for administering their risk management program in a manner that will attempt to minimize risk to students, employees, and visitors and protect the property of the campus. Each president has designated a risk manager to assist the campus administrators in maintaining the campus risk management policies and practices.
The California State University Risk Management Authority (CSURMA) is an association of the CSU and its auxiliary organizations joined to protect member resources by providing broad coverage and quality risk management services that stabilize risk cost in a reliable, economical and beneficial manner.
Student Academic Field Experience for Credit Liability Insurance Program (SAFECLIP), Student Professional Liability Insurance Program (SPLIP)
In 2006/07, CSURMA developed two insurance programs, SAFECLIP and SPLIP, for CSU students involved in off-campus learning programs for both service learning and clinical experience.
SAFECLIP provides general and professional liability coverage for students enrolled in service-learning course sections for which they receive academic credit. In essence, the program provides indemnity, including legal defense costs for students, faculty, campus and host institution (when required by contract/agreement), if there is a claim or lawsuit involving injury to others or damage to property in connection with service learning and other academic fieldwork experiences.
Similarly, SPLIP provides general and professional liability coverage as well as educator’s errors & omissions liability coverage for students enrolled in nursing, allied health, social work or education credential programs of the CSU who also perform community service or volunteer work for academic credit.
For a summary of these coverages, see Appendix items D and E.
Risk Management in Service Learning: Why This Resource Guide?
The CSU continues to be a national leader in service learning. Because of the large numbers of students participating, and in response to questions about risk management issues related to the placement of students at learning sites, a systemwide meeting between service-learning directors, faculty and risk managers, held in April 2001, recommended the development of three working groups to discuss and address the risk challenges of the program.
The Research Process
Between 2001 and 2002, the working groups met to research and draft forms, checklists and content for the manual. They worked with general counsel to assure the manual would be consistent with university regulations, and to determine how related policies could be integrated. The culminating result was the distribution of the Community Service Learning in the California State University – Best Practices for Managing Risk in Service Learning manual in 2002.
(See www.calstate.edu/cce/resource_center/servlearn_risk.shtml for archival information.)
In 2010, through an internal CSU systemwide audit process, it became apparent that the manual should be reviewed and updated accordingly. In order to address University Audit’s recommendations, the systemwide Office of Risk Management & Public Safety, together with the CSU Center for Community Engagement, assembled a committee of campus risk managers and community engagement professionals to review and update the manual. Through a series of meetings, peer review and research, the manual has been updated and renamed to Community Service Learning in the California State University – A Resource Guide for Managing Risk in Service Learning.
The end product is a practical resource guide for managing risk in service learning. The following pages contain recommended forms, checklists and descriptions that can be used to help build new service-learning partnerships while improving upon existing partnerships with community-based organizations (also referred to as “learning site” throughout the resource guide). The forms provided in this resource guide outline the standards for managing risk in service learning. Additionally, the appendix calls attention to some reference documents mentioned in this guide as well as those that may be beneficial to campuses. An online collection of frequently asked questions (FAQ) is also available on the CSU Center for Community Engagement’s website at www.calstate.edu/cce/resource_center/servlearn_risk.shtml.
The continued focus is on creating and developing positive, safe, out-of-classroom learning experiences for all service-learning students. A flow chart is included to walk the reader through the risk management process in a logical and easy-to-follow manner. Designed to work together, the segments contained in this resource guide can also be used independently in instances where portions of the process are already underway on a campus. As the CSU moves forward in providing quality and impactful service-learning opportunities for all its students, it can serve as a guide to the necessary steps in creating new opportunities. Taking into account numerous perspectives, the resource guide is intended to represent a commonsense and reasonable approach.
This resource guide is primarily to be used by service-learning faculty and service-learning/community engagement staff on CSU campuses. While some information will apply to other types of experiential education and community service, this resource guide is not intended to cover the intricacies that exist in each of the different types of experiential education. Service-learning placements differ from community service placements because of the academic requirement associated with them. All types of experiential education need to examine risk management issues as they pertain to their programs. While this resource guide is not intended to be all-inclusive, it may serve as a valuable resource for other experiential education experiences, such as internships. The online FAQ website contains some additional information and resources. Additionally, if you question the recommendations in this resource guide as they relate to other types of experiential education or community service, please have a conversation with your risk manager.











Guiding Principles to Reduce Risk in Service Learning
Service learning links community service experiences with course content to create a positive, safe and valuable out-of-classroom learning experience. For a successful program, faculty members, students, college staff and community partners must work together as a team to make the most of the service-learning experience and manage the unique risks that exist.
By diligence and commitment to detail, many of the risks can be reduced or mitigated. There is insurance available to protect the CSU as well as the learning site, if the proper agreement is in place. Students can avoid unsafe situations when everyone is familiar with the placement details and a proper risk assessment has been completed.
Academic and student preparation with a learning plan and orientations will greatly enhance the results and continue to make the service-learning experience meaningful. Flexibility is a must when alternative placements or special student needs are involved.
Strive to equip the students to become responsible partners in their own placement as models of good conduct and representatives of the CSU by providing orientations, learning objectives and procedures for emergencies. These lessons are lifelong character-building experiences that will benefit the student long after they have graduated.
Using this Guide
The following pages are an overview of the process and tools that can be used by faculty, campus service-learning staff and risk managers.
Risk Management in Service-Learning Flow Chart for New Service-Learning Placements
Familiarize yourself with the Guiding Principles to Reduce Risk in Service Learning
Develop a Risk Assessment Plan
Develop Learning Plan & Review and Sign with Students
Develop Service-Learning Agreement
Determine if you will do a Pre-placement Risk Assessment and/or a Site Visit
Develop and deliver student orientation in partnerships with the Learning Site
Build Relationships with your Campus Risk Manager and Contracts Officer
Revisit Service-Learning Agreement, as needed and/or if more than 5 years old
Tools
Process for Implementing the Risk Management Tools
The tools and strategies developed are the result of the CSU’s more than 10 years of practical experience in implementing risk management procedures for service learning. The forms in this resource guide are templates and outline the recommended standards for campuses to follow:
- Develop a Risk Assessment Plan
- Pre-placement Risk Assessment (this may or may not include a site visit)
- Service Learning Agreement
- Student Orientation
- Learning Plan
These guidelines have been designed so that there is a consistent approach within the CSU regarding several key risk management components. Campuses have discretion to use the forms, language and strategies they have developed as long as they uphold the spirit of the standards outlined in this guide. For example, the revised two-page Service Learning Agreement (SLA) does not require a scope of work because that information is included in the Learning Plan; however, campuses that have in the past included the scope of work in the SLA and want to continue to do so, can. As a rule of thumb, any recommendation and changes should involve consultation among the service-learning office, faculty member, campus risk manager, campus counsel and contracts, services and procurement, as applicable.
As individual components, the tools and strategies developed to reduce risk in service-learning placements can be implemented separately, but they can also be used together as a whole process when starting new partnerships with community-based organizations. The flow chart on the previous page outlines the process of creating a placement for a service-learning course. Additionally, Appendix A includes a Quick Reference of Good Practices in Service Learning that models the philosophies of service learning and attempts to take into account the best interests of the student, faculty member and university.
Build Relationships: As with any partnership, the first step is to take time to build relationships; this includes your university risk manager as well as your contracts officer. Faculty interested in creating a new service-learning course or working with a new community partner are strongly encouraged to work with their campus service-learning office, which can provide a significant amount of assistance. Campus risk managers can help assess the risk involved with any service-learning placement and advise how to conduct any partnership with the least amount of risk exposure. The job of risk managers is not to prohibit educational experiences that may seem “too risky,” but rather to find ways to reduce the amount of risk and liability exposure, so that the service-learning opportunity is a safe, healthful and fulfilling educational experience for all parties involved.















This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.