Minutes of the Graduate Committee
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5200 N. Barton Ave M/S UL34
Fresno, California 93740-8014
Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743
October 10, 2023
Members Present: M. López (Chair), J. Goto (ex officio), L. Diala, A. Hoskins, D.
Lent,
N. Mahalik
Members Absent : M. Crawford, S. Hernandez
Guests: N/A
The meeting was called to order at 2:03 p.m. by Chair López.
I. MSC to approve the minutes from October 3, 2023
II. MSC to approve the agenda for October 10, 2023
III. Communication and Announcements
● Re: APM 311: Teaching Associates -- M. Lopez shared that Personnel
Committee has concern regarding whether FAFSA was included in other
policies, but confirmed that language was changed throughout
● Re: APM 206: Online Courses -- M. Lopez has been asked to serve in an
ad-hoc committee with reps from UGC, AP&P, and the blended programs
committee to review and revise the policy.
o L. Diala shared that her program is working under the max percentage
of online courses set by the Provost’s office.
● Re: Blended Degree Programs -- D. Lent shared that the committee
working on the creation of blended degree programs plan to submit program
proposals preemptively, in advance of the university having a clear policy
and/or processes in place.
o J. Goto shared, from CSU Grad Deans meeting, that Fresno State is not
alone in still working out these policies/procedures.
IV. Geology - Catalog Revision - Admission Requirements
● N. Mahalik -- the two changes are the removal of the GRE and the
requirement that an advisor be identified prior to admission. GEOL cited
Biology program as precedential example.
o D. Lent -- the motivation for Biology was to make sure that students
could graduate in two years. However, issues may arise if student/advisor
pairing is not a fit; what do you do when no one can support them.
● M. Lopez asked if the faculty therefore needs to approve of addition of
person to lab group?
o D. Lent said that there is a policy requiring a meeting with advisor and
that all students are thesis students.
● M. Lopez asks about how students find out about work done by faculty.
o D. Lent shared that the website is now being updated regularly to
include what projects are available by faculty, when positions are
available, etc.
o N. Mahalik shared that it seems like it could be limiting for students to
need to be assigned a topic before discovering their research interests. In
his department, the students spend the first year learning about their own
interests with the ability to switch faculty.
o D. Lent shared that for their students giving them a chance to explore
resulted in no graduating on time; 1.5 years of research is required for the
research and the only way to keep students on track was to come in with
an advisor. Also, if students do not work out, usually a switch is not
problematic if it is due to the change being due to a difference in path
rather than issue of performance.
● D. Lent suggested having written policies for students changing labs and
to use quadrant IV of the application to include the advisor’s name.
● MSC to approve catalog changes for MS in Geology.
5. APM 218 - Policy on Credit for Prior Learning
● M. Lopez – confusion over numbering of policy -- the old APM 218
covered history GE graduation requirements.
○ New APM 218 is for prior learning.
● M. Lopez reminded that up to 9 units can be transferred from a previous
institution. Would prior learning units fall within this max?
○ D. Lent -- the language limits amount counted towards undergraduate
and not to graduate.
○ A. Hoskins commented that there is a difference between undergrad
and graduate courses in that undergraduates take many lower level
courses from outside of the major while graduate students are taking all,
or a vast majority of their courses, in the specific department.
○ J. Goto is concerned about the potential of double counting service
credit for both the undergraduate and graduate courses thereby double
counting the work.
○ M. Lopez commented that leaving max limit consideration to an
external agency might allow for violation of internal policies on re: external
units.
● J. Goto would like to see APM moved to the grouping that is for both
undergraduate and graduate students.
○ D. Lent -- the only language for graduate students in 218 is about
Armed Service education.
○ J. Goto does not think that we have had a case previously that dealt
with using examinations based on educational experiences in the armed
services.
○ D. Lent is concerned that work from the military might not align with
appropriate courses in the program.
● M. Lopez suggested that the DRGS policies state that any credit for prior
experiences not exceed the 9 outside units that can be transferred
currently.
● MSC for M. Lopez to write memo to Senate with concerns: 1) change
numbering of APM to be in area of both levels of programs and 2) that
restrictions placed on undergraduate be applied to both types of programs
striking out baccalaureate. Passed unanimously.
MSC to adjourn at 2:59 p.m.
The next meeting of the University Graduate Committee will be at 2:00 p.m. on
Tuesday, October 24 in TA 117.
Agenda for Tuesday, October 24, 2023
I. Approval of minutes from October 10, 2023
II. Approval of agenda for October 24, 2023
III. Communications and Announcements
IV. Catalog Change Request: MA in Reading
V. Review of Interdisciplinary Studies MA/MS
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.