Minutes of the Graduate Committee, California State University, Fresno, November 9, 2021

MINUTES OF THE GRADUATE COMMITTEE
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO
5241 N. Maple, M/S TA43
Fresno, California 93740-8027
Office of the Academic Senate Ext. 8-2743

November 9, 2021

Members Present: M. López (Chair), K. Capehart, D. Lent, R. Sias, D. Walker, and
J. Marshall (ex officio); M. Jagtap (student rep)

Member Excused: B. Sethuramasamyraja, G. Sharma

The meeting was called to order at 2:03 PM by Chair López on Zoom.

I. Minutes: MSC to revise and approve the minutes for October 26, 2021
II. Agenda: MSC to approve the Agenda for November 9, 2021
III. Updates, Announcements, and Communications:
▪ J. Marshall suggests that before the end of the semester we invite interim Dean Joy Goto
to an upcoming meeting or event. Chair López will reach out to Dean Goto to arrange to
meet on November 30th
.
▪ Chair López proposes that the final meeting of the semester, on December 7, be set
aside for socialization.

IV. Catalog Change Requests
● Three psychology programs, Applied Behavior Analysis, School Psychology and General
Psychology, are changing language to remove GRE from their admission requirements.
Additionally, School Psychology will remove the CBEST from required material for
admissions.
○ A. Hoskins asked about the 72-unit requirement for one degree. This is
appropriate for the specific program in question. D. Walker asked why we are
reviewing these, since GRE was waived. It was clarified the waiver of GRE was
only temporary and these requests are to be made permanent. It was noted by J.
Marshall that these are programmatic changes, and these require approval from
the UGC. Chair López notes that many of these approvals are akin to consent
calendar items and may require minimal review prior to approval. J. Marshall
reiterates that this is part of shared governance, and these programmatic
changes require a full review, even if changes are trivial, as the changes may
impact various offices and processes across the University.
○ MSC to remove GRE for the three graduate programs in Psychology (Applied
Behavior Analysis, School Psychology and General Psychology) and the CBEST
from the School Psychology.

● The MS in Biology program proposed changes to their program description and clarified
the admissions requirements to be admitted to the MS program. J. Marshall
communicated issues with ambiguity in language resulted in possible disenfranchising
international students. Chair López wanted to know if the GRE was meaningful in any
way and what went into the Biology Department's decision to require GRE for some but
not others. J. Marshall notes that some programs already require some students to take
the GRE but not others, so there is precedence. K. Capehart asked how this GRE
requirement for international students isn’t discriminatory. J. Marshall notes that we
don’t often have the ability to evaluate the quality of foreign degrees and the GRE allows
for additional scrutiny. D. Walker voiced her concern about equity.
○ M. Jagtap notes that GRE scores can result in rejection of international student
visas. She thinks that GRE should be required for international students and have
posted the specific score requirements that students must meet for admission.
She noted that a focus on analytical writing would be preferable. Chair López will
take notes and potentially follow-up with the International Office (S. Lam)
regarding concerns listed by student representative M. Jagtap.
○ MSC to approve catalog revision proposal for the MS in Biology.
● Industrial Technology program requests that AGRI 220 be removed, and that IT 285 be
added to the courses available to fulfill the Graduate Writing Requirement. J. Marshall
notes that if the GWR is embedded in a course, it must be a course that everyone takes
as part of their graduate curriculum. K. Capehart and R. Sias were both concerned about
the rigor of embedding this requirement in a course. Chair López points out that the
syllabus lays out the requirements and assessment to fulfill the requirement. As long as
University standards are met, the course embedded GWR should fulfill requirements.
○ MSC to approve catalog revision for the MS in Industrial Technology for the
Graduate Writing Requirement.

V. History is requesting the elimination of the Certificate in Teaching American History.
● Chair López provided history regarding creation of an option and the certificate. The
Certificate provides no benefit to teachers and no individual has participated in this
program.
○ MSC to approve proposal to discontinue the Certificate of Advanced Study in
Teaching American History.

VI. MSC to adjourn at 2:55PM.

The UGC’s next meeting is scheduled for November 30, 2021 at 2:00 p.m. via Zoom.

Agenda for November 30, 2021
I. Approval of minutes from November 9, 2021
II. Approval of Agenda for November 30, 2021
III. Updates and Announcements
A. Reminder - End-of-semester get-together December 7, 5:00-6:30 p.m. at Mad
Duck
B. APM 233
IV. Introductions: Interim Dean Joy Goto
V. COVID GRE waivers -- Fall 2022

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.