PERIODIC EVALUATION OF TENURED FACULTY
I. INTRODUCTION
Tenured faculty have earned the right under California law to continued employment by virtue of probationary and tenured service during which both competence and performance have been rigorously reviewed and found to meet high professional standards. Therefore, in light of the special nature of tenured appointments, performance appraisals are formative in that the focus is upon the enhancement of instructional performance and fulfillment of faculty responsibilities.
Periodic evaluation of tenured faculty serves as a means to stimulate the on-going professional development of faculty and to assure the overall quality of instruction. Further, Title 5, CSU Policy, and the collective bargaining agreement require that tenured faculty not subject to promotion review shall be evaluated at least every five (5) years. The evaluation shall include assessment by the department chair, department committee, and school/college dean. The review will consider teaching effectiveness and university and community service.
II.STANDARDS
Faculty workload is defined as 12 WTUs plus 3 WTU equivalencies of indirect instructional activity (student advisement, curriculum development and improvements, and committee assignments).
Teaching Effectiveness: This will be assessed in accordance with the current Policy on Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness. (Academic Policy Manual, 322-1)
University Service: The faculty member being evaluated must provide evidence of consistent university service. (Academic Policy Manual, 325.II.D.3).
Optional: Faculty members may also choose to include, and have considered, research, scholarly, and creative activities, and/or community service.
In situations when tenured faculty are provided assigned time for RSCA (e.g., to remain in alignment with accreditation requirements), departments and colleges/schools may implement specific RSCA checklists for evaluations of tenured faculty. These standards are to be written by the department or school in question and approved by the college/school dean.
III. PROCESS
The periodic evaluation of tenured faculty shall be conducted by a committee consisting of a minimum of three (3) tenured professors elected by the tenured faculty of the department. 1The department chair may submit a separate assessment individually or in consultation with department tenured faculty members. In the case that the department chair is being evaluated under the provisions of this policy, and not APM 125, a department committee may be established to conduct the evaluation of the chair. If any stage of the evaluation has not been completed within the specified period of time, the periodic evaluation shall be automatically transferred to the next level of review or appropriate administrator, and the faculty unit employee shall be notified.
1 Committee members may include Fresno State faculty from outside the department or program.
The faculty member being evaluated shall submit a current vita and a 1-2 page reflection on their accomplishments over the last five years.
The committee shall develop an assessment report based upon the committee’s evaluation of the quality and currency of: 1) materials submitted by the faculty member; 2) peer and student evaluations conducted in the last five years; and 3) relevant materials in the Personnel Action File. The assessment report of the committee and the department chair evaluation will be shared with the tenured faculty member. If the assessment is negative, the faculty member shall be provided the opportunity to meet and discuss with the department chair and/or committee before the assessment is forwarded to the subsequent level of assessment. The department chair and/or committee may amend their assessment as a result of this or these meetings. The faculty member may also submit their comments regarding the assessment in writing. The assessment report of the department chair and the committee, with relevant documents used in the evaluation process, shall be forwarded to the dean along with any recommendation the committee and/or chair choose to make. The dean shall consult with the chair and committee and may add an independent assessment before discussing the assessments and any recommendations with the faculty member. The entire assessment report, including the dean’s assessment, shall be placed in the faculty member’s Personnel Action File.
The faculty member being evaluated may submit a rebuttal within seven (7) days of the issuance of the final assessment report. This rebuttal is to be included in the Personnel Action File.
IV. OUTCOMES
An unsatisfactory overall evaluation will mandate that an interim evaluation be conducted the following academic year using the same criteria and standards.
If the periodic evaluation conducted is a result of a previously unsatisfactory evaluation, the following actions may be taken: scheduling of further interim periodic evaluations; additional student and/or peer evaluations of teaching; establishment of performance goals with scheduled reporting of progress; other professional development activities designed to improve specified aspects of performance; and if appropriate, verbal or written recommendations (development program) or a recommendation for discipline pursuant to Article 19 of the collective bargaining agreement.
Approved by the Academic Senate May 1981
Approved by the President May 1981
Revised February
1995, September 2026
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.