IN THEIR OWN WORDS: STUDENT STORIES FROM THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
By Cory Cowan, Research Analyst; Giang Huynh, Research Assistant; and Alex Nottbohm, Research Analyst
May 2021
In March 2020, the coronavirus outbreak, COVID-19, was declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization. The following months ushered in unprecedented change, loss, and disruption for Fresno State’s students, faculty, and staff.
During the early stages of the pandemic, the university was required to make substantial changes to its typical daily operations, leaving students to quickly adapt to a new normal. Through a series of virtual interviews and focus groups with students in 2020, we heard 32 students’ stories about being Fresno State students during the COVID-19 pandemic.
We also recognize that 2020 was a tumultuous year, with many historical events that significantly affected our students and the Fresno community at large. These included the Black Lives Matter movement in June and statewide wildfires, including the local Creek Fire in September, which uprooted many students from their homes.
Although these events considerably affected many of our students, this study focused on exploring students’ experiences and better understanding the effects of living through a global pandemic.
SPRING 2020
“I think the thing that was hard for me is that it kind of just happened all of a sudden. I went on a conference trip, and I was on the trip when I got the email that school would be transitioning online. So I didn’t know my last day was my last day.
“I do okay with online school, but I think the thing that was hard was the expectations and the trajectory changed so fast. And I know that’s not anyone’s fault because it’s kind of just what happened, but it’s been hard.
“And I worked on campus too, and so my job was deemed nonessential. So it’s like to not have class, to not have graduation, to not have a job in the same week—it’s a lot.”
In spring 2020, we interviewed seven students about their experiences with the transition to virtual instruction and the weeks that followed Fresno County’s shelter-in-place orders.
Students described the switch from in-person to virtual instruction as happening “so fast.” The COVID-19 pandemic swiftly robbed students of their safety, jobs, opportunities, social connections, and school environment. Students learned to quickly adapt to their new reality, but this transition was not without barriers and struggles.
The initial weeks of virtual learning were filled with confusion and uncertainty as students and faculty adjusted. Students were unsure of classroom expectations because faculty members adapted each class differently.
While adjusting to virtual learning, students also dealt with technical issues, including glitchy Zoom lectures, unstable internet connections, and a lack of Zoom training.
“It’s different having that interaction online versus having interactions in person because online, you either have technical problems, or you’re cutting in and out.
“I feel like some of my peers who usually would be talking and sharing—I see them sharing, but it’s not as much as they would when we were in class. So I feel like that’s a bit of a downfall.”
Students reported mixed experiences in their interactions with faculty during the switch to virtual instruction.
Faculty members who were more active and involved, such as those who maintained frequent check-ins and provided updates about their courses, helped students function successfully in an online environment.
On the other hand, faculty members who were slower to adapt their courses and communicate with students intensified the difficulties students experienced with virtual instruction.
“Even though things developed so fast, I’m glad they told us as soon as they knew what was happening and didn’t wait. But it’s just with my professors—it’s been a little harder. Some of them are really on top of it, and then some of them I’ve basically heard nothing from.”
Students were satisfied with the university’s communication and appreciated updates about current events and institutional plans for the virtual transition during the following fall semester.
Although some students were uncertain about the availability of campus resources, others were grateful for emails explaining resources that were vital or unique to virtual instruction. These included internet hotspots, laptop rentals through the library, and continued virtual access to tutoring and Supplemental Instruction.
“I felt like maybe announcing the hotspots before closing campus or transitioning to virtual would have been very essential. They had to make school virtual, and then they announced that they were giving out hotspots.
“It’s just a matter of—for me, it’s like, ‘Oh, I have internet at home.’ But then I didn’t take into consideration, ‘What if the internet lags? Or what if I have to travel somewhere?’
“I didn’t take that into consideration. So maybe having these essential items available for us and then transitioning us to virtual would have been a lot better, in my opinion.”
Overall, as students adjusted to life during a pandemic, they experienced fear and confusion about what the future would bring. Moving into the fall semester, some issues we heard about during the spring persisted, while new issues emerged.
FALL 2020
“Sometimes you just want to get out of your house because you’re just stuck on the computer all day. So it’s kind of weird because we want to escape school at home. I’d much rather not be in the same place all day. I used to want to escape school, but now I really just want to escape my house.”
As Fresno State continued to operate virtually following the outbreak of the pandemic, students experienced a fully online fall semester for the first time.
In fall 2020, we spoke with 25 students about their continued virtual-learning experiences. From the students’ perspectives, learning from home presented both positive and negative aspects.
On the positive side, virtual learning allowed room for creativity in learning from home and connecting with other students through Discord, breakout rooms, group chats, and other tools. It also involved less commuting, greater flexibility, and opportunities for self-paced learning.
During interactions with their peers, students were willing to exchange contact information and resources. Although classroom interactions were limited, some students used virtual events to connect with others.
Students expressed gratitude for support from the university, professors, and staff because it helped alleviate their stress and concerns to some extent.
Students also found that virtual learning worked best when professors demonstrated empathy, understanding, and flexibility.
“It’s sort of good for some of my professors. I have a professor for marketing, and he’s a really good professor. He’s always available. And he’s not really tech-savvy, but he shows that he’s willing to work with students.
“I feel like that’s really helpful. When I have professors who don’t do that, it’s harder for me because I know they don’t want to help me virtually.”
On the other hand, virtual learning took away irreplaceable in-person learning experiences, including classroom engagement, a set schedule, clear expectations, and human interaction.
Students struggled because virtual learning involved a heavier workload and made it more difficult to collaborate with peers on group assignments.
Course materials were harder to follow because students received less guidance than they did in in-person classrooms, particularly when professors were absent or difficult to contact.
Students also expressed frustration about technical issues and delayed communication from peers and professors.
Freshmen were particularly affected by virtual learning because they had greater difficulty adjusting to college workloads and scheduling while navigating college from home.
“I’ve also had trouble with having to teach myself everything. I’m much better in a classroom, and I like to be able to ask my questions right away.
“With online classes, some of the teachers do their Zooms and then just upload them, so you watch them at your own pace. And that’s kind of difficult because I have questions as I’m watching them.”
The pandemic took a toll on students physically and mentally.
Students were unable to participate in many in-person activities, attend social events, or use the gym and recreation center because of COVID-19 restrictions.
They also had to share their workspaces with other people at home, where it was difficult to find quiet spaces in which to concentrate on school.
Not all students could afford a designated study area or reliable devices for virtual learning, which prevented them from fully dedicating their time and attention to school.
As a result, students demonstrated signs of depression, including feeling isolated, having difficulty keeping up with classes and homework, staying in bed, and wanting to escape their homes and computers.
Many students found it difficult to motivate themselves to study or complete assignments, even when they had never previously been the type of student to procrastinate.
“Yeah, so I’d say my workspace is kind of the opposite—just far from ideal—because I think I mentioned earlier that I was in a really loud house.
“My sister is in school too, and my mom is in online meetings all the time. So half the house I can’t even go to because there will just be people yelling in the background all the time.
“My room is kind of small, and that’s about all I have. So right now, I’m kind of crunched up on my bed. But I guess that’s about it, really.”
Overall, as students continued virtual learning following the spring semester, their fear and confusion turned into defeat and despair. Students expressed distress and hopelessness about their learning progress and their futures.
Throughout a historically challenging year, our students persevered through the challenges presented by the COVID-19 pandemic.
While learning how to be students during a global pandemic, many struggled with their mental health, missing connections with faculty and peers, motivation, technological problems, and sharing physical spaces at home.
Although they faced many challenges, students proved impressively resilient.
They expressed deep appreciation for faculty members who went above and beyond to create connections with their students and for Fresno State’s constant communication during rapidly changing circumstances.
We urge the campus community to continue fostering connections with students and providing more opportunities and resources for mental-health support as we move toward returning to an in-person university experience.
Students repeatedly expressed gratitude during the interviews and focus groups for having a space in which they could be heard and understood. We are grateful to the students who allowed us to give voice to their stories during these unprecedented hardships.
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.