Multiculturalism, Diversity and Gender Issues

A Targeted Analysis of the 2004-05 HERI Faculty Survey

by ChrisTina Leimer
Director, Institutional Research, Assessment and Planning
California State University, Fresno

Executive Summary

With the Diversity Task Force gearing up, full-time undergraduate faculty responses to diversity-related questions on the 2005 Higher Education Research Institute (HERI) Faculty Survey can be used to facilitate discussion. Twenty-two survey questions focused on multicultural, race/ethnicity, or gender issues. Using ANOVAs, T-tests and chi-square tests of independence, these items were analyzed by academic rank, race/ethnicity and gender to examine faculty behavior, experience, perceptions and values related to multiculturalism, diversity and gender issues.

Questions Asked

Values and Beliefs about the Curriculum and Learning

  • How important is enhancing knowledge of race/ethnic groups as an undergraduate education goal?
  • Should racial/ethnic diversity be more strongly reflected in the curriculum?
  • To what extent should Western civilization and culture be the foundation of the undergraduate curriculum?
  • To what extent does promoting diversity lead to too many under-prepared students?
  • To what extent does a racially/ethnically diverse student body enhance the educational experience for all students?

Curriculum in Practice

  • In how many courses does the faculty teach readings on racial/ethnic issues or women’s/gender issues?
  • Has the faculty taught ethnic or women’s studies courses?
  • Has the faculty conducted research or writing focused on international/global issues, racial/ethnic minorities, or women’s/gender issues?

Views About the University Environment

  • Is there a lot of racial conflict here?
  • To what extent is there respect for diverse values and beliefs on campus?

Experience on Campus

  • Have faculty members been sexually harassed at this campus?
  • To what extent has subtle discrimination been a source of stress?

Diversity-Related University Priorities

  • How important is recruiting more minority students?
  • How important is creating a multicultural environment?
  • How important is promoting gender equity among faculty?
  • How important is increasing the representation of minorities and women in the faculty and administration?
  • How important is promoting racial understanding?

Findings

Across academic ranks, the full-time faculty believes that there is little racial conflict on this campus and subtle discrimination is not much of a source of stress. However, women and faculty of color rate subtle discrimination as a higher stressor than do men and white faculty. Faculty of color say racial conflict on campus is more extensive than white faculty do.

Approximately 25% of full-time faculty members have conducted research or written on global/international issues or racial/ethnic minority issues. This is comparable to other four-year colleges and universities.

Sixteen percent of the faculty has written or conducted research on women’s or gender issues, as have a comparable portion of faculty at other colleges and universities.

Twenty-three percent of the full-time faculty has taught racial/ethnic minorities studies, 6.2% has taught women’s studies, and 8.4% has taught ethnic studies. These percentages too are comparable to other four-year colleges and universities.

Associate Professors are more likely to conduct research or write about international/global issues than are the other academic ranks.

Faculty of color are more likely than white faculty to have taught ethnic studies courses.

Women are more likely than men to have taught women’s studies courses, to have conducted research or writing on women’s/gender issues and to have been sexually harassed at this campus.

Women are likely to have included readings on racial/ethnic issues and women’s/gender issues in more of their courses than men have.

Assistant Professors have a greater belief than Professors that diversity should be more strongly reflected in the curriculum. Faculty of color believe this to a greater degree than white faculty do.

Professors believe more strongly than Associate and Assistant Professors that Western civilization and culture should be the foundation of the curriculum. Male faculty members are more supportive of this Western culture orientation than are female faculty members.

Faculty of color and women consider enhancing knowledge of racial/ethnic groups to be a more important undergraduate educational goal than white faculty and men do.

The highest rated issue overall is the belief that a diverse student body enhances the educational experience for all students. Faculty of color and women more strongly support this belief than do white faculty and men.

Promoting racial understanding is more personally important to faculty of color and women than to white faculty and men.

Introduction

With the Diversity Task Force gearing up, full-time undergraduate faculty responses to diversity-related questions on the 2005 Higher Education Research Institute (HERI) Faculty Survey can be used to facilitate discussion. Twenty-two survey questions focused on multicultural, race/ethnicity, or gender issues. Using ANOVAs, T-tests and chi-square tests of independence, these items were analyzed by academic rank, race/ethnicity and gender to examine faculty behavior, experience, perceptions and values related to multiculturalism, diversity and gender issues.

Methodology

The following analysis is based on data collected in the Spring 2005 administration of the HERI faculty survey. The response rate was 29% (N=304). The overall margin of error for the entire sample was 5.7%. The margin of error for the full-time undergraduate faculty subpopulation was 6.7%. The full-time undergraduate faculty (N=213) population is the subject of this study.

As is common, the sample did not adequately match its population (Tables 1A, 1B, 1C). Based on academic rank, gender and race/ethnicity, the full-time undergraduate faculty sample overrepresented full-time Lecturers and women and under-represented Professors. The sample was weighted to match its population.

Descriptive statistics provide the overall picture of full-time faculty on these issues. To determine if there were differences “between” academic ranks on the 16 Likert scale items, One-Way ANOVA was used. The Tukey’s HSD post hoc comparison test distinguished the groups that differed from each other. T-Tests were used on the Likert scale items to analyze differences between genders and racial/ethnic groups. Because the number of respondents in specific racial/ethnic categories of non-white faculty was too small for analysis, the race/ethnicity variable was recoded into “white” and “of color.” To analyze the five binomial variables by race and gender, crosstabulations with Fisher’s exact test and Yate’s corrected chi-square examined independence.

When bivariate tests indicated significant differences by academic rank and gender, or, as was the case with the factor “reflecting diversity in the curriculum,” by academic rank, race and gender, multifactorial ANOVA was used to test for main and interaction effects and to determine the strength of the bivariate relationships when placed in relation to each other in the same model. Only those effects that remain academic rank, gender or race specific, or where interactions exist, are reported as findings.

The following survey items were tested.

Likert Scale items

  • Indicate the importance of enhancing knowledge of race/ethnic groups as an undergraduate educational goal. The scale was 1=Not Important, 2=Somewhat, 3=Very, 4=Essential

Indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with these statements about your university.

  • Racial and ethnic diversity should be more strongly reflected in the curriculum.
  • There is a lot of racial conflict here. The scale for these items is 1=Disagree Strongly, 2=Disagree Somewhat, 3=Agree Somewhat, 4=Agree Strongly

How important do you believe each of these priorities is at your university?

  • Recruiting more minority students
  • Creating a multicultural environment
  • Promoting gender equity among faculty
  • Increasing the representation of minorities in the faculty and administration
  • Increasing the representation of women in the faculty and administration The scale for these items is 1=Low Priority, 2=Medium, 3=High, 4=Highest

Indicate your agreement with these statements.

  • Western civilization and culture should be the foundation of the undergraduate curriculum.
  • Promoting diversity leads to the admission of too many under-prepared students.
  • A racially/ethnically diverse student body enhances the educational experience of all students. The scale for these items is 1=Disagree Strongly, 2=Disagree Somewhat, 3=Agree Somewhat, 4=Agree Strongly

In how many of the courses you teach do you use each of the following?

  • Readings on racial/ethnic issues
  • Readings on women/gender issues Scale: 1=None, 2=Some, 3=Most, 4=All

Indicate the importance to you personally of the following.

  • Helping to promote racial understanding Scale:1=Not Important, 2=Somewhat, 3=Very, 4=Essential

Indicate how well the following describes your university.

  • There is respect for the expression of diverse values and beliefs Scale: 1=Not Descriptive, 2=Somewhat Descriptive, 3=Very Descriptive

To what extent has this been a source of stress during the last two years?

  • Subtle Discrimination Scale: 1=Not at all, 2=Somewhat, 3=Extensive

Binomial Items (Yes/No)

  • Have you been sexually harassed at this institution?

During the past two years, have you engaged in any of the following activities?

  • Taught an ethnic studies course
  • Taught a women's studies course
  • Conducted research or writing focused on international/global issues
  • Conducted research or writing focused on racial or ethnic minorities
  • Conducted research or writing focused on women and gender issues

In this report, numbers in parentheses in the text are mean scores. Where they could be inserted without intrusiveness, they are included for easy reference. Tables at the end of the document provide more statistical detail.

Findings

Among the full-time faculty in general (Table 2A), responses to most of the Likert scale diversity, multicultural, and gender equity questions are centrist. The only items on which responses were near one end of the scale are the extent to which subtle discrimination has been a stressor and the extent to which faculty believe there is racial conflict on the campus. In both cases, scores are at the lower end of the scale indicating that little racial conflict exists and subtle discrimination has not been much of a source of stress.

There are, however, differences between male and female faculty, and white faculty and faculty of color on these issues. Women and faculty of color are likely to rate subtle discrimination as a higher source of stress than do male faculty and white faculty (Table 6A and 5A). Faculty of color rate racial conflict on campus as more extensive than white faculty do (Table 5A).

Approximately 25% of full-time faculty members said they have conducted research or written on global/international issues or racial/ethnic minority issues. Sixteen percent have written or conducted research on women’s or gender issues. (Table 2B) These percentages are comparable to full-time faculty at other four-year colleges and universities (Table 3).

Twenty-three percent of the full-time faculty has taught racial/ethnic minorities studies, 6.2% has taught women’s studies, and 8.4% has taught ethnic studies (Table 2B). These percentages are comparable to full-time faculty at other four-year colleges and universities (Table 3).

There is no difference by academic rank on teaching ethnic or women’s studies, or in conducting research or writing on racial/minorities. However, Associate Professors are more likely to conduct research or write about international/global issues than are the other academic ranks. While 43% of Associate Professors include this topic in their scholarly activity, only 27% of Assistant Professors do, as do 24% of Full Professors and 11% of full-time Lecturers.

As is the case with 13 of the 22 items in this study, there are differences by gender and race/ethnicity. For instance, faculty of color are more likely than white faculty to have taught ethnic studies courses (Table 5B). Women are more likely than men to have taught women’s studies courses, to have conducted research or writing on women’s/gender issues and to have been sexually harassed at this campus (Table 6B). This is true at other campuses as well (Table 3). Although the percentages in the table show that a higher percentage of female faculty members on this campus say they have been sexually harassed than the percentage at other campuses, given the margin of error of this survey it is unlikely that any difference exists between the extent of harassment on this campus and others. Nationally comparative data by race/ethnicity was not provided by HERI.

Table 1A

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Academic Rank

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Academic Rank
  Population Survey Sample FT Faculty Population FT Faculty Survey Sample
2004-05 N % N % N % N %
LECTURER 577 51.70 109 36.1 115 19.0 60 28.2
ASSIS PROF 135 12.10 57 18.9 134 22.1 50 23.5
ASSOC PROF 91 8.15 45 14.9 88 14.5 41 19.2
PROFESSOR 313 28.05 91 30.1 269 44.4 62 29.1
2004 Total 1116 100.0 302 100 606 100 213 100

Table 1B

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Gender

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Gender
  Population Survey Sample FT Faculty Population FT Faculty Survey Sample
2004-05 N % N % N % N %
Female 501 42.2 152 50.2 252 38.7 102 48.1
Male 687 57.8 151 50.2 400 61.3 110 51.9
2004 Total 1188 100 303 50 652 100 212 100

Table 1C

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Race/Ethnicity

Comparison of Faculty Population and HERI Survey Sample by Race/Ethnicity
  Population Survey Sample FT Faculty Population FT Faculty Survey Sample
2004-05 N % N % N % N %
Am Ind 8 0.7% 10 3.3% 3 0.5% 7 3.2%
Asian 102 8.8% 24 7.9% 70 10.7% 19 8.6%
Af. Am. 37 3.2% 6 2.0% 26 4.0% 5 2.3%
Hispanic 110 9.5% 23 7.5% 54 8.3% 15 6.8%
Non-White 35 3.0% 0 0.0% 15 2.3% 0 0.0%
White 860 73.9% 227 74.4% 483 74.1% 167 75.9%
Other 6 0.5% 10 3.3% 1 0.2% 7 3.2%
Unknown 6 0.5% 5 1.6% 0 0.0% 0 0.0%
TOTAL* 1164 100% 305 100% 652 100% 220 100%

 

 

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.